GRAN MILANO
A stone thrown into the pond of the primaries does not resolve the political chess game on the left
The M5S is putting the brakes on the centre-left primaries in Milan, whilst the PD remains divided and Schlein is playing for time. Meanwhile, the candidates are launching their campaigns, but the decision will be made in Rome

(Photo: Getty)
A large stone falls into a pond and one would expect high waves: ripples and backwash. Yet nothing happens; it’s dead calm. This, too, happens in Milan, which would prefer not to be dependent on Rome. It so happens that the secretary of one of the parties in the centre-left coalition, Stefano Buffagni of the M5S, gives an interview in which he says quite openly what many – including those in Avs circles – have been muttering for some time in countless private discussions: we don’t like the primaries in Milan. For a thousand reasons.
Detractors might argue: holding local primaries before the general election reduces one’s bargaining power, which is why some people don’t want them. Or: how on earth can one decide not to hold them in Milan if they are being held for the general election? The answer, in the latter case, is relatively simple. If Elly Schlein’s Mr Wolf, Igor Taruffi, travels to Milan and makes it clear to everyone that the party leader does not want the city primaries to be held alongside the national primaries – but rather after the national primaries – it may well be that there simply isn’t enough time to hold them.
Let us add: unlike the general election – for which it is still unclear whether it will be held in spring 2027 or in autumn – it is certain that Beppe Sala will step down before going on holiday, and that the election will therefore take place between mid-May and mid-June. Indeed, Sala himself makes a point so obvious it goes without saying: if we assume it will be in March, how on earth are we supposed to organise it?
This gives rise to two interpretations. The first is that if the national leadership were to set the date for the primaries by mid-January, the primaries would be held in Milan because there is physically enough time to organise them. The second is that if the national leadership were to drag its feet… no one would know what to do, and we would revert to the Buffagni ruling: what’s the point of holding them at all?
In the wake of the interview with the M5S secretary, two major, predictable endorsements of the primaries emerged. One came from Lia Quartapelle, a reformist MP strongly backing Mario Calabresi. The other came from Sinistra Italiana. Strangely, however, AVS and the majority factions within the PD have remained silent.
It is no secret that within the metropolitan secretariat, the view is that if primaries are held, they will be ‘anarchic’. Everyone will be in the running; there will be no run-offs, no mergers, and no screening process upon joining the PD that results in a single flagship candidate. This would particularly affect Majorino, who draws his greatest strength from within the party. The question arises: can Schlein afford to let a member of her own secretariat go into the race at risk of losing? If she chooses not to run that risk, there is only one course of action: to enter the fray herself and campaign for him. Yet that would also expose her to the possibility of defeat. Is she prepared to accept that?
Rome seems far away, and this is an extremely complicated game of Risk, in which the M5S’s position does not make it any harder to decipher, but rather helps to clarify matters. Because the current trajectory, amid silence and delays, as it stands, leaves everyone in the lurch. Whether it’s those who want to stand, those who want to withdraw after having clamoured for primaries, or those ready to stand either within a coalition or as independents (spoiler: we’re not just talking about Calabresi).
Meanwhile, between the end of this month and the start of next month, the campaigns of Anna Scavuzzo (on 26 November) and Mario Calabresi (on 3 December) will be launched. Pierfrancesco Majorino and Tommaso Goisis have already kicked off theirs, drawing crowds of thousands. Lorenzo Pacini, who seems determined to stay in the race despite everything and everyone, could make further announcements in the coming weeks.
The process appears to have been set in motion at a local level, but the issue – as is constantly being reiterated – is a national one. And at national level, Conte, Schlein, Bonelli and Fratoianni do not seem to be discussing what is happening in Milan with a view to reaching a final decision. It is clear that Buffagni is speaking on behalf of the former prime minister. And it is equally clear that the primaries will only go ahead if agreed with Elly Schlein, as Igor Taruffi (who is speaking on behalf of the prospective prime minister) has clearly stated.
Amid this clash between local momentum and national resistance, time is running out beneath the Madonnina. It must be said that, now more than ever, the role of a local PD leader can certainly be described as a gruelling job.