The fears of the broad coalition and the plan to outmanoeuvre Elly Schlein

Within the centre-left’s jubilant war machine, set on winning the elections, doubts have crept in that it might not be quite so impossible to lose them after all. And there are those who dream (with very little hope) of avoiding the polling booths once again so as not to have Schlein as a candidate. Twists and turns on the left


16 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The fears of the broad coalition and the plan to outmanoeuvre Elly Schlein
To put it bluntly, we could also describe it as follows: the (almost impossible) plan to outmanoeuvre Elly Schlein. The path seems to be set, at least on the left, and everything appears to have become rather straightforward, at least on the surface. By November, therefore, the coalition’s manifesto will be in place. By February, as is well known, the primaries will take place. The coalition primaries, it seems, will be open to everyone, will be a two-round system and will also allow for online voting. By March, it appears, a coalition leader is also expected to be in place, who will most likely be either Giuseppe Conte or Elly Schlein. And yet. Preparations are underway for an election in the spring, in a window that could run from mid-April to mid-June, and no one really believes that the formation of a government will be delayed until after the summer (the date marked on the calendars: 9 May). 
Preparations are underway for election day, even though everyone on the centre-left knows that Meloni will try to bring forward the general election (April) and then the local elections (June) (the only firm no from the Quirinale concerns the possibility of holding elections in February: it is better to wait for the Constitutional Court to rule on the constitutionality of the new electoral law). Everything appears straightforward: drafting the manifesto will not be difficult, organising the primaries will not be difficult, and finding a leader will not be difficult. Just as local councils are preparing – even where it is not necessary – to include the M5S in their governing coalitions, in the upcoming local elections, as in Rome and Turin, the centre-left coalition at national level will bring together everyone it can: the PD, the M5S, AVS, Italia Viva, the civic list led by Onorato, the Socialists, Più Europa, Rifondazione Comunista, and the party led by Ruffini and Gabrielli – none of whom have been excluded from drafting the manifesto. And yet. Everything seems to be heading in a clear direction – that of victory – and if we add to this the fact that election day could well bring more centre-left voters to the polls than the progressive coalition could mobilise at national level (voting will take place in the spring in cities where the centre-left is strong, such as Milan, Turin, Bologna, Naples and Rome), the chances of victory for the broad coalition – the progressive camp, or whatever you wish to call it – are not just good: they are very high indeed.
On top of all this, further details must be added. It should be borne in mind that, during the era of the Second Republic, no outgoing coalition has ever managed to secure re-election to lead the country. It must be borne in mind that, for this governing majority, the likelihood of losing the election is clearly higher than in the past, because not only has it always been a daunting task for a governing majority to win re-election, but attempting to do so after having governed for longer than any previous government increases the likelihood of defeat. On top of all this, it must be added that the right appears divided, with Vannacci outside the coalition; however much he may have been weakened (the fact that he no longer appears every evening on TV programmes that portray him as a martyr for freedom is helping), he will chip away at the centre-right’s vote, if it is true that Meloni has chosen not to include him in her coalition. Nonetheless, the prospects for success of the broad coalition are also rising for other reasons, quite apart from the polls, because while Meloni cannot be accused of having been a genuine follower of Trumpism, anyone who has come anywhere near Trump – even for a moment – over the last two years has not been spared the spread of his ‘radioactivity’, and it is not difficult to imagine that Meloni, too, could meet the same fate as Bolsonaro Jr. in Brazil, Orbán in Hungary, and Wilders in the Netherlands.
To all this, one must add that, however strong Meloni may be, her allies are well and truly done for; Forza Italia is torn apart by internal divisions; the Lega is in the throes of turmoil; and to imagine that, in this context, the centre-left has any chance of not winning the elections might seem, if not impossible, then at least bizarre. And yet, within the centre-left, one need only speak to any party leader to realise that, with regard to the upcoming elections – despite everything pointing towards a victory that, if not easy, is at least uncomplicated – something is amiss. It is a subtle, widespread and deep-seated feeling, in which the figure at the centre of the anxiety and panic is the person who is likely to be the candidate to lead the coalition: Elly Schlein, the secretary of the PD. There are many fears; they are often impossible to articulate in front of an open microphone, but behind closed doors, these fears take shape.
There is a fear within the M5S that a leader from outside the M5S could prompt many M5S voters not to vote. There is concern within the centre-left that a head-to-head contest between Meloni and Schlein could help Meloni narrow the small deficit the centre-right currently faces—estimated at between one and five percentage points. There is also the memory of what Silvio Berlusconi achieved in 2006, when he lost the election but did so after recovering a five-point deficit in just three weeks. There are memories of what happened to the PD in 2013, when the centre-right made up a fifteen-point deficit in just a few weeks, albeit aided in that instance by the surge of the M5S, which was outside the centre-left coalition at the time. The situation may seem paradoxical, but the point is one you will have guessed: within the centre-left’s jubilant war machine – which seems to be cheerfully on course to win the next election – there is great concern that they have become caught up in a perfect mechanism whereby elections that are impossible to lose might not, in fact, be won.
It is worth focusing on the context described to understand why there are numerous leading figures within the centre-left who still dream of seeing Plan A fall through so that they can draw up a Plan B. Letting Plan A fall through means preparing for the primaries whilst knowing that, right up to the last moment, it would be better not to hold them. The hope of avoiding them—the only way to prevent the current secretary from becoming the centre-left’s inevitable candidate for Prime Minister—rests on two scenarios. Scenario number one, the great hope of the PD reformists (and of AVS): Giuseppe Conte decides to step aside, asks Elly Schlein – out of a sense of responsibility – to withdraw from the primaries, and, in light of the coalition’s discouraging poll results, an agreement is reached on a third candidate (such as Roberto Gualtieri) to run united without undermining one another (a possibility close to zero). Scenario number two: the Constitutional Court, in assessing the new electoral law, decides that the mandatory nomination of a prime ministerial candidate – currently required under the so-called Stabilicum – is unconstitutional, in the sense that whilst a prime ministerial candidate may be nominated, this cannot be made a decisive condition for participating in the elections. Under this scenario, as one can understand, the need for primaries would vanish, and without primaries, everything could be back in play. The centre-left, as you will have realised, is heading into elections that are difficult to lose. But precisely because it seems possible not to win elections that are impossible to lose, the centre-left is approaching the primaries with the mindset of those preparing to draw up Plan A in the hope of letting it fail in favour of Plan B. The (almost impossible) plan to outmanoeuvre Schlein does exist. Whether it comes to fruition is another matter entirely.