World
A little less Brexit •
British Prime Minister Burnham takes three steps towards the EU – the only ones possible at present
The agreement with the European Union provides for improvements for London. The desire to return and its limitations

Photo: ANSA
Brussels. Andy Burnham’s first EU–UK summit was meant to be a ‘reset’, with a ‘historic’ agreement to bring the two sides of the Channel closer together ten years after the Brexit referendum. Instead, the meeting between the British Prime Minister and the two leaders of the EU institutions, António Costa and Ursula von der Leyen, demonstrated once again just how difficult it is to undo Brexit and its damaging effects. Three agreements were announced on youth mobility, the alignment of carbon markets and phytosanitary controls. However, these will not be signed until the UK agrees to lower tuition fees for EU students. Burnham made it clear that, during the current parliamentary term, he will not be able to take the UK any further in its rapprochement with the EU. The most he can do is engage in “brainstorming”.
In words, both the European Union and the United Kingdom want to put Brexit behind them, particularly the ‘hard’ version chosen by the governments of Theresa May and Boris Johnson following the 2016 referendum. The President of the European Council, António Costa, welcomed Burnham with these words: “Dear Andy, you are always welcome in the EU”. Burnham described the moment as “historic”, thanks to a “win-win” agreement. The Labour leader explained that “the status quo isn’t working”, “it isn’t working well enough for the UK”, where “there has been a decade of drift, too many divisions, low economic growth and higher prices in shops”. A clear majority of Britons want “a better deal than a hard Brexit”, said Burnham.
The deal concluded today brings some improvements for the UK. The agreement on plant health checks will allow British agri-food businesses to export to the EU without having to undergo the strict checks introduced following Brexit. Burnham emphasised the benefits for ordinary people’s cost of living. The agreement “will help ease the pressure on prices” in supermarkets, said the Prime Minister. “The agreement could add up to 0.9 per cent to the UK’s GDP. It is a £17 billion boost, the largest single measure to support growth that we can take in this parliamentary term,” Burnham emphasised. The British Prime Minister, like von der Leyen and Costa, stressed the importance of youth mobility. Both sides have committed to welcoming 100,000 young people under the age of 31, who will be able to live, study and work in each other’s territories for three years. “It is our duty to open up new opportunities for them,” said Costa. “This agreement is for you,” said Burnham: “You will have a new freedom.” In reality, it is one of the freedoms taken away by Brexit.
Yet, despite the conclusion of negotiations and the positive atmosphere at the summit, the three sectoral agreements will not be signed unless other disputes are resolved. The main one concerns the abolition of tuition fees for EU students moving to the UK, or at least equal treatment with British students. Burnham did not have the courage to confront the Brexiteers and sceptics within his own party over a measure that would impose an additional cost on the UK budget. In the end, the two sides decided to postpone the issue of tuition fees for six months, leaving the three sectoral agreements on hold in the meantime.
The dilemmas of Brexit have resurfaced in relation to phytosanitary controls. Integration into the EU always entails a surrender of sovereignty and a financial cost. With regard to phytosanitary controls, the UK will have to continually align its legislation with that of the EU. Burnham secured a symbolic concession: the possibility of being consulted in the event of phytosanitary emergencies or crises, but without any ability to influence EU decisions that will also apply to the UK. Furthermore, if a future British government were to renege on the phytosanitary agreement, it would be forced to pay the costs incurred by the EU in restoring border controls.
Burnham acknowledged that “incremental steps only take us so far”. But for the UK to rejoin the single market or the customs union would mean becoming a legislative colony of the EU. Full membership of the EU is unthinkable for the time being. The EU has welcomed Burnham’s decision to launch a national dialogue on relations. “I very much welcome the willingness to have a broader debate on the UK’s future choices,” said the Commission President. “Today’s Britain and today’s EU are not the same as they were in 2016. Life has moved on in so many ways. We could never have imagined some of the things that have happened over the last decade,” said Burnham. But today’s agreement marks “probably the limit of what we can achieve in this parliamentary term”. Thus, for next year’s EU–UK summit, Burnham has settled for proposing a “brainstorming session” on options for long-term relations.