Tech
The analysis •
Banning something does not mean eliminating it. The risk of banning social media for minors
Restrictions on social media may lead adults to let their guard down, convinced that the problem has been solved, but there is a danger that this could make unauthorised access less secure. A ban is no substitute for the day-to-day choices made by families. The work of Smartphone Free Childhood Italia

Photo by Jay Openiano on Unsplash
The majority is proposing new restrictions on minors’ access to social media. An amendment to the security decree, with Fabio Rampelli (Fratelli d’Italia) as the lead signatory, provides for a ban on children under 13, accounts linked to those of their parents until the age of 16, and independent access thereafter. Platforms will be required to verify age in accordance with procedures laid down by AGCOM. This is an important cultural signal: the institutions recognise the risks that early access to social media poses to young people’s wellbeing and mental health. But how effective can a ban be? The history of prohibition suggests caution. Banning widespread behaviour does not mean eliminating it. This is particularly true amongst teenagers, who are notoriously keen to flout bans.
In Australia, where access to social media for under-16s has been banned since December 2025, a study published in the British Medical Journal found that over 85 per cent of the minors surveyed continued to use the platforms in question. A proportion of them were using fake accounts. A report in The Guardian also describes young people who, by claiming to be of legal age, encountered violent content not intended for minors. The risk is that clandestine access becomes less safe – just as the whisky produced by Al Capone was less safe than that sold legally. There is another risk in ‘common sense’ bans: they reassure the very adults who should be keeping a watchful eye.
Without going as far as speakeasies, in 1972, child-resistant caps for aspirin were made compulsory in the United States to prevent child poisoning. A common-sense measure. Yet, in 1984, the economist W. Kip Viscusi found no statistically significant reduction in aspirin poisoning. One possible explanation? Parents, reassured by the caps, may have paid less attention to where they left their medicines. This is the ‘lulling effect’ – the false sense of security produced by a safety measure. Social media is not a packet of aspirin. But a restriction can lead adults to let their guard down, convinced that the problem has been solved. A ban is no substitute for families’ day-to-day choices.
Smartphone Free Childhood Italia is working on these very issues: it promotes communities of parents who decide together to delay their children’s access to personal smartphones and social media. Saying ‘no’ is easier when you’re not the only one doing so. “We hope that the next step will be public recognition of the role played by these organisations,” explains Lilit Boninsegni, head of Smartphone Free Childhood Italia. “We need digital education campaigns on a larger scale and practical tools to support communities wishing to embark on initiatives such as those promoted by Smartphone Free Childhood. Families cannot be left to face a challenge of this magnitude on their own.” Institutions can support these networks, promote training in schools and demand greater accountability from platforms. But the responsibility for education ultimately lies with families and communities.
There is a more uncomfortable question. Why has the smartphone become the primary space where young people can enjoy autonomy? There, they can meet friends, explore and escape the watchful eyes of adults. If we want to delay their access to it, we must offer real alternatives: playing outside, visiting a park, gradually venturing out on their own, and meeting up without every activity being organised and supervised. We have restricted the spaces of freedom in the physical world to protect children, whilst allowing them to seek independence online. “The paradox?” comments Ilaria Pelati, an educationalist with the Gorilla Association, which promotes outdoor education. “It’s too dangerous to go to school or play in the local park on their own, but it’s fine to explore the internet from the apparent safety of their bedroom.” A ban can dictate when children are allowed to use social media. However, if the mobile phone remains their only space of freedom, banning it will be an uphill struggle. Restoring children’s autonomy, and helping families to guide them, is a challenge that no ban can tackle in our place.