Fritz Bauer and the Auschwitz trial

A review of Ronen Steinke’s book, published by Ronzani Editore, 291 pp., 20 euros

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Fritz Bauer and the Auschwitz trial
When, thanks to a series of chance events, traces of Adolf Eichmann, in hiding in Argentina, come to light, the German judge Fritz Bauer finds himself faced with a dramatic dilemma: should he initiate standard extradition proceedings, at the risk of allowing the culprit to slip away? Or should he seek another solution, even if it means breaking the law? Bauer does not trust the system; he feels surrounded by too many former Nazis. In the utmost secrecy, he decides to follow his conscience and passes the information on to Israel. Under cover of night, a Mossad agent breaks into his office, finds a folder prominently displayed on his desk and photographs its contents. The rest is history. Fritz Bauer’s was truly an extraordinary life. A non-practising Jew, an SPD activist, a brilliant lawyer and a young magistrate in the Weimar Republic, he was arrested by the Nazis in his Stuttgart office on 23 March 1933 and imprisoned in the Heuberg concentration camp. Released the following year, Bauer first fled to Denmark – where he also ran into some trouble due to a homosexuality he never admitted to – and then to Sweden, where he led a vigorous anti-Nazi campaign alongside his fellow exiles.
But once the war was over, unexpectedly, the talented jurist found it difficult to return to his post. “I had begun negotiations with the Americans regarding a trip to Stuttgart (…) but I never received a reply and I do not understand why. I did, however, assume (…) that they did not want Jews, or to put it more accurately, that they considered their more or less public activities to be inappropriate”. The Allies considered it risky to impose Jewish judges on the defeated German people, whose goodwill they wished to regain. Despite these bitter experiences, having finally returned to the ranks of the judiciary, Bauer found himself surrounded by former Nazi colleagues, some of whom had been actively involved in the regime’s worst crimes, whilst others had been passive and indifferent accomplices. Amidst countless difficulties, boycotted and isolated, in the early 1960s the judge managed to organise a sensational show trial in Frankfurt (dubbed the ‘Auschwitz trial’), held in a large courtroom in the presence of journalists from all over the world. It was a trial that would make history, and which would force Germany to look in the mirror, in a tormented exercise of collective soul-searching. Bauer declared: “Above every law, above every command, there exists something that is incorruptible and indestructible: the clear awareness that there are things that cannot be done on this earth. Firstly, because they are forbidden by the Ten Commandments; and secondly, of course, because they are contrary to every religion and every moral code”. (…) For this reason, the central point of these trials can be summarised as follows: ‘You should have said no’.”
* * *
Ronen Steinke
, "Fritz Bauer and the Auschwitz
Trial", Ronzani Editore, 291 pp., 20 euros