The geometric problem facing Italian rugby. Interview with Vittorio Munari

Following defeats against South Africa and Argentina, the men’s national team will play their third match in the Northern Hemisphere Series of the Nations Championship on Saturday. The rugby pundit on TV explains why “we’ve never taken two steps forward, but rather one forward and then straight back. That’s not a criticism. It’s a fact.”

20 NOV 26
Last updated: 09:17 AM
Translated by AI
A picture of the match between Italy and Argentina (photo by Tano Pecoraro for LaPresse)

A picture of the match between Italy and Argentina (photo by Tano Pecoraro for LaPresse)

Figiani: big, burly, strong. And hungry. The Azzurri’s third match in the Northern Hemisphere Series of the Nations Championship – on Saturday 21st at 5.40 pm at the Bluenergy Stadium in Udine (and on Sky Sport channels) – will be a real cracker. Following the two matches this November against South Africa (7–66) and Argentina (14–19), and the three matches in the same tournament last July against Japan (10–27), New Zealand (17–47) and Australia (10–57), and following their final Six Nations match against Wales (17–31), they have now suffered six consecutive defeats (their last victory – their first ever – came against England, 23–18). Vittorio Munari, the voice of rugby – from player to coach, manager and pundit in print, online and on TV – is fed up with always having to say the same things.
Munari: Has Italy learnt to lose?
“They’ve never learnt how to win. If you look at the history of the national team, they’ve never followed up a resounding victory with another in the next match. People either ignore this or forget it. Even ten years ago, after the 20–18 win in Florence, they lost to Tonga a week later. We’ve never taken two steps forward, but rather one forward and then straight back. This isn’t a criticism. It’s a fact.”
Why does this happen?
“Our national team lacks depth – that is to say, it has few players – and since the game is played more frequently, and is more physical, tougher and more selective, it is essential to be able to rely on a greater number of high-quality players. And we don’t have them. Two summers ago we went to play in the southern hemisphere with our most experienced players, who wore themselves out, so we lost them. Rugby, especially nowadays, is a gruelling sport. Take Tommaso Menoncello, for example: he plays in France, where the standard is high and the tackles are extremely hard; he’s 24 and has already had two operations on his collarbones. In 2026, it’s true that we fielded only a few fewer players than South Africa, England and Ireland, but it’s also true that not all of them were up to the standard required to play at that level. Now we’re hoping to get the injured players back, not so much for the Six Nations in February and March, but for the World Cup in October and November.”
How can you increase the depth of a team?
“Why has Wales managed, in a year and a half, to go from finishing bottom of the table to beating the All Blacks? Because its player base produces a large number of top-class players. Ours does not. It’s not a question of birth rates or Covid: everyone faces those challenges. It’s a geometric problem. Today, our rugby movement is shaped like an isosceles triangle, where the base is getting narrower and narrower and the apex is too far away. Instead, the ideal would be an equilateral triangle, with three equal sides, a strong base that firmly supports the apex, with the right balance between players, coaches, interest, the media… In short, the Pyramid of Cheops. That’s what happened to Rommel in Africa and to Napoleon in Russia: they were defeated because they had strayed too far from their supply lines.”
So the problem stems from the ground up?
“The Federation does not disclose the figures for our sport. And when it does, it mixes them up, confuses them, and even includes the ‘Old’ players. Fewer players, fewer registered members, fewer teams. The two franchises, Benetton and Zebre, funded by the Federation, are unable to hold on to our best players – who are heading abroad – and are stuffed full of second-rate foreign players. The top league, now called Serie A Elite, has gone to the dogs. And things will get even worse when the most experienced players, who are keeping the whole thing afloat, stop mentoring the younger ones.”
What should I do?
“I’m fed up with saying – and I’ve been saying this for 25 years – that we’re not getting anywhere like this. From Dondi’s presidency to Duodo’s, via Gavazzi and Innocenti, despite all the talk and promises, they’re all slaves to a system that costs too much, and nothing has changed. They think only of top-flight rugby and chasing electoral votes. Instead, we need to build loyalty amongst young players by relying on competent coaches, but to do that we need to train the coaches, educate the educators and instruct the instructors. And we mustn’t select the same young players based on weight and height.”