The twists and turns in the De Gennaro case

Thirty-four years after the events, it appears that the public prosecutor’s office is not seeking to target the Mafia, but rather to piece together the story of a particularly tragic affair. Even the scale of the alleged offences – which suggest that De Gennaro was in some way aiding and abetting Mafia interests – seems exaggerated 


17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The twists and turns in the De Gennaro case

(Photo: Ansa)

Gianni De Gennaro, former Chief of Police and former Chairman of Finmeccanica, is under investigation by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office for obstructing the investigation into the Via D’Amelio massacre, which claimed the life of Judge Paolo Borsellino. The Public Prosecutor’s Office had also requested house arrest for De Gennaro and some of his associates, but the judge presiding over the preliminary investigations did not grant it. Essentially, the charge centres on the allegation that De Gennaro attempted to prevent Salvatore Contorno from making certain statements to the judicial authorities and, many years later, concealed and destroyed documentation deemed relevant to reconstructing certain aspects of the investigation.
Thirty-four years after the events, it appears that the public prosecutor’s office is not aiming to target the Mafia, but rather to piece together the story of a particularly tragic affair. Even the scale of the alleged offences – which suggest that De Gennaro was in some way aiding and abetting Mafia interests – seems exaggerated. The charge of obstructing the investigation levelled against De Gennaro does not concern the way in which the anti-Mafia investigations were conducted at the time, but rather the alleged attempt to hinder the investigations carried out by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office in recent years, in particular those relating to the relatives of Arnaldo La Barbera, who are suspected of being in possession of Borsellino’s ‘red diary’.
Misdirection presupposes a deliberate intention to divert investigations, not merely errors, omissions or questionable judgements, and requires particularly solid evidence. Perhaps the prosecution deemed it necessary to allege such a serious offence to avoid the statute of limitations, but in any case, such a grave accusation against senior figures and officials who have led major operations against the Mafia appears to be an attempt to distort the sequence of events as they actually unfolded. Reflecting on any mistakes made in the past can help to prevent them from being repeated, but if criminal proceedings are used as a substitute for reflection, the result is merely confusion, rather than a strengthening of the fight against organised crime.