The resistance of those students who march to the beat of their own drum and tear down the barricades

The protests have explicit targets (the government and the world) and a closer, implicit one: fellow students. The protest against those who have turned protesting into a profession

20 NOV 26
Translated by AI
The resistance of those students who march to the beat of their own drum and tear down the barricades
From the days of May 1915, when they were calling for Italy to enter the war, to the rallies of the 1970s, where the Red Brigades were glorified, professors and students shouting the same slogans are a harbinger of the worst. In recent weeks we have seen them again, protesting together against the uncertainty of the future (as if there were such a thing as a certain future), cuts to education, rearmament, Israel and Zelensky. There are valid reasons in this melting pot too. The cuts, for example. However, when everything and everyone is targeted, distinguishing the wheat from the chaff becomes impossible. Fortunately, in every flock there are a few black sheep. From Patrizia De Grazia, the radical from Turin who went on hunger strike to reopen the occupied university, to those in France attempting to dismantle the barricades, a new form of student dissent is emerging. It is protest against protest, a challenge to the ‘collectives’ that run rampant on university campuses, claiming to speak on their own behalf and that of others. In Tours, the blockades have even forced the postponement of the student representative elections.
No one denies the right to protest. But there is also the right to study without protesting. The occupations have explicit targets – the government and the world – and a closer, implicit one: fellow students. The difference is that the minister is not barred from the lecture theatre, whereas fellow students are. It is a curious way of challenging authority by harassing those who have none. True rebellion, then, is that of those who do not bow to those who have turned rebellion into a profession – a blind, conformist, violent Pavlovian reflex. The few who stand tall are already paying the price for their dissent. De Grazia took part in a discussion on the war with Alessandro Barbero at the Einaudi Campus. The debate descended into a row and, in the end, fifty activists surrounded her and called her a ‘Nazi’ for her support for Ukraine. Things aren’t any better in France either. In La Rochelle, a student tried to clear the way into the university by moving the rubbish bins being used as barricades. Since then, he has been receiving death threats every day. And what are the academic authorities doing? I am not aware of any words of solidarity towards those who are standing their ground. On the contrary, faced with these abuses of power, the vice-chancellors are backing down and merely moving lectures online. So those who wish to study must fight on two fronts: resisting the occupiers and calling on the institutions not to give in to bullying. It is a difficult position, which highlights the true value of the solitary courage of these non-conformist students. Each of whom can say: ‘Etiamsi omnes, ego non.’
Umberto Eco wrote that the twelve professors who, in 1931, refused to swear allegiance to fascism saved the honour of the Italian university. Today, it is the students who say no who are defending the honour of the European university.