Tech
Editorials •
The demagoguery of the state ban on social media
A form of paternalism that risks exacerbating a real problem. The state must deal with abuse, platforms with their obligations, and parents with their children. The rest is the all-too-convenient illusion of being able to delegate the hard work of bringing up children to the law.

Photo: Getty
The amendment through which the majority seeks to ban social media for under-13s and allow its use up to the age of sixteen only via accounts linked to those of their parents follows a trend that has spread from Australia to Europe: the UK has announced a ban for under-16s, whilst France has attempted a similar measure. The point is that the Australian experiment, at least so far, has not been a success. After three months, 81.5 per cent of young people were still using the restricted platforms, down from 85.9 per cent previously. Moreover, the proportion of parents unaware that their children were using social media had risen from 23.3 per cent to 33.3 per cent. A fine result, for a law designed to protect them.
The problem lies in the idea that, to combat the dangers of a tool, one must ban the tool itself. It would be like banning schools to put an end to bullying. If social media spreads hatred, violence and illegal content, platforms must be obliged to remove such content promptly. If certain algorithms encourage compulsive behaviour, action should be taken to address those mechanisms. But what is the point of thinking we can save them from the digital environment by banishing them from it? As The Economist pointed out, bans may drive them towards clandestine accounts or less regulated platforms, thereby also depriving them of opportunities for information, social interaction and knowledge. There is also another paradox: in order to verify whether someone is thirteen or sixteen years old, we risk normalising new, invasive identification systems, involving documents, facial recognition and the collection of personal data. More surveillance in the name of protection. And, above all, more state paternalism to avoid the real issue. Who puts a smartphone in a child’s hand? If the problem is the time spent in front of algorithms, should we also ban online videos, or perhaps we should ask parents to actually act like parents? The state must deal with abuse, platforms with their obligations, and parents with their children. The rest is the all-too-convenient illusion of being able to delegate the hard work of bringing up children to the law.