Long live Europe, so far removed from the table of autocracies and scoundrels

Yalta? Who? Not having been to Shenzhen and having been with Zelensky has served as a reminder of the difference between those who allow themselves to be used by autocracies and those who try to defend freedoms. A Europe at a distance from Xi, Putin and Trump isn’t so bad after all
20 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Russian President Vladimir Putin, left, Chinese President Xi Jinping, centre, and US President Donald Trump attend a trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, in Guangdong province, southern China, on Thursday 19 November 2026. (Vyacheslav Prokofyev/

Photo: LaPresse

On the one hand, two dictatorships attempting to use a leader seduced by autocracies to weaken liberal democracies. On the other, democracies trying to defend a democracy under attack from a criminal autocracy. On the one hand, two adversaries of America attempting to drive America further away from its historic allies. On this side, democracies that, having to contend with the strategic distancing of their historic ally, are trying to reorganise themselves to transform potential vulnerability into a new strength. On the other side, three leaders who dream of building a new Yalta, so to speak – a new agreement amongst the world’s great powers to redefine the political boundaries of the planet. On this side, the democracies, faced with the bluff of the new Yalta, are doing their utmost, using every means at their disposal, to prevent the farce of the new Yalta from producing an effect similar to that of Munich in 1938, when a naive leader named Chamberlain, so very much like a certain Donald, went down in history for having tried to build peace not by shutting the mouth of a dangerous crocodile – who was then called Hitler and is now called Putin – but by letting it feast, feeding it territorial concessions, political leniency and plenty of backing down.
The ‘summit of the willing’ organised yesterday in Berlin is not a counter-summit; it is not a response to the three-way, doughnut-shaped meeting organised in Shenzhen, China, by Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump. But there could not have been a better moment to vividly illustrate the difference between two worlds that could not be further apart. On the one hand, the right to attack democracies is being defended. On the other, the right to defend them is upheld. It’s quite simple. Much has been written in recent days, in serious, harsh and apocalyptic tones, to highlight Europe’s grave and worrying absence from that table in China, where the cards for the new world were supposedly being dealt. But Europe, which was not part of that three-way summit – between three champions of illiberal thought – should be proud, rather than disappointed, that it did not do what Trump has done yet again: treat the enemies of the free West as friends – ‘he is my friend’ – and treat America’s allies as adversaries. Of course. The three leaders gathered in Shenzhen, as the Financial Times rightly pointed out, would not have been able to impose a new partition of Europe – and there is no doubt about that – but it is also true that even the implicit recognition of spheres of influence could have destabilising effects on the world, given Putin’s expansionist intentions and Xi’s ambitions regarding Taiwan.
But the real reason why Europe, despite not being at that doughnut-shaped table, was the elephant in the room is one that is directly linked to the commitment shown by European countries – some more, some less – to a miracle called Ukraine. Supporting Ukraine’s defence has enabled Europe to defend itself against Putinist expansionism. Supporting Ukraine’s defence has enabled Europe to stem Trumpian aggression. Supporting Ukraine’s defence has enabled Europe to discover that it is stronger than it often tends to portray itself – a strength that is also reflected in the €90 billion loan already agreed by the European Union to support Ukraine in 2026 and 2027. Supporting Ukraine’s defence has enabled democracies to appear less vulnerable than they are often portrayed. Supporting Ukraine’s defence has given Ukraine the chance to avoid having to accept a settlement based on an unjust peace. Supporting Ukraine’s defence is, at the same time, the reason why Europe – despite not having been at that table yesterday – continued to influence the decisions of those present; indeed, European support helped to embarrass some of the participants, who cannot have been pleased when, a few days ago, Ukraine – to London’s applause – brought down part of the Kerch Bridge, linking Russia and Crimea – a nerve centre of Russian logistics in Crimea, which Putin himself, when inaugurating it in 2018, had hailed as ‘a miracle’ – but it is also what has given Europe a concrete reason to defend our freedoms together. With a thousand hesitations, a thousand waverings, a thousand contradictions, a thousand dangers on the horizon. But with one certainty. The Shenzhen meeting was not a new Yalta – not least because Europe was not there – and it will not be a new Munich of 1938, because Europe is here, after all. There was no new Yalta, nor was there a new Munich, and the fact that Europe was not at that doughnut-shaped table served as a reminder of the difference between a leader of a democracy who allows himself to be used by autocracies to weaken liberal democracies, and democracies that try to defend a democracy under attack from a criminal autocracy.