The rifts between the PD and the organisation

Fiano, Picierno, Furlan, Chinnici, Cottarelli and the others. The defections from the PD conceal painful stories of marginalisation. Anti-Semitism, due process, Ukraine, alternative agendas to Landini’s. What is the ‘minority vocation’ of Schlein & Co.?
19 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Elly Schlein at the Democratic Party’s National Assembly at the La Nuvola Conference Centre, Rome, on Sunday 18 October 2026 (Photo: Roberto Monaldo / LaPresse)Elly Schlein during the Democratic Party’s National Assembly, Rome, Sunday, October

Photo: LaPresse

Emanuele Fiano’s departure from the Democratic Party was met by his former party with the same moral indifference with which the PD yesterday chose to vote against a bill aimed at making the fight against anti-Semitism more effective. The bill in question, as anyone who has had time to read the text will have noticed – and as anyone who has not allowed their mind to be clouded by pro-Palestinian extremist propaganda will have realised – is entirely harmless; one might even say it is minimal, and does nothing more than adopt a definition from the IHRA, the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, as a reference for recognising and combating antisemitism (it will still be possible to criticise Israel). Fiano’s departure is significant for what it reveals, and it does not take much to realise that the fact that Fiano – whose political commitment to combating antisemitism also stems from a unique personal history (his father was deported to Auschwitz and was the sole survivor of his entire family) – his departure signals how high a priority the fight against anti-Semitism currently is within the party (fanning the flames of hatred against Israel, demonising it and applying double standards is, within the centre-left’s agenda, more important than defending Jews at all costs, in defiance of anti-fascism).
However, the shrugs that accompanied Fiano’s departure are part of a wider context. A context that reveals a PD so uninterested in nurturing its vocation as a majority party that it has chosen to observe the repeated defections recorded in recent years without asking itself a crucial question: what is the PD stripping away from its identity? The stories of those who have left the PD, from February 2023 to the present day – that is, since Elly Schlein took the helm of the party – are very different from one another, but when placed side by side, they allow for a powerful reflection on the policy of exclusion pursued, in a stubbornly uniform manner, by the PD leadership. Emanuele Fiano’s departure bears witness to the PD’s lack of interest in the fight against anti-Semitism. Pina Picierno’s departure highlights the PD’s ambiguities regarding its defence of Ukraine. The departure of Caterina Chinnici – a Member of the European Parliament, former magistrate and daughter of Rocco Chinnici – and that of Elisabetta Gualmini, former vice-president of the Emilia-Romagna region, highlight the PD’s ambiguities on the issue of due process. The departure of Carlo Cottarelli, a former PD MP, highlights the PD’s limited ability to be seen as a bulwark against populism on economic matters. The departure of Annamaria Furlan, former secretary of the CISL trade union, who moved to Italia Viva following a dispute over workers’ participation in corporate governance, highlights the PD’s inability to stand by workers without simultaneously hindering policies that could help them find employment; indeed, it is no coincidence that Furlan left the PD even after the party chose to betray its history by backing the abolition of the Jobs Act via a referendum. There have been numerous defections from the PD in recent years, at both local and national levels.
Not all of these instances, from the perspective of individual stories, may have posed a problem in terms of personal approval ratings. Yet a significant proportion of these positions, including that on Fiano, point to a series of issues on which the PD has chosen to stand aside, to retreat, shifting towards a protest-oriented position – at times overlapping with that of the M5S – thereby providing a practical demonstration of a problem that goes beyond the desire to combat anti-Semitism (a concept which, in theory, we believe is a left-wing one), beyond the desire to be a guardian of due process (a concept which, in theory, we believe is a left-wing one), beyond the desire not to regard adherence to the CGIL’s agenda as the only way to protect workers, and beyond the desire to regard the defence of Ukraine as an issue that cannot be sacrificed on the altar of alliances (a concept which, in theory, we believe is a left-wing one). Over the last few years, the main objective of the centre-left – and indeed that of the PD – has been to act with the primary aim of protecting their own vested interests.
It remains unclear whether the PD has succeeded in this, as it pursues a left-wing electorate whose very existence is uncertain; while we await an assessment of what the party has gained by dismissing those who have left in recent years, it is clear what it has lost: its focus on the fight against anti-Semitism, the centrality of due process, the battle against trade-union populism, and the priority of defending against Putinist fascism. Every departure has a story. Each departure has consequences. The most evident consequence so far is that it has helped hand over to the right battles that once belonged to the left, contributing to making the right appear more moderate than it actually is. Will it work? Good luck, and long live the anti-Semitism bill – a bulwark against an old, somewhat fascist tendency that tended to regard the defence of Jews against those who considered them guilty simply for being Jewish as entirely secondary.