A distorted constitution. The risks of upsetting the balance of the process

It is by no means clear what need the reform – which aims to introduce the protection of crime victims into the Constitution – is intended to meet. The President of the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers writes to us

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of A distorted constitution. The risks of upsetting the balance of the process

Photo: ANSA

It is by no means clear what need the reform – which aims to introduce the protection of crime victims into the Constitution – is intended to address. Neither a specific supranational obligation nor any acknowledged shortcoming in our Constitution justifies it. It would therefore be necessary to explain which shortcoming is to be remedied by that statement of principle, inserted specifically within Article 24 of the Constitution, according to which ‘the Republic protects the victims of crime’. And to explain, in particular, why the Republic does not, instead, protect all victims of every other form of injustice and of tragic events not attributable to a criminal offence. Such a selectively and categorically asserted protection suggests, in fact, that in the future constitutionally-oriented interpretation of individual procedural and substantive rules, precedence must be given to the victim, with any balancing of interests being carried out in their favour vis-à-vis the other parties to the proceedings.
Doing so encourages a trend that is anything but modern and which, on the contrary, promotes a cultural perspective that looks to the past, to a system of justice in which it is no longer the public prosecutor who bears sole responsibility for bringing criminal proceedings against the perpetrator, but in which a focus on the victim’s claims regains prominence. A judicial system in which the victim becomes the driving force behind criminal proceedings, claiming rights and taking initiatives that are today wisely reserved as the exclusive prerogative of the state and therefore of the public prosecutor alone. That balance, which in modern states had been painstakingly achieved at the expense of the desire for revenge, risks being compromised.
The protection of the victim of a crime, so categorically enshrined in the Constitution, will legitimately be interpreted by the legislator as an explicit call to shift the balance of the trial in the victim’s favour. No longer a criminal trial governed by the need to curb the state’s punitive power, but one tailored to safeguarding the victim’s needs and expectations. No longer a penalty meted out according to the principle of proportionality, but a retributive criminal law, commensurate with the extent of the pain and distress caused by the offender. A penalty of poetic justice. We need to reflect on where we actually wish to take our legal system and consider the imbalances which, as a result of a demagogic choice, may be introduced into the procedural system, giving rise to unreasonable and dangerous distortions.
Francesco Petrelli
President of the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers