The PD and the temptation of a wealth tax

For Schlein, taxes are never the problem, but always the solution 

17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The PD and the temptation of a wealth tax
A few months ago, Romano Prodi summed up the issue as follows: “A wealth tax would be a marvellous thing, but it cannot be done, so it is a bad idea”, because “when it comes to taxes, the right wins”. But Elly Schlein, evidently, did not wish to follow the advice of the only centre-left leader to have won a couple of general elections, and has returned to proposing a wealth tax. Not in the ‘very hard’ version proposed by the CGIL, which aims to tax wealth exceeding 2 million euros to raise 26 billion, nor in the ‘hard’ version proposed by the AVS, which sets the threshold at assets above 5.4 million with an estimated revenue of 16 billion, but in a ‘soft’ form: a 2 per cent rate on assets exceeding 100 million to raise around 8 billion.
It is the Italian version of the Zucman tax, named after the French economist who devised it. The timing is not ideal, given that a similar proposal has just been rejected in a referendum in progressive California – right in the midst of the ‘blue wave’ that swept Trump aside – and even in France, where the tax is backed by Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s far left, it does not seem to have much of a future. In any case, the PD’s problem is not the measure itself – which would raise around 8 billion, affecting a few thousand ultra-wealthy taxpayers – but the perception that accompanies it, as highlighted by Prodi: namely, that the left is the party of taxes. The fear, therefore, is that we will start with the ‘Scrooge McDucks’ but then end up with the ‘Ducklings’.
This is also because the PD’s definition of ‘rich’ varies considerably, depending on the tax measures in question. It is by no means a definition that applies to billionaires. With regard to the measure, contained in the Budget Bill, which extends the income bracket to which the 33 per cent tax rate applies (instead of 43 per cent) from 50,000 to 55,000 euros, the PD secretary’s criticism is: “They’re helping the rich”. Indeed, it is true that this tax cut – with a maximum benefit of 500 euros per year – mainly favours those on higher incomes, but this accounts for around 6 per cent of taxpayers who pay around 40 per cent of personal income tax. They are the hardest-pressed citizens in the country, as few others are anywhere in the world.
One can understand the left’s opposition to extending the flat tax to incomes of up to 100,000 euros, both for reasons of horizontal tax equity and for reasons of political expediency, given that VAT-registered self-employed individuals predominantly vote for the right. However, it is harder to grasp the opposition to reducing personal income tax (IRPEF) for those earning over 50,000 euros (from 2,500 euros net per month upwards), since – in a political paradox – these taxpayers are predominantly PD voters: employees, middle managers, executives and pensioners with a medium-to-high level of education (according to a recent Youtrend survey for Il Sole 24 Ore, the PD is the leading party among voters with high socio-economic status, whilst FdI is the leading party among those with medium-to-low status).
But things did not turn out much differently with the other proposals to cut personal income tax (IRPEF), which affected the middle class. Last year’s Budget Bill provided for a two-point cut – from 35 to 33 per cent – in the tax rate for the income bracket between 28,000 and 50,000 euros, and the PD’s reaction was the same: “The Meloni government’s income tax cut is a gift to the wealthiest,” said Schlein. “The Meloni government is handing out billions to the highest earners: the rich get more, the poor are left behind,” commented Francesco Boccia, leader of the Democratic Party senators. The “rich”, in this case, were workers earning €1,800 a month or more. When, the previous year, the government intervened on even lower incomes, merging the first tax bracket up to 28,000 euros with a 23 per cent rate (thereby eliminating the 25 per cent rate), the PD’s reaction – which certainly could not claim that this was a gift to the “rich” – was nonetheless one of opposition: “We are calling for those 4.3 billion to be channelled into the public health service,” said Schlein. But the surreal aspect is that, in those very same months, the PD was denouncing the harmful effect of fiscal drag on personal income tax payers, whilst at the same time opposing the measures through which the government was returning to them the windfall from that fiscal drag.
The same approach applies to other taxes such as motor vehicle tax, a regressive wealth tax that hits the poorest hardest: when the government approved the abolition of the tax on small and medium-sized cars in September, the PD reacted by calling it an ‘electoral ploy’. Similarly, even when the government increases taxes on specific sectors – as is the case, for example, with banks and the energy sector – the PD’s criticism is that Meloni has done too little: ‘extra profits’ must be taxed more heavily. It is no coincidence that the only government measure in this budget to have received the PD’s approval is the introduction of a new tax: the ‘exit tax’.
Whether it be income tax (IRPEF) for middle-to-high or middle-to-low earners, the extension of the flat tax, a wealth tax on the poor such as vehicle tax (or even the Rai licence fee), or taxes on corporate profits, the PD has always taken a stand against reducing the tax burden. The paradox is that whilst the Meloni government has raised the tax burden to 43 per cent during this parliamentary term – a record high for the last ten years – a large section of the electorate, already disgruntled at being squeezed like a lemon, fears that things could get much worse should the broad coalition emerge victorious.
Many on the left are wondering how it is possible that the poor and the middle class in Italy do not look favourably upon candidates proposing a tax that affects the 0.1 per cent of the population who possess multi-million fortunes: the problem is not the wealth tax on the ‘ultra-rich’ per se, but everything else.