Politics
not just the M5S •
Opponents of the wealth tax. From Renzi’s ‘no’ to Magi: ‘The priority is to cut taxes’. Onorato: ‘Risk of an own goal’
Negotiations on the tax on the super-rich continue, following the clash between Avs and M5S. Concerns are once again being raised by the centrists, who also fear a media backlash. Maraio: “Do not fuel social hatred.” And Ruffini has submitted a “brief” to the broad coalition talks setting out his observations. A new round of in-person talks on Ukraine is due to take place today.

Matteo Renzi, with Italia Viva, has long made no secret of his reservations. Riccardo Magi adds: “The priority is to cut taxes”. Enzo Maraio is also of the same mind, arguing that the issue of inequality must be tackled “without fuelling social hatred”. Then there are the doubts of Alessandro Onorato, who fears a media backlash: “It could be an own goal”. Ernesto Maria Ruffini also expresses scepticism. Those opposed to the wealth tax are witnessing an increasingly heated debate characterised by clashes – AVS versus Giuseppe Conte – and ultimatums. Meanwhile, Meloni has an easy time of it in jumping into the controversy: “Their only solution is to tax wealth.”
They speak to Il Foglio and explain the position their representatives have put forward at the economic talks. Yesterday morning there was a meeting at which an agreement was reached on artificial intelligence. Another meeting was scheduled for yesterday evening (but was subsequently postponed due to other parliamentary commitments), to seek a compromise – no easy task – on the wealth tax, without which, in the words of Fratoianni and Bonelli, ‘there is no coalition’. And today the sherpas will meet again. Raffaella Paita is representing IV at the talks. Over the last few days, the senator has said it time and again, on TV and in the newspapers: “I am working to ensure there is no wealth tax; I believe taxation in this area is already excessive”. For Renzi’s supporters—who have found themselves playing off their arch-enemy Conte—the priorities lie elsewhere: protecting the middle class and young people, and reducing the tax burden through other means. A tax on the super-rich is the last thing on their minds.
There is broad consensus amongst the centrist parties on this point. “In our view, the priority for a progressive and reformist government is to reduce taxes on labour, with a specific focus on certain groups.” Which ones? “Young people, to try to tackle the exodus of young people,” replies the leader of +Europa. And where will the resources come from? “They can be raised through a more progressive tax system and a slightly higher tax burden on unproductive capital”, says Magi. With one caveat: “But for every extra euro in wealth tax, there must be one euro less in taxes on labour, and without increasing public spending. Then we need the legalisation of cannabis, a genuine wealth tax on drug-trafficking organisations. This would allow us to raise several billion in additional revenue”. Then there are Ruffini’s ‘submissions’. The former director of the Revenue Agency and current leader of Più uno is convinced that no new taxes are needed; if anything, work needs to be done on personal income tax (IRPEF) and on combating tax evasion. He has also set this out in a document submitted to the broad coalition’s negotiating table. Alessandro Onorato is also among the ranks of the critics. “I am opposed to the media narrative surrounding the wealth tax; it could be an own goal: everyone, starting with those on low incomes, feels that they would be the ones affected,” says the leader of Progetto Civico. “First, we must make those who do not pay taxes actually pay them – both tax evaders and, above all, foreign multinationals that generate revenue in Italy, use our data and our infrastructure, yet pay their taxes in other countries. It is unacceptable.” And so, Onorato turns the argument on its head, “we must be the patriots; today there is unfair competition against Italian companies. If we have the courage to do this, we would recoup at least 5 billion in tax avoidance every year. Then – and we’re discussing this at the negotiating table – we can consider a solidarity levy from a very small percentage of the population. It wouldn’t be a problem, especially if we make it clear straight away what this money is for: I would rebuild all Italian schools, 50 per cent of which don’t even have a gym today.” Onorato also raises the issue of income tax brackets: “It is unacceptable that someone earning 50,000 euros a year should pay the same tax rate as someone earning 2 or 10. We need a higher tax rate that complies with the provisions of our Constitution. This is not the case today.”
Finally, Maraio, from the PSI. “The proposal for a wealth tax had the merit of sparking a debate. Now we must steer it towards the fundamental issue: how to reduce inequalities and create the conditions for growth. We propose, for example, to draw instead on the windfall profits of banks and insurance companies.” Because, as the socialist explains: “It is not enough simply to redistribute; we must create the conditions for development, without fuelling social hatred and divisions. The left,” he concludes, “must not limit itself to talking only about taxes – that risks being misleading – but must aim to truly shift the balance, combining economic and social justice”. Notes for the programme, for the next round of talks. Among today’s topics is also foreign policy. But this time it will be in person.
