Culture
The analysis •
The real risk of a social media ban that undermines minors’ autonomy
How do we foster responsible, mature citizens? The ban promises to protect young people, but risks turning them into subjects to be monitored rather than citizens in the making. Amidst identity checks, fake accounts and restrictions on social interaction, the crucial question remains unanswered

The announced amendment to the Security Decree prohibits children under the age of 13 from accessing social media. For teenagers aged between 13 and 16, it only permits accounts linked to those of their parents. From the age of 16, it will be possible to open an independent profile. The solution seems straightforward but presents many grey areas. The crux of the matter regarding implementation is clear. Without identification tools, it is impossible to know who is a minor. Invasive tools, however, infringe on privacy. How can control be reconciled with the protection of privacy (remember, this was a priority in the world of yesterday)? The European Digital Services Act already imposes many obligations on platforms. National provisions must comply with the constraints of EU law. The technical problems highlight the fragility of a paternalistic approach. The adjective ‘paternalistic’ is purely descriptive. The ban presupposes that minors are incapable of acting for themselves and that the law must take the place of their autonomy. Is this the best way to teach them to be responsible? There is also an issue that is difficult to sidestep: a provision of this kind has been included in a piece of legislation on security. An educational, social and health issue is being tackled with a predominantly restrictive approach. The risk is that ordinary socialising behaviour amongst adolescents will gradually fall within the realm of illegality, surveillance and transgression. Adolescents also socialise online: it is hypocritical not to recognise that it is precisely there, today, more than anywhere else, that they learn to interact with strangers. An administrative restriction on access is not a criminal sanction. However, it creates a framework in which a young person seeking a space for social interaction becomes a subject to be monitored. Their behaviour will be viewed either as compliance with or a breach of a rule. Public policy must be assessed not only for its protective intent, but also for the proportionality of the restrictions and for the effects on the people it is intended to protect. Instagram and its competitors are now predominantly portrayed as places of exposure to harmful content. Are they really this, first and foremost, more than anything else? Experience should suggest that they are also spaces where teenagers build relationships, explore their own identity and learn to interact with others using contemporary codes of behaviour. Ignoring this dimension means viewing minors solely as vulnerable individuals. They are not yet adults, it is true. However, they should be on the path towards adulthood. If we see only their vulnerabilities, what becomes of that path? A ban risks encouraging the use of fake accounts, false claims, or more dangerous alternatives (hard drugs rather than soft ones, the dark web rather than social media). It transforms the digital experience into a battleground. Since time immemorial, young people have thought that older generations do not speak their language. It would be desirable for the law not to reinforce this view. The fundamental question – one on which almost no one speaks – concerns the model of protection we wish to adopt. The crux of the matter is the relative weight to be given to bans, surveillance, platform accountability and the progressive autonomy of adolescents. Politicians justify this intervention with the aim of regulating the technological power of the web giants. However, the logic of prohibition ultimately ends up regulating young people’s behaviour. Public opinion has focused heavily on the use of social media and how to regulate it. One question has not been asked. How will young people aged between 13 and 16 view these rules? What will they infer about their status as individuals and as citizens? This is not a rhetorical question. Whether a ban on social media fosters civic-mindedness or mistrust of institutions will not be decided by those who drafted it, but by those who are subject to it.
Gilberto Corbellini
Alberto Mingardi