Politics
tensions and twists •
From Kyiv to the budget: the table is wobbling. Fratoianni & Bonelli vs Conte: “Without a wealth tax, there will be no coalition”
On the broader front, discussions on Ukraine are still ongoing, with no significant progress. But it is the tax on the super-rich that now threatens to derail the negotiations. Following a day of internal controversy, 18 joint amendments have been tabled. The allies’ suspicions regarding the M5S leader

In the middle of the afternoon, Nicola Fratoianni spoke to reporters in the Transatlantico. He vented his frustration: “Without the wealth tax, there’s no coalition.” It was a message directed at Giuseppe Conte, who has been putting a spanner in the works regarding the tax on the super-rich. There are many unresolved issues, starting with Ukraine, and the words of the AVS leader serve as a barometer for a day of renewed tensions within the broad coalition, in which even the package of joint amendments to the budget bill risks falling through – the M5S has threatened to withdraw its signatures.
Early in the morning, proceedings begin with the Kyiv talks: the group leaders, the ‘sherpas’, have breakfast via video call in an attempt to make some progress. Some are smoking a cigarette, whilst others, such as the Democrat Alessandro Alfieri, have to join from Turkmenistan, where he is on a mission. The connection suffers a little as a result. The new development is that work is being carried out on a written outline – a draft document – on which, however, there will be a great deal of work to do. And indeed, the working group will meet again on Thursday. Riccardo Magi says we are ‘on the right track’. But the feeling among many is that the M5S is in less of a hurry than Avs and the PD, which is trying to explore avenues for compromise. Progress has been made on Europe and on military spending. Joint work in Parliament on Palestine has also already borne fruit. But as we read in the notes of one of the sherpas, ‘there are still problematic aspects’. These are precisely those concerning Kyiv: on the one hand, ‘support for Ukraine’ and for the resistance is shared by all. On the other hand, there is the far more thorny issue of the wording. This is where internal party balances come into play, but above all the primaries. The ‘clear break’ from Meloni’s foreign policy, a new diplomatic role, and an EU envoy for peace (Conte favours Antonio Costa) form a basis. But that is not enough. And indeed, the issue will be discussed again and again until the leaders find a solution as to what it means to support Kyiv. Sources within the PD are letting it be known, once again, that ultimately financial support will be the route on which agreement is reached. This had been suggested long before the current crisis by Avs. But it does not sit well with IV, for example, and fails to convince the other centrist parties at the table. Nor, though for different reasons, does the Five Star Movement (M5S) like it: “Nothing changes if they then use that money to buy weapons,” cuts short one of Conte’s loyalists. The allies’ fear remains the same: that alongside its legitimate positions, the M5S wants to keep its hands as free as possible ahead of the election campaign. To set itself apart. This is also why it is putting up a fight against the wealth tax, which has suddenly become the issue that risks derailing the whole process – even more so than foreign policy – to the extent that Fratoianni raises the tone and, later, Bonelli also intervenes, echoing his colleague, to say that “without the wealth tax, there’s no point in holding primaries”. Today, the economic working group will also resume discussions with AVS – which has the backing of the PD – as they go on the offensive, armed with studies, polls and proposals to flush out Conte. In short, tensions could rise, along with suspicions regarding the M5S. Yesterday, the M5S even threatened to backtrack on the joint amendments: according to sources in Via di Campo Marzio, Renzi’s supporters are said to have rejected the idea of using windfall profits to cover the costs. A version of events that IV rejects outright. Fratoianni explains once again: “The amendments? A matter that was never even on the table.” In short, the prevailing view within the PD and AVS is different: the M5S did not take kindly to recent headlines about the Conte-Renzi alliance – from healthcare to the wealth tax – and decided to send a signal to break this narrative. In the end, the issue was resolved, but the discontent on the left remains and will shape future discussions. Ultimately, the centre-left tabled 18 joint proposals (whereas the individual parties have put forward thousands), funded – as PD group leader Chiara Braga explains – in part by ‘energy windfall profits’. But not those from banks or arms manufacturers, as the M5S would have preferred. Yesterday morning, the former prime minister had laid down the line for his voters: “Vote for whoever you think is best placed to beat Meloni, not your party leader.” He then expressed the hope that the polling stations would be, for the broad coalition, “a celebration, to be tackled as a team. Otherwise, we’ll be left with nothing but rubble’. Then the day took a different turn, one marked by controversy. In the evening, Conte spoke again, presenting his book at Roma Tre University. He called for ‘primaries in early February’ and explained that the choice of ‘progressive values is irreversible’. That may well be the case, but between ultimatums and some acrimony amongst allies, the table is now wobbling. And today it all starts again.
