Criminal lawyers oppose the introduction of victim protection into the Constitution. There is a strike.

“Placing the protection of the victim right alongside the inviolability of the defence means introducing a criterion that can be invoked to restrict the rights of the accused,” says Rinaldo Romanelli (Ucpi)

16 NOV 26
Last updated: 10:57
Translated by AI
Image of Criminal lawyers oppose the introduction of victim protection into the Constitution. There is a strike.

Photo: ANSA

“Including victim protection in the Constitution risks having devastating effects on the balance of criminal proceedings, because it brings the right to punish the guilty party into the trial, thereby undermining all those principles of due process and civilisation that have been hard-won over time”. The statement was made to Il Foglio by Rinaldo Romanelli, secretary of the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers (UCPI), which has resolved that criminal defence lawyers are to abstain from court hearings and judicial activities throughout the country from 23 to 27 November, with the aim of urging the Chamber of Deputies not to give final approval to the constitutional reform which, precisely, enshrines victim protection in the Constitution. 
The reform, which has already been approved almost unanimously twice by the Senate and once by the Chamber of Deputies (where it has now returned for final approval), inserts the following provision into Article 24 of the Constitution, immediately following the recognition of the inviolability of the defence: “The Republic protects the victims of crime”.
“Today, the Constitution already recognises and guarantees the rights of those who have been the victims of a crime. Article 24 already ensures full access to justice for everyone, including the victim,” points out Romanelli, who then adds: “In criminal proceedings, the inviolability of the right to a defence takes on the meaning of a necessary and insurmountable limit in the face of the enormous power that the state exercises over the accused. At the time of the offence, in fact, the vulnerable party is the victim, whilst at the time of the trial the vulnerable party is the defendant. In this context, placing the protection of the victim right alongside the inviolability of the right to a defence means introducing a criterion that can be invoked to restrict the rights of the accused.”
Some specific examples: “The first concerns the possibility of challenging evidence obtained unlawfully or outside the legal framework. This right lies at the heart of the adversarial process. Today, if a wiretap is declared inadmissible, it is inadmissible. If the reform is approved and the protection of the victim is placed on an equal footing with the right to a defence, then even an inadmissible wiretap – one that could provide a decisive element in establishing the defendant’s criminal liability – could become admissible in court proceedings”, states Romanelli. “Another example: the statute of limitations. If the victim’s right to see a conviction secured is introduced, then it will no longer be possible to regard as acceptable a system that allows offences to lapse on the basis of the passage of time. And what about the suspension of proceedings with a probation order? Who can rule out the possibility that, in future, the Constitutional Court might rule that, without the victim’s consent, proceedings cannot be suspended? The same applies to alternative forms of sentence enforcement. But I could go on forever,” says the UCPI secretary.
In short, this is a ‘populist reform, good for winning support but with damaging consequences for the functioning of the legal process’. Rather, Romanelli states, “victim protection should be strengthened through accessible and prompt compensation, psychological, social and legal support services, and measures aimed at ensuring trials are of reasonable duration, whilst safeguarding the effectiveness of the adversarial process and the inviolability of the right to a defence”.
Ivan Scalfarotto (Italia viva) is the only MP to have openly – and courageously – taken a stand against the constitutional reform. “The reform paves the way for the privatisation of criminal proceedings, which risk being transformed from a process of establishing a citizen’s liability before the state into a contest between the victim and the defendant,” he tells Il Foglio. “The civil party is so called because it is entitled to compensation for damages. With this reform, however, the penalty is no longer imposed for the purposes of retribution or general deterrence, but becomes almost a means of satisfying the victim. All this runs counter to the constitutional principles of the presumption of innocence of the accused and the rehabilitation of the convicted person. The reform opens the door to a complete distortion of the principles of criminal procedure.” “I say all this – and I want to emphasise this – not because I do not care about the victims of crime. But because their protection is already provided for by the current Article 24 of the Constitution and by the laws implementing it,” concludes Scalfarotto.