Culture
the comparison •
Salis is worth seven. “L’anti Meloni” who isn’t making a splash in bookshops
The newspapers are taking it seriously, but his book is selling less than half as many copies as D’Alema’s. “Eravamo comunisti” versus “E’ già domani”, and the past beats the future two to one

Photo: ANSA
Massimo D’Alema and Silvia Salis arrived in bookshops a week apart – he on 6 October and she on 13 October. In the week ending 5 November, he sold 2,483 copies, whilst she sold 1,067 – less than half. ‘Eravamo comunisti’ versus ‘È già domani’, and the past beats the future two to one. The veteran leader brings nostalgia to the bookshops – and nostalgia sells – whilst the rising star sells her promise, but people, it seems, are buying it with caution. Is it really possible that the great political phenomenon – the one who is supposed to challenge Giorgia Meloni and take Elly Schlein’s place to lead the centre-left back to victory – has, according to the latest figures, sold a total of 7,190 copies? Not a flop, but not a success either. True phenomena do not need to be announced; you can sense them coming by their scent, like certain summer storms.
In May 2021, Giorgia Meloni was leading an opposition party and published "Io sono Giorgia" with Rizzoli. Ten days later, the book was second in the Nielsen charts; the following week it was number one; and within two weeks, the publisher announced six print runs and 110,000 copies. Bookshops arrived before the ballot boxes. Yet for months, Salis has been portrayed as if she had already made it. In the spring, Bloomberg ran a profile of her entitled “An anti-Meloni emerges in Italy”, and since then the phrase has bounced from newspaper to newspaper like a pinball. Vanity Fair put her on the cover, just as it had done in 2013 with another mayor named Matteo Renzi. Rolling Stone, after seeing her at the Palazzo Ducale, wrote that “she could go anywhere and hold them all together”. And even before the book was published, L’Espresso reported that the delay in its release had thrown the launch of Eravamo comunisti into disarray, as if the autumn publishing season were supposed to revolve around her schedule. And she herself, it seems, already sees herself as a future occupant of Palazzo Chigi.
A small crowd of advisers surrounds Silvia Salis – highly skilled people who know how to make what has been rehearsed in front of the mirror appear spontaneous. But it is not just the newspapers that are paying attention. A few days ago, a phone call did the rounds amongst the leaders of the small centrist parties – those who vie for decimal points and meet at conferences. It had the tone of a confidential conversation and an air of great interest. “Did you know that Salis is registering a party symbol?” Alessandro Onorato heard it said, Ernesto Maria Ruffini repeated it, Franco Gabrielli had it told to him, and the rumour did the rounds of the small archipelago like stock market news amongst shareholders. Whether it’s true, nobody knows for certain. However, the phone call suggests that even they regard the former hammer-throw champion as someone who really does win votes – the woman who, according to many, could one day take Schlein’s place at the helm of the centre-left (or the PD). Then, of course, there’s the bookshop – an old-fashioned, somewhat rough-and-ready place where there are no image consultants or glossy photos, just people who either buy a book or walk straight past. Seven thousand copies, to be precise. Seven. In Italian politics, the number seven has a specific, somewhat melancholic connotation: it is the number associated with the centrists. In 2022, Carlo Calenda and Renzi’s ‘Third Pole’ stalled at 7.8 per cent. It is the significant percentage of those who form alliances, who bring a ministry and a couple of undersecretaries to the table, who are valuable to a coalition but do not lead it. It is not the figure for a prime ministerial candidate. It is not the figure associated with a major political phenomenon. Perhaps, then, the leaders of the smaller parties were right to ring one another, but for the wrong reason. Salis does not appear to pose a threat to Schlein. Rather, she resembles a new tenant in the crowded ‘seven per cent’ block, where Ruffini, Onorato, Gabrielli, Renzi, the Socialists and the Radicals already reside, and where the flats are not exactly huge.
More on these topics
Milano 1982, vicedirettore del Foglio. Cresciuto a Catania, liceo classico “Galileo” a Firenze, tre lauree a Siena e una parentesi universitaria in Inghilterra. Ho vinto alcuni dei principali premi giornalistici italiani, tra cui il Premiolino (2023) e il premio Biagio Agnes (2024) per la carta stampata. Giornalista parlamentare, responsabile del servizio politico e del sito web, lavoro al Foglio dal 2007. Ho scritto per Mondadori "Fummo giovani soltanto allora", la vita spericolata del giovane Indro Montanelli.

