Government and healthcare: a rift to be mended

The Covid commission, which is giving a platform to the claims of the anti-vaxxer movement, risks turning into a trial of medical professionals and fuelling mistrust of medicine and research. The political responsibilities of the ruling party 

16 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Government and healthcare: a rift to be mended

(Photo: Getty)

There is something profoundly wrong with what is happening in the parliamentary committee of inquiry into Covid. Not in the fact that an investigation is taking place, that decisions made during the pandemic are being reconstructed, that any errors are being examined, and that political, administrative or health-related responsibilities are being established. All of this is legitimate, right and even necessary. A mature democracy is not afraid to take stock of its own decisions, not even those taken in the most difficult of times. The problem lies elsewhere: the committee seems to be gradually turning into a platform for the most radical views of the anti-vaxxer movement. 
These are not simply people calling for a closer look at the adverse effects of vaccines, claiming the right to share personal experiences, or challenging certain decisions taken during the emergency. Rather, they are representatives of organisations who go so far as to describe those who have worked in public institutions and the healthcare sector as criminals, accusing doctors administering vaccines of lining their own pockets, of acting out of financial self-interest, and of betraying their professional duty.
The most recent hearing, held on 12 November with Maria Grazia Piccinelli, chair of the Fortitudo Committee, is emblematic. In her testimony, she implicated Mario Draghi, the health authorities, the judiciary and the healthcare professionals who took part in the vaccination campaign. It even went so far as to call for formal notices of investigation and detention for the former Prime Minister and the doctors administering the vaccines. It was claimed that the latter had enriched themselves at the vaccination centres, carrying out their work without adequate clinical assessments.
These are extremely serious allegations, which must be regarded for what they are: statements made by a witness, not conclusions established by the committee. But this is precisely where a political and institutional question arises: what message is Parliament seeking to convey when it gives such prominence to a narrative that puts an entire professional community in the dock?
Because we are not just talking about Mario Draghi, Roberto Speranza or whoever was in government at the time. We are talking about thousands upon thousands of doctors, nurses, pharmacists, technicians, social and healthcare workers, and professionals in prevention and research. People who have endured gruelling shifts, working on wards, in hospitals, in intensive care units, in A&E departments and at vaccination centres. People who have made difficult decisions under extraordinary circumstances, often with constantly evolving information, whilst shouldering enormous responsibilities.
It is possible to discuss political decisions, the proportionality of the restrictions, the organisation of the vaccination campaign and the procedures adopted. It is possible to identify errors and establish individual accountability. But it is one thing to conduct an investigation; it is quite another to fuel a collective narrative in which those who acted in accordance with the knowledge and evidence available at the time are portrayed as accomplices, profiteers or even criminals.
This issue directly implicates the ruling party. Not only because the committee chair belongs to its political camp, but because this party plays a central role in leading and directing the work of the parliamentary body. The chairmanship does not imply that every statement made by those being questioned is endorsed by the person chairing the proceedings. However, it does entail a political responsibility: to ensure pluralism, rigour, balance and respect for the individuals and professions involved. The question is inevitable: does the majority party realise the message it is sending to the healthcare sector? 
The risk is that this will cement the image of a government which, rather than acknowledging the work carried out by doctors and nurses during one of the greatest health emergencies in recent history, gives credence to a narrative that holds them responsible for an alleged criminal operation. A narrative that deliberately confuses political responsibilities with professional ones and turns the debate on the management of the pandemic into a blanket indictment of the health service. This is not a trivial matter, especially for a government that needs to rebuild and strengthen the National Health Service.
The difficulties facing the Italian healthcare system are plain for all to see: waiting lists, staff shortages, recruitment difficulties, the exodus of professionals to the private sector or to other countries, often unsustainable working conditions, and local services struggling to provide adequate care for citizens. Against this backdrop, the priority should be to enhance the status of the professions, improve working conditions, invest in training and restore the appeal of working in healthcare. Fostering a climate of delegitimisation, on the other hand, only serves to widen a divide that the country cannot afford.
There is a further factor that makes what is happening within the Covid committee a cause for concern. It is not merely giving a platform to the anti-vaxxer movement, but to a broader cultural sphere in which anti-scientific positions, conspiracy theories and, in some cases, forms of religious fanaticism that seek to replace medical knowledge with ideological convictions or personal beliefs are given a voice.
It is a phenomenon with which Italy should be well acquainted and from which it should have learnt a lesson. We cannot forget the Di Bella case, when a treatment lacking adequate scientific evidence was turned into a national battle, fuelling hopes amongst patients and their families and leading to a bitter clash between evidence-based medicine, the judiciary, politics and public opinion. We cannot forget the Stamina case involving Davide Vannoni, with its burden of false hopes, suffering and legal battles, which forced the authorities to intervene to halt a practice lacking a solid scientific basis. These are different cases, but they share one common element: the difficulty institutions face in defending the scientific method when it comes into conflict with emotional expectations, media pressure and ideological campaigns.
Freedom of inquiry and opinion is sacrosanct. Even those who believe they have suffered harm must be able to be heard and receive answers. But not everything presented as an alternative to conventional medicine has scientific merit. And not all theories deserve the same recognition in terms of evidence.
Parliament should be the place where facts are distinguished from speculation, not the place where any form of challenge to science is granted a stamp of authority. The risk is that the Covid committee will end up legitimising an entire culture of mistrust towards medicine, research and scientific institutions. A culture that regards scientific knowledge as mere opinion, expertise as an agenda to be unmasked, and doctors as potential accomplices of a system of power.
The pandemic, after all, has shown just how fragile the relationship is between citizens, institutions and scientific knowledge. It has demonstrated that we need to communicate better, acknowledge mistakes, explain uncertainties and avoid turning scientific guidance into indisputable political truths. But this realisation cannot lead to the opposite principle: that all opinions are of equal value.
Science is not infallible; by its very nature, it is subject to verification and review. But the scientific method remains the most reliable tool we have for distinguishing what works from what does not, what cures from what merely gives false hope. To forget this is to take a step backwards that Italy cannot afford.
There remains one question to which the Prime Minister and the Health Secretary should respond: does the government really want to be remembered as the one that turned its back on healthcare professionals? The Health Secretary cannot regard what is happening as merely a matter concerning the functioning of a parliamentary committee. His institutional role also entails the responsibility to uphold the integrity of the healthcare professions and to defend the relationship of trust between citizens, the health service and the scientific community. He is not being asked to prevent an inquiry, to censor a hearing or to shield anyone from their responsibilities. He is being asked to make it clear that the National Health Service cannot be discredited through generalisations and indiscriminate accusations. He is being asked to recognise the work of those who, during the pandemic, worked in the country’s hospitals and healthcare services.
Finally, there is a question of political perspective that should not be underestimated. The forthcoming general election is drawing near, and relations with the healthcare sector cannot be regarded as a secondary issue. Doctors, nurses, pharmacists, healthcare professionals and social care workers are not a marginal group, nor are they merely a collection of corporate interests to be listened to only when it comes to renewing a contract or resolving a dispute. They number in the hundreds of thousands. They are one of the cornerstones of the Italian system. Every day they come into contact with millions of citizens, support families in their moments of greatest vulnerability, have first-hand knowledge of the country’s problems and, through their professional authority, help to shape public opinion. They are a fundamental part of Italian society, not only because of the work they do, but also because of the role of trust they fulfil within communities. To think that we can leave them on the sidelines, ignore their difficulties, fail to recognise their commitment and, at the same time, tolerate their being publicly discredited is a mistake that risks having consequences far beyond the controversy surrounding the Covid Commission.
The relationship with the healthcare sector must be restored. And it must be restored now, not when the election campaign begins and we realise that hundreds of thousands of professionals, along with their families, no longer feel represented or listened to. You cannot ask for trust from those you have left in the lurch, nor can you expect gratitude from those who, over the years, have received mainly broken promises and scant attention. A government that genuinely wants to address healthcare must start by showing respect for those who keep the healthcare system running. It must listen to the professions, invest in working conditions, recognise expertise and defend the value of evidence-based medicine.
The Covid commission should serve to establish the truth about a difficult period, not to settle scores with those who worked to care for people. The ruling party has a particular responsibility to ensure that this does not happen. Because everything can be discussed, even the mistakes made during the pandemic. But one cannot envisage building the future of the Italian healthcare system in opposition to its professionals. And above all, one cannot imagine tackling the country’s upcoming challenges – including those relating to the elections – whilst abandoning one of its most important pillars.