Costa (Forza Italia) says: “Our new bill extends compensation for victims of miscarriages of justice. But it won’t get passed.”

“These are liberal and identity-based issues for Forza Italia, and no one in the coalition questions them. But it won’t become law by the end of the parliamentary term; it needs time to develop,” says the party’s leader in the Chamber of Deputies

16 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Costa (Forza Italia) says: “Our new bill extends compensation for victims of miscarriages of justice. But it won’t get passed.”

Photo: ANSA

Forza Italia aims to broaden the scope for compensation in cases of wrongful imprisonment. "If a person is cleared of all charges following an investigation or trial, the state must ensure that they regain the image, reputation, credibility and financial circumstances they had before becoming entangled in the judicial system," Enrico Costa, Forza Italia’s leader in the Chamber of Deputies and a signatory to a draft bill, tells Il Foglio. As he himself explains, “will not become law by the end of this parliamentary term. Proposals of this kind need time to mature; it is difficult to get it right at the first attempt. But they are inspired by the principles of due process, and these are liberal values central to Forza Italia’s identity; no one in the coalition questions them.” 
The proposal covers several issues. First and foremost, it aims to extend protection to victims of miscarriages of justice by amending the current law dating from 1988. Until now, in order to obtain compensation from the state, a citizen had to prove that the judge had acted with ‘gross negligence’, that is to say, with a gross breach of the duty of care and a clear deviation from the rules of prudence and expertise that the specific case would have required. “A very high threshold, which in practice has made compensation difficult to obtain,” emphasises Costa, citing in his proposal some statistical figures for the period 2010–2025, according to which, out of 872 cases brought and 372 final judgements, the state was found to be at fault in only 15 cases. By removing the word “serious”, the possibility of obtaining compensation is therefore extended to all cases of negligence. “As regards the personal and financial liability of the magistrate, we are leaving everything as it is today, but we are extending the possibility of obtaining compensation to all cases of negligence, removing all those loopholes that currently exist which prevent a person from being compensated. And the state bears the full cost,” explains the MP. If anything, it will be the state, after compensating the citizen, that brings the public prosecutor into the matter by way of recourse: in such cases, the public prosecutor may in fact be held personally liable only in cases of wilful misconduct or gross negligence.  "If every error, even the slightest, were to expose the individual magistrate to the risk of having to bear personal financial liability, there would be a risk of influencing their decisions, of them signing documents with a trembling hand, pushing them towards more cautious or defensive choices for fear of personal consequences," explains Costa. The new provisions, therefore, significantly strengthen the protection of those who have suffered harm, without, however, undermining the magistrate’s independence.” Nevertheless, the document states that the judgement handed down in the compensation proceedings brought against the state “has effects, limited to the establishment of the facts, also in disciplinary proceedings against the magistrate and in the periodic assessments of their professional conduct.”
Currently, compensation is only awarded to those who have been deprived of their personal liberty (in prison or under arrest) and subsequently found not guilty. “With this law, we are extending compensation to those who have been subject to precautionary measures that affect them personally, such as a frozen bank account, a seized home, a residence ban or a travel ban. We want to extend compensation to those who have suffered such harm as well,” explains Costa. According to him, the real innovation concerns reckless prosecution. "A few years ago, the president of the Turin Court, Massimo Terzi, stated that a great many trials reaching his court should never even have begun, because it was already clear from the outset how they would end," explains the MP. "Among these cases are also those in which the prosecution becomes fixated on a line of argument – perhaps one that has received a great deal of media attention – and therefore refuses to reconsider its position despite the evidence." Under this proposal, when a judge, in acquitting a person, considers that the trial should never even have begun, they may award compensation to the person found innocent. “Because, as Piero Calamandrei said, ‘a trial – and not just a criminal one – is in itself a punishment that judges and lawyers must shorten by delivering justice’.”
In financial terms, the proposal requires €10 million per year from 2026 onwards. Costa himself, however, does not express confidence that his proposal will be published in the Official Gazette by the end of the parliamentary term. More likely, however, is the success of the Zuncheddu amendment to the Budget Bill (recently tabled and supported by Forza Italia itself), which provides for the establishment of a fund for victims of miscarriages of justice. “It is intended to enable a person who has been the victim of a state error and has lost their personal liberty for at least three years, only to have their conviction quashed on appeal, to receive one year’s financial support. It is very little,” he observes, “but it is nonetheless a signal from the state to help them get back on their feet.” The other bills put forward by Forza Italia have certainly met with greater success. These range from the reimbursement of legal costs for acquitted persons up to 10,500 euros, to ‘legal oblivion’ for the acquitted – that is, the de-indexing of news reports relating to investigations that mention the name of a person who has been acquitted – right through to the publication of acquittal judgements, for which the Senate plenary gave its final approval at the end of October. "We hope to finalise," Costa concludes, "the reform of the rules governing the seizure of smartphones as well," announced in February 2024 by Justice Minister Carlo Nordio and currently stalled. "An agreement will be reached," the Justice Minister had replied at the latest Foglio festival in Florence. A festival of optimism, not by chance.