Second loan. For Kyiv, the EU’s common debt (including perpetual debt) is not a taboo subject

Ursula von der Leyen’s Commission has proposed a new loan of 45 billion to cover Ukraine’s budget shortfall in 2027, following the 90 billion loan approved at the start of 2026. The proposal stipulates that the EU will pay the interest on behalf of Kyiv
19 NOV 26
Translated by AI
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen arrives for the weekly College of Commissioners meeting at the EU headquarters in Brussels, Belgium, on Wednesday 18 November 2026. (AP Photo/Omar Havana) Associated Press/LaPresse Only Italy and Spain

Photo: LaPresse

Brussels. The European Union is capable of extraordinary decisions when it has exhausted all other options and faces an existential threat. For the second time in a year, leaders will resort to joint borrowing to ensure that Ukraine does not go bankrupt, leaving it without the funds to survive as a state and defend itself against Russia’s war. Yesterday, Ursula von der Leyen’s Commission proposed a new 45-billion loan to cover Kyiv’s budget shortfall in 2027, following the 90-billion loan approved at the start of 2026. In both cases, the chosen instrument is joint debt: the Commission borrows on the markets, using the EU budget as collateral, to finance loans to Ukraine. There are precedents for Eurobonds in extraordinary crises: SURE and NextGenerationEU during the Covid pandemic, or SAFE for the rearmament plan. The ‘frugal’ states, who denounce joint debt as the ultimate evil, are prepared to resort to it for Ukraine. Even though it is set to become perpetual debt and European taxpayers will have to shoulder 40 billion euros in interest over seven years.
The Commission’s proposal on the new loan came on the eve of the summit between Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin, which some fear could turn into a ‘Yalta 2.0’ to the detriment of Europe. “We believe this is the best way to give Ukraine a strong hand at the negotiating table,” von der Leyen explained yesterday. It is a sign of the EU’s determination not to abandon Kyiv should Trump and Putin reach an agreement. Today, the leaders of the coalition of the willing will meet in Berlin. Next week, the Commission will present the twenty-second package of sanctions against Russia. Heads of state and government will discuss the 45 billion loan to Ukraine at the extraordinary summit at the end of the month, when they will also discuss the new budget for 2028–34. The aim is to reach an agreement on both at the European Council in mid-December. However, several obstacles remain before the second loan to Ukraine and the EU budget can be approved.
The Commission’s proposal provides for the EU to pay the interest on Ukraine’s behalf. Between the first loan of €90 billion and the second of €45 billion, this amounts to approximately €40 billion for the period 2028–34, according to estimates based on current interest rates. There is no other option. If the burden were to fall on Kyiv, Ukraine’s budget would become unsustainable and the country would lose further aid, such as that from the International Monetary Fund. The Commission is trying to conceal the direct costs. The proposal stipulates that the interest could be covered by profits made on frozen Russian assets. The problem is that those resources (between 4 and 6 billion a year) are already being used to repay another 45-billion loan granted by the G7 in 2024. It will take years to repay the G7. Then “it will take decades” to repay the EU loans, says a senior Commission official. As for the principal, “I’ll have long since retired by then, and perhaps worse,” the official quips. “Ukraine will only have to repay (the principal) once Russia has compensated for the damage it has caused in Ukraine,” said von der Leyen. But it is not known whether the war will end, or when. It is unlikely that Vladimir Putin will agree to pay war reparations to Kyiv.
Negotiations on the 2028–34 budget are already tense due to the clash between the ‘frugal’ countries, which want more cuts, and the ‘friends of cohesion’, who want more money. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has introduced a new point of contention by announcing that he will veto the budget if certain Member States request to be exempted from the 45 billion loan to Ukraine. Hungary, Slovakia and the Czech Republic had secured an exemption from the first 90 billion loan. Now Bulgaria is also asking to be excluded. “Solidarity is a two-way street,” explains a diplomat from a “frugal” country: “The cohesion countries receive solidarity for their regions. They must show solidarity for European security.” Von der Leyen said she “supports” Merz: “A shared budget, shared responsibilities”. However, the unanimity rule and the right of veto could complicate the EU’s plans to support Ukraine. Last year, it took over six months – and the ousting of Viktor Orbán from power in Hungary – to approve the first 90-billion loan.