The oil is extra virgin olive oil, but the law may not recognise it as such

The replanting of olive groves affected by Xylella risks funding cultivars whose oils cannot be sold as extra virgin. The crux of the matter lies in the European standards on sterols, which do not always distinguish between fraud and the genetic characteristics of the olives

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The oil is extra virgin olive oil, but the law may not recognise it as such
In Puglia, significant public funds are being allocated to replant olive groves destroyed by Xylella. Yet one of the varieties authorised for replanting can produce a genuine oil that does not meet EU requirements to be marketed as extra virgin olive oil. The risk is that plantations will be funded without resolving the issue of sales. At the root of this are sterols, lipid components found in vegetable oils. Their profile acts as a sort of chemical fingerprint that helps detect adulteration, such as the addition of seed oils. The European Union sets limits, including a minimum of 1,000 milligrams of total sterols per kilogram of oil. When a value falls outside these limits, the oil is deemed non-compliant with the declared category. However, this does not necessarily mean that it is adulterated, as the genetic characteristics of a cultivar can naturally produce values outside the threshold.
Why is this issue coming to the fore now? For decades, the market has been dominated by blends – mixtures of oils obtained from different varieties – which compensated for certain analytical characteristics of the individual varieties. Today, the market places greater value on single-variety oils. Characteristics that were previously overlooked have thus become visible commercial obstacles: it is not the olives that have changed, but the way in which the oil is produced and sold.
This is the case with Coratina, a symbol of Apulian olive cultivation: some of its single-variety oils contain sterols below the European limit. The International Olive Council has recognised this distinctive feature, granting an exceptional threshold of 800 milligrams per kilogram. The EU has implemented this derogation only for Koroneiki and Nocellara del Belice. The Commission has confirmed the launch of the procedure to include Coratina, with the aim of concluding it by April 2027. Until then, single-variety Coratina oils with sterol levels between 800 and 999 milligrams remain subject to the issue of commercial non-compliance.
Other issues concern Coriana and Lecciana, cultivars developed through Italian research. Anomalies in campesterol – a component of the sterol profile – have been detected in some samples. Lecciana has another genetic characteristic: it is one of the four cultivars authorised for replanting in areas infected by Xylella, alongside Leccino, Favolosa and Leccio del Corno. The government is supporting the replanting programme with public funds, and whilst the new olive groves come into production, some single-variety oils risk not being able to be sold as extra virgin. The solution is not to abandon Lecciana, but to inform those responsible for planting. For example, olive groves should be planted with 80–90 per cent Lecciana and 10–20 per cent of another authorised variety, not only to ensure effective cross-pollination but also to produce a blend. This approach, following analytical and agronomic checks, would guarantee the compliance of the oils produced.
This issue also raises questions about our control system. Sterols remain essential in combating fraud, but why not combine them with other markers? Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis, DNA analysis and other methods can help to identify and quantify the olive varieties present in an oil and its geographical origin. The ICQRF, the Ministry of Agriculture’s anti-fraud inspectorate, is developing protocols to utilise and integrate these modern analytical techniques, alongside other indicators such as panel testing, in commercial matters relating to extra virgin olive oils. This would represent an enhancement of controls to better protect Italian olive oils, not a ploy to circumvent legal requirements.
We are now awaiting a swift European correction regarding Coratina, as well as a scientific and regulatory review of Lecciana and Coriana, with the involvement of the International Olive Council. Research is transforming olive groves, and the market is changing the oils we choose to buy. The rules must be able to distinguish between fraud and natural characteristics – whether genetic or agronomic – in order to protect producers and consumers. Effective monitoring must recognise not only counterfeit oil, but also genuine oil.