Politics
Articles from Il Foglio •
The De Gennaro case and the paradoxes of the judicial anti-Mafia movement. What we have written
Weak allegations and contradictions. Moral judgements, media verdicts and that media pillory which invariably accompanies the most high-profile investigations. Also involved are magistrates who are attempting to put history on trial. The tragic affair that led to the suicide of the former chief of police encompasses many of these elements
21 NOV 26
Last updated: 02:24 PM
Translated by AI

Weak allegations and contradictions. Moral judgements, media verdicts and that media pillory which invariably accompanies the most high-profile investigations. Also involved are magistrates attempting to put history on trial. The tragic affair that led to Gianni De Gennaro’s suicide encompasses many of these elements. On 16 November, it emerged that the former Chief of Police had been placed on the list of suspects by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office in the investigation into the cover-up of the Via D’Amelio massacre, in which Paolo Borsellino was killed. The Public Prosecutor’s Office had also requested house arrest for De Gennaro and some of his associates, but the judge presiding over the preliminary investigations did not grant it.
An investigation in which, for many, the verdict of guilt was a foregone conclusion, regardless of the evidence that will – or should have – emerged during the judicial proceedings. So much so that Salvatore Borsellino, the magistrate’s brother, says today: “The prosecutors are responsible for incitement to suicide”. Meanwhile, legal expert Giovanni Fiandaca, speaking to this newspaper, adds: “A share of the blame lies with that section of the press which acts as a mouthpiece for the investigations.”
These dynamics and responsibilities have been highlighted in the articles in which Il Foglio has covered the De Gennaro case this week.
These dynamics and responsibilities have been highlighted in the articles in which Il Foglio has covered the De Gennaro case this week.
As Ermes Antonucci has reconstructed, the allegations of obstruction of justice levelled at Gianni De Gennaro by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office are based on a reconstruction riddled with contradictions, conjecture and logical leaps. In the search warrant, the prosecutors present hypotheses lacking adequate evidence as facts, going so far as to make moral judgements and comparisons with Mafia methods, without clarifying what role the former Chief of Police might have played in the cover-up of the Via D’Amelio massacre.
Furthermore,
the order in which the investigating magistrate in Caltanissetta rejected the request for house arrest for Gianni De Gennaro contains a paradox: after having dismantled the prosecution’s allegations of a cover-up, highlighting contradictions and serious investigative shortcomings, the judge once again alludes to a possible ‘control room’ behind the 1992 massacres, without providing any concrete evidence to support this. This is an example of the tendency to turn judicial investigations into historical reconstructions, rather than focusing on establishing specific offences.
the order in which the investigating magistrate in Caltanissetta rejected the request for house arrest for Gianni De Gennaro contains a paradox: after having dismantled the prosecution’s allegations of a cover-up, highlighting contradictions and serious investigative shortcomings, the judge once again alludes to a possible ‘control room’ behind the 1992 massacres, without providing any concrete evidence to support this. This is an example of the tendency to turn judicial investigations into historical reconstructions, rather than focusing on establishing specific offences.
According to Calogero Mannino, a former Christian Democrat minister acquitted after thirty years of legal proceedings, the De Gennaro case was yet another example of a judiciary that claims to put history on trial. In an interview with Salvatore Merlo, Mannino argued that, following the proceedings against Mori and Subranni, the new investigations no longer respond to judicial or political needs, but rather to the anti-Mafia apparatus’s need to justify its own survival: “Investigations are not carried out because a crime has been committed, but because the apparatus must survive,” is the gist of his complaint.
Finally, as Giuliano Ferrara has recounted, the De Gennaro case was yet another example of a quintessentially Italian paradox: those who have fought the Mafia end up being accused of having aided it. It happened to Mario Mori, who arrested Totò Riina, and then to De Gennaro, a key figure in the collaboration with Falcone and Buscetta. This is the result of a drift towards judicial moralism, which claims to combat crime whilst refusing to accept the ambiguities and inevitable compromises inherent in investigative work.


