A wealth tax, whatever form it takes, is a risk. It is far better to tax inheritances

In Italy, every child can inherit one million euros tax-free, and pays just 4 per cent tax on any amount exceeding that. In other European countries, large inheritances are taxed much more heavily. An imbalance that needs addressing (and two advantages)
20 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni (R) and Italian Economy Minister Giancarlo Giorgetti during briefings to the Chamber of Deputies on the forthcoming European Council meeting, Rome, Italy, 22 October 2025. ANSA/FABIO FRUSTACI

Photo: ANSA

The hot topic of the wealth tax is back in the centre-left debate. There is discussion about how to tax the rich, whilst overlooking the main question: how can we reduce taxes for working people? There are three proposals: the CGIL’s proposal, the proposal on the super-rich inspired by Gabriel Zucman, and the reform of inheritance tax. The economic and political consequences vary.
The CGIL is proposing an annual tax on individual net assets exceeding 2 million euros, with marginal rates of 0.883 per cent for amounts between 2 and 5 million, 1.766 per cent for amounts between 5 and 10 million, and 2.649 per cent for amounts over 10 million. This would affect 465,000 taxpayers and generate 26 billion annually. Over three-quarters of the revenue would come from net worth exceeding 10 million. These figures are theoretically plausible, but difficult to implement. It would be necessary to assess unlisted companies, trace ownership of holding companies and trusts, and update property valuations every year.
The CGIL proposes maintaining the tax obligation for 10 years after emigration, but collecting tax on foreign assets would be complicated. Then there is the political issue. Nearly half a million taxpayers include entrepreneurs, professionals and families with property assets that are often illiquid. An annual tax on such a large group would provoke fierce opposition. For the centre-left, this is probably the surest way to lose the election.
The second proposal, inspired by Zucman, provides for a minimum personal tax rate of 2 per cent on very large fortunes exceeding 100 million euros, taking into account taxes already paid. This could be improved because a wealth tax is also payable on assets that decrease in value; therefore, as an alternative, it would be better to tax capital gains accrued even without a sale. A wealth tax on the super-rich is politically much more popular, but in Italy a particular problem arises: according to the Boston Consulting Group, around 3,000 Italians possess over 100 million dollars in financial wealth. The group of individuals with net worth exceeding 100 million euros is limited to a few thousand identifiable people: owners and controlling shareholders of Italy’s largest companies. Their wealth consists of the value of the companies, not of cash on hand. An annual tax of 2 per cent could prompt them to move their residence and holding companies abroad. Factories do not automatically relocate, but corporate control, investment decisions and company headquarters could be moved.
There are calls for an ‘exit tax’, but the problem remains. Italian property remains taxable; shareholdings and financial assets are more difficult to track after moving abroad. An exit tax may discourage relocations, but it does not guarantee future tax collection. A popular proposal could thus encourage the transfer of control of large Italian companies abroad.
There is a third, more reasonable option: reforming inheritance tax. The first advantage is that no new tax is introduced. In Italy, each child can inherit one million euros tax-free and pays just 4 per cent on any amount exceeding that. In other European countries, large inheritances are taxed much more heavily. The second advantage is administrative: assets are valued at the time of transfer, not annually. The one-million-euro exemption per child could be retained, the tax rate on the excess raised to 20 per cent, and property values updated. Simulations indicate initial revenue of over 5 billion, rising to nearly 7 billion by 2032. Tax avoidance through gifts and trusts must be tackled, and payment plans introduced to safeguard the generational handover of businesses. The key question is how to use these resources. We are not proposing additional taxes: we want to allocate them to a structural reduction in personal income tax (IRPEF). With 6 billion, it is possible to lower the rate for the second tax bracket from 33 per cent to 28 per cent. One cannot criticise the Meloni government for having raised the tax burden to historic highs and then propose yet another tax. We must reduce taxes on labour, offsetting the cut by increasing taxation on large inheritances.
Italy taxes labour too heavily and inheritance too lightly: the latter accounts for just 0.04 per cent of GDP in tax revenue, compared with 0.6 per cent in France. This imbalance favours those who inherit over those who build up their wealth through work. It would be enough to move slightly towards what other countries do – without going as far as the level of French inheritance tax – to achieve something useful and perhaps even politically acceptable.