Politics
Round-table discussions and programmes •
The M5S’s red lines. Baldino reiterates: “No to arms for Kyiv”. Silvestri: “Wealth tax? It’s difficult to implement”
The M5S vice-president: “Sitting at the negotiating table with a smoking gun undermines diplomacy.” Could financial support for Ukraine be the key to reaching an agreement? “We’ll discuss it; I’m confident,” replies Silvestri

Rome. From the ‘improved’ universal basic income to the wealth tax: ‘We agree with the concept, but we have doubts about its feasibility’. Right up to the issue of all issues, Ukraine, which will be discussed again as early as today. “No to arms for Kyiv”. Whilst the broad coalition is divided between round-table discussions, meetings and video calls, Vittoria Baldino and Francesco Silvestri are setting out the Five Star Movement’s red lines. Speaking to Il Foglio, they confirm the key positions – those on which Giuseppe Conte’s team is certainly prepared to engage in debate. But they will not make too many concessions. Starting with the Universal Basic Income, a card that Conte is prepared to play, even for electoral gain. All parties are convinced of the need for a measure to tackle poverty. But there are still reservations about the Five Star Movement’s version. “In recent years, as income has been scaled back and funding cut, poverty and hardship have grown,” states M5S Vice-President Baldino. “The progressive coalition cannot fail to recognise that there is a pressing need: to address the needs of the most disadvantaged. Whilst the middle class is becoming increasingly impoverished.” Yet the Basic Income, at least in its original form, had shown more than a few limitations in the area of active labour market policies, just as some grey areas had emerged regarding who had access to it. Conte himself spoke, not coincidentally, of a ‘revised’ Basic Income. Baldino describes it as ‘strengthened’. And she is convinced that, in the end, all the coalition partners will say yes, aware that such a scheme is indispensable. “I’m glad they agree with us,” smiles the deputy leader, who is also willing to accept a change to the scheme’s name: “Let’s not get hung up on names. We want to help people, which is something we have objectively done – unlike Giorgia Meloni – during the few years we governed in peace and without pandemics.”
Positions on the wealth tax appear to be further apart, at least for now, as was also evident from yesterday’s economic roundtable. Those who attended described it as a ‘frank’ discussion, with a lively exchange between Mario Turco, Conte’s other deputy, and Marco Grimaldi: for Avs, the wealth tax is ‘indispensable’. The M5S – with an unusual alliance with Renzi’s camp – is focusing more on investment income and vast financial wealth than on assets themselves. In fact, in Via di Campo Marzio, there are fears of capital flight abroad. Conte, whilst retaining some reservations, has nevertheless said “yes to a tax on the super-rich”. What was once an almost isolated position, championed by Chiara Appendino, is gaining some ground. “We agree on the concept, on the need for redistribution. However, we have some doubts about the feasibility of the wealth tax. As Conte explained – having studied the dossier whilst Prime Minister – there are risks,” says former group leader Francesco Silvestri. “Those who have more should make a contribution. We are in favour of using the tax system for redistribution, as well as reducing the tax burden, especially for the middle class,” echoed Baldino. But he clarified: “Obviously, this must not undermine the productive sector. ‘Wealth tax’ must not be a term that frightens property owners into thinking the centre-left government wants to dip into their pockets. We are talking about extremely large fortunes. There is therefore a willingness to explore this idea, but whilst assessing a system that is truly sustainable and effective, without publicity stunts or announcements for their own sake.”
The meeting will resume later this morning. However, the Ukraine issue will dominate proceedings even more, with this being the second meeting following last Thursday’s deadlock. The positions are well known, whilst discussions revolve around – more or less creative – formulations and international law. There are calls for envoys and negotiations, “defensive measures” and a “clear break”. And is it even being suggested that financial support, rather than military aid, could be the key to an agreement? “We’ll see, we’ll discuss it,” says Silvestri. He leaves the door open. “But I am very confident.” Baldino, on the other hand, gets straight to the point: “We have received a clear mandate from our grassroots. Continuing to send weapons pushes peace further away. Sitting at the negotiating table with a smoking gun, it seems to me, undermines any diplomatic effort that appears to be underway at the moment. We will then see whether it proves decisive.” Words that, however, might not go down well with the PD, bringing divisions back to the fore. “But when I think of where we were four years ago, in Letta’s time, we’ve made huge strides forward. I’d sign up to ensure the next four years are just as positive. There’s common ground on most of the programme; the issues that divide us,” concludes Silvestri, “are now very few indeed.”
Ruggiero Montenegro
