"De Gennaro? Investigations aren’t carried out because a crime has been committed, but because the system must survive." Calogero Mannino speaks

The former minister, speaking to Il Foglio: “I was arrested at the age of fifty-five and acquitted for the last time at eighty-one. They put General Antonio Subranni and General Mario Mori on trial; now it is De Gennaro’s turn. These are trials of history, of survivors, of a group of elderly people and of a string of the dead who are being smeared.”

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of "De Gennaro? Investigations aren’t carried out because a crime has been committed, but because the system must survive." Calogero Mannino speaks

Calogero Mannino – photo: LaPresse

“I was arrested at the age of fifty-five and acquitted for the last time at eighty-one,” says Calogero Mannino, who is now eighty-seven. “General Antonio Subranni was declared innocent at ninety, when he was no longer able to rejoice in it. General Mario Mori had the honour of wearing his uniform restored after he turned eighty. Now it is Gianni De Gennaro’s turn, who is seventy-eight years old.” All elderly. “You bet.” What sort of trials are these? “Trials of history, of survivors, of a group of old people and of a string of the dead who are being smeared. Those who could have been accused are no longer here, those who could have known are no longer here, those who should exonerate them are no longer here.” Paolo Borsellino, Giovanni Falcone, Arnaldo La Barbera, Judge Giovanni Tinebra, Giuseppe D’Avanzo, even Totò Riina. They’re all dead. “The old men remain, and they are being held to account for absurd things.” Novels? “We’d need Dumas for that.” And what would you say to De Gennaro today? “He doesn’t need to be told anything. He’s a man who can smile at these things. But his blood – that must have turned to water by now.” And what did you think when you read the news that the public prosecutors in Caltanissetta were seeking the arrest of De Gennaro, a man who for forty years was the face of the state? “I thought back to when I read my own arrest warrant. It seemed madness then, and it seems madness now. But by now I’m immune to it.”
Calogero Mannino speaks with the calmness of someone who has ceased to be surprised and with the irony of someone who has had thirty years to hone it, and his gaze, that of a man well into his eighties, now rests on the request by which the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office sought to place the almost 80-year-old Gianni De Gennaro under house arrest, ‘in view of his age’, the former chief of police, the ‘super-cop’, the man who enjoyed the trust of at least three Presidents of the Republic, under investigation for obstructing the inquiry into the Via D’Amelio massacre – that is, for events that took place over thirty years ago. “I note, however, that the investigating judge has rejected the prosecution’s request, and this is a positive sign. Perhaps, little by little, things are starting to move. The investigating judge is waking up, and not just in De Gennaro’s case. In other cases, he has put up resistance and returned the files to the public prosecutor.” So, is something changing? “Who knows. As far as I’m concerned, the De Gennaro case is already closed. The judge wrote that there is nothing serious and nothing urgent, and the rest will become clear once the documents have been filed. If anything, the question is a different one. What evidence was presented to this public prosecutor to make him act so hastily? He must have formed an opinion, but on what basis? Who knows.”
In 2023, when the trial concerning the negotiations came to a close, the Court of Cassation criticised the judges in Palermo for adopting a ‘historiographical’ approach. Did you feel more like a defendant in a trial or a character in a history book? “A character. I realised that straight away.” Mori, De Gennaro, Subranni, Mannino. Is there a common thread running through all these trials? “Thirty years ago, the common thread was politics. My trial was part of the grand manoeuvre that followed the massacres – namely, the replacement of the political class in Italy. Giulio Andreotti had to be put on trial, and with him, the Christian Democrats.” Those were the years when Luciano Violante, says Mannino, “was training young magistrates”. The very same Violante who, says the former minister, “is now rushing to defend De Gennaro. And that pleases me”. And today, when no one from the First Republic remains? “Now that there are no longer any political reasons for those trials, there is merely a machine that must somehow survive on its own terms. They have set up a mechanism from which some can no longer turn back. Casella’s anti-Mafia machine, so to speak, must justify its very existence, and to justify its existence it must investigate history. But since there is no substance to it, and indeed there are no longer any people to investigate, they investigate the elderly. Those who have not yet died.”
And who can stop this machine? “I don’t know. No one. Perhaps some investigating magistrate who isn’t a fan of Dumas. But I fear that the judicial power of the public prosecutors has been established and legitimised by the sovereignty of the people, by the last referendum. The biggest mistake Giorgia Meloni’s right wing could have made was to undertake a reform without having the strength to push it through in front of the country. It would have been better not to have done it at all. Now that power, having been established, is being exercised. And if nothing else comes along, it is exercised with imagination too.” Historical novels, in fact.
Mannino was perhaps the first character in this novel. He was a Christian Democrat minister. In 1995, Gian Carlo Caselli’s public prosecutor’s office had him arrested on mafia charges, and years later accused him of having initiated negotiations with Cosa Nostra. He has lived through thirty years of Italian history as a defendant, and has emerged unscathed every time. What does an eighty-seven-year-old man do with all the time these trials have taken up? “The bitterness never ends. You accumulate so much of it that you can no longer shake it off. Just think of that poor woman, my wife, forced to go to the prisons in Palermo and Rome, to queue up to see me for thirty minutes through a pane of glass. And I couldn’t touch her face, as much as I needed to. My hands were trembling. Today I feel sorry for De Gennaro, even though he has an ironic and sly nature that protects him.”
In Mannino’s case, the Court of Cassation even denied him compensation for wrongful imprisonment, and now there is discussion of a bill for victims of miscarriages of justice, put forward by the Radicals. “It’s a perfectly fair law.” In all these years, has anyone ever apologised to you? “No.” Then, however, he recalls a lunch in Milan, back in the years when he was on trial in Palermo. “In the room was the Milan public prosecutor, Francesco Saverio Borrelli, the man who had launched Operation Clean Hands. Everyone had recognised me; everyone was looking at me. Borrelli got up from his table and came over to greet me. I couldn’t say a word, I was so overcome with emotion.”