The flimsy allegations against De Gennaro, amid contradictions, conjecture and moral judgements

The investigation by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office lacks any evidential or even logical basis, yet is rife with defamatory insinuations against the former Chief of Police

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The flimsy allegations against De Gennaro, amid contradictions, conjecture and moral judgements

Gianni De Gennaro (Ansa)

The search warrant issued by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office against former Chief of Police Gianni De Gennaro, who is under investigation for misdirection in connection with the inquiry into the Via D’Amelio massacre, is yet another collection of contradictions, logical leaps, inquisitorial conjectures and moral judgements on the part of the prosecutors. We might as well call it the ‘Nisseno method’ by now, given what has already happened in the case of Gioacchino Natoli and Giuseppe Pignatone, who were torn to shreds by an investigation – subsequently dropped – that should never even have been launched (as the alleged offences were already time-barred), in the case of Senator Roberto Scarpinato, whose conversations with Natoli were intercepted, transcribed and then forwarded to the Anti-Mafia Commission without any authorisation from Parliament, and also in the case of the former deputy prosecutor of the National Anti-Mafia Directorate, Michele Prestipino, who is under investigation for disclosure of official secrets aggravated by aiding the Mafia. Now it is De Gennaro’s turn, another icon of the anti-Mafia world, former head of the Anti-Mafia Investigation Directorate, then of the Police, then of the secret services, as well as a collaborator and friend, at the time, of Giovanni Falcone. There are two main charges brought against De Gennaro by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office, headed by Salvatore De Luca. 
The first charge concerns an alleged “misdirection of testimony”: De Gennaro, together with his long-standing associate Franco Pacetto and Massimo Carnicelli, his personal security officer, is alleged to have persuaded the state witness Salvatore Contorno not to make any statements to the magistrates. The second is a case of “physical obstruction of justice”: De Gennaro, Donatella Peruzzi, an official with the DIS, and Carnicelli are alleged to have concealed paper and digital documents following the searches carried out by the Nissa Public Prosecutor’s Office in September 2023 at the homes of Arnaldo La Barbera’s family members. These are two very serious allegations, but a reading of the search warrant raises many questions about the validity of the reconstructions of events, which are often presented as certainties despite the absence of any evidential or even logical basis (and to think that, in De Gennaro’s case, the prosecutors had requested house arrest, which was rejected by the investigating judge along with all requests for pre-trial detention made for the other suspects).
Regardless of the opacity of the relationship between De Gennaro and Contorno – which certainly warrants further investigation – a clear contradiction emerges regarding the alleged ‘misleading testimony’. On 15 May 2025, when Contorno was summoned by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office, it was Contorno himself who rang Pacetto (a colleague of De Gennaro) and voluntarily informed him that he did not intend to answer questions. “Right, let’s see this magistrate – I’ll tell him to fuck off and that’ll be the end of it,” says Contorno. Shortly afterwards, he reiterates: “Right, I’ll tell them to fuck off and I’ll leave straight away.” The decision not to cooperate, therefore, comes from Contorno himself, without any order or prompting from the person he was speaking to. The associate then states on the record before the public prosecutors that he does not wish to say anything, reserving the right to reconsider later. Yet, on page 53, the prosecution describes the “illegality” of De Gennaro’s interventions – via Pacetto – to induce Contorno to maintain a “pledge of silence” as “almost self-evident”. But what interventions? And what pledge of silence? In that conversation (and in the others), there is no order from De Gennaro, nor does Pacetto suggest to Contorno that he should not answer.
On page 64, the prosecution goes so far as to claim once again that Pacetto was instructed by De Gennaro “to carry out systematic surveillance of Contorno in order to prevent him, should he feel abandoned, from revealing to the judicial authorities the truth about his – at the very least ambiguous – relations with De Gennaro and La Barbera”. However, to attribute to De Gennaro a mandate aimed at preventing disclosures to the judicial authorities, more would be required than simply demonstrating that Pacetto associated with Contorno. Furthermore, the phrase “the truth of his relations” presupposes that there is a truth that has already been identified and that Contorno is capable of revealing it. A “truth”, however, that the Nissa Public Prosecutor’s Office takes for granted, without specifying what it might consist of, thereby fuelling a conspiracy theory that should have no place in judicial proceedings.
Equally numerous contradictions emerge regarding the alleged ‘material misdirection’. In some intercepted conversations, De Gennaro states that he burnt paper documents and retained digital copies, entrusting the storage media to various individuals. These are circumstances that warrant rigorous investigation, but the public prosecutor’s office makes a logical leap when it attributes to those materials a content and significance that it admits it does not know. On page 91, the prosecution writes: “At present, it is not known what documentation was involved.” A few lines later, it claims that those documents were “certainly relevant to the Contorno affair”. On page 94, it describes them as “certainly significant for the investigations and compromising” for De Gennaro.
We are faced with a masterpiece of imagination: how can one be certain of the investigative relevance of documents whose content is unknown? A mystery. Yet the public prosecutor’s office goes so far as to conclude that the entirety of De Gennaro’s activities concerning his personal archive ‘cannot make any logical sense other than to mislead the investigation’. Little and big Torquemadas are on the rise.
More generally, and this is the main shortcoming of the Nissena investigation against De Gennaro, it is impossible to understand what the management of Contorno (who was arrested in 1989 in Palermo following a mysterious clandestine return from the United States and his revelations during the ‘maxiprocesso’) has to do with the misdirection of the investigations into the 1992 Via D’Amelio massacre, which has since been attributed to the group of Carabinieri under La Barbera’s command. The prosecution itself points out that ‘from the trial records and therefore also from the judgement itself (on the cover-up orchestrated by the Carabinieri, ed.), no evidence has ever emerged of De Gennaro playing a leading role in the investigations into the cover-up’. Immediately afterwards, however, the prosecution once again lets its imagination run wild. It cites a conversation in which De Gennaro and Peruzzi discuss the appeal lodged by the prosecution precisely regarding the cover-up trial, emphasising that the tone of the conversation suggested a certain “unease” on De Gennaro’s part. Where the prosecutors perceived this unease is another mystery. But the problem is far more general: even if the concern over a judicial appeal (which does not directly concern him) were true, the prosecution should demonstrate – or at the very least attempt to explain – how De Gennaro was involved in the cover-up or was aware of its mechanisms. None of this is done.
Amidst this flurry of conjecture, fanciful deductions and illogical leaps, what ultimately stands out is the decision – it cannot be described otherwise – by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office to judge certain aspects of De Gennaro’s behaviour using suggestive comparisons of a defamatory nature. On page 62, for example, the Public Prosecutor’s Office writes that De Gennaro, once he became aware of the existence of investigations against him, allegedly ‘took a series of precautions in his communications’, meeting his colleagues outdoors after leaving his mobile phones in the office, using his secretaries as intermediaries and requesting that the most important messages be delivered to him in paper form, via security staff. Indeed, the Nissa Public Prosecutor’s Office goes so far as to state that “the method of communication via paper – that is, the use of sealed notes delivered in person – is highly reminiscent of the communication via ‘pizzini’ that has emerged in the most significant Mafia investigations”. Thus, De Gennaro – a former senior civil servant who played a leading role in the fight against the Mafia in Italy – is, in essence, being accused, incredibly, of adopting Mafia methods.
That is not all. On page 91, the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office comments on a remark made by De Gennaro to Peruzzi: “The only one who could have been questioned told them to fuck off, Totuccio!”. Once again, the Caltanissetta prosecutors set themselves up as moral judges: “Such remarks, uttered by someone who for years was called upon to lead the investigative bodies tasked with the highest level of combating the Cosa Nostra and all other mafias operating in Italy, merit careful consideration as they reveal – contrary to what one would expect from a figure of such high institutional standing – a desire to keep circumstances relating to certain historical periods hidden even today, circumstances which at this stage can only be regarded as fatal for De Gennaro himself, evidently fearing that their coming to light might reveal his role in these events, which in many respects remain obscure”. Faced with this passage, one is led to wonder whether we are talking about a public prosecutor’s office operating in Italy or in Iran.
However, the crux of the matter emerges on page 91 of the search warrant. The prosecutors highlight a specific pattern of conduct by De Gennaro: when he received information from one of his associates, such as Pacetto, he would relay it to another individual close to him, such as Peruzzi, while omitting the source of the information itself. This is enough for the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office to speak of a ‘strategy singularly analogous to that adopted by criminal organisations, which effectively tend to compartmentalise the circulation of information amongst the members of the group’. In short, the prosecutors essentially state that De Gennaro used methods similar to those of criminal and Mafia organisations. Such statements could lead to De Gennaro bringing a defamation claim against the magistrates.
The only thing that is clear at the moment is the travesty of justice perpetrated by the Nissa Public Prosecutor’s Office in its search warrant. This travesty is in line with the work previously carried out by the public prosecutor’s office on the ‘Mafia-procurement’ case, so dear to the centre-right majority and the Anti-Mafia Commission. One wonders how those who describe themselves as ‘defenders of due process’ can fuel this drift, uncritically reporting the prosecutor’s office’s allegations or even praising its work. But as we know, the defence of due process in Italy is blinded by ideology.