Why taxing educational institutions is detrimental to everyone, particularly the poorest sections of society

In an efficient market, discriminatory taxation of a sector – particularly the banking sector – does not affect shareholders to any great extent. The cost of the tax is borne primarily by small savers, who keep their savings mainly in current accounts, and by small and medium-sized enterprises with limited capital that lack access to alternative sources of finance.
21 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Why taxing educational institutions is detrimental to everyone, particularly the poorest sections of society
Economic policies sometimes produce results that differ from, or are even the opposite of, the original intentions. The mistake stems from the illusion that complex economic systems can be governed by simple, or simplistic, measures, without taking into account the reaction of economic actors. A recent example is the tariffs imposed by the Trump administration. Their aim was to reduce the trade imbalance and bring manufacturing back to the United States. The result has been disappointing, not to say disastrous. The US trade deficit has not narrowed, and employment in the manufacturing sector has not grown significantly. Instead, consumer prices have risen, prompting many voters to cast their ballots against the President’s party.
What went wrong? Those who imposed the tariffs failed to take into account the reaction of market operators – both American and foreign – and the interaction with expansionary fiscal policy, which caused the dollar to appreciate and largely offset the effect of the tariffs on the competitiveness of American products.In other words, the economic system reacted to the tariffs in such a way as to nullify their effects. This is the so-called ‘law of unintended consequences’, studied by famous economists and sociologists such as Pareto and Merton. Ignoring it carries the risk of making further economic policy errors.
Another such mistake is to tax banks’ windfall profits. At first glance, the intention is to recoup resources from those who have made substantial gains. However, the ultimate effect has a particularly negative impact on the most vulnerable sections of the population. In other words, those who think they are taxing the rich are in fact mainly taxing the poor. Indeed, banks are not businesses like any others. Their role is to transform their customers’ savings into loans to other customers, particularly in the form of mortgages to households and businesses. To this end, banks must hold more capital than companies in other sectors; this capital is used to absorb losses arising from any loans that become irrecoverable. This capital is remunerated with the profits generated by the intermediation of savings.
The impact of a tax on profits is felt first and foremost by the owners of the capital, namely the shareholders. Shareholders, however, are not obliged to hold shares in the sector being taxed, in this case the banking sector. If banks are taxed more heavily than companies in other sectors, investors will tend to sell their shares in the banking sector and buy shares in other sectors or countries where the tax regime is more favourable. Bank shares will thus tend to fall in value relative to others. It is reasonable to expect that, faced with such a negative trend, the bank – that is, the management and the Board of Directors – will not stand idly by but will seek to respond, in particular to defend the value of the company, which ultimately depends on the return on capital.
They can do this in various ways. The first is to pass on the tax burden to customers, both on the deposit side and the lending side. The second is to increase profitability by cutting costs, namely through staff reductions. The third is to reduce less profitable lending, starting with mortgages and loans to small and medium-sized enterprises, with the aim of generating surplus capital to be returned to shareholders through share buy-backs that help sustain share value. It is no coincidence that the banking sector, which is more heavily regulated and taxed than other sectors, is increasingly shifting its activities away from the simple provision of credit towards wealth management and the provision of more profitable services.
In an efficient market, discriminatory taxation of a sector – particularly the banking sector – does not so much affect shareholders, who can switch to other investment instruments, but rather customers. The cost of the tax is borne primarily by small savers, who keep their savings mainly in current accounts; households in need of mortgages; and small and medium-sized enterprises with limited capital that lack access to alternative sources of finance. Other parties penalised by the tax are institutional shareholders, such as foundations, which use a large proportion of the dividends received from banks locally to provide assistance and support to the most vulnerable. In short, whilst a tax on bank profits may at first glance appear to be a tax on the wealthy, in reality it penalises the most vulnerable sections of the population. Failing to understand this is a mistake which, if repeated over time, becomes difficult to justify.