Economy
The European Way •
Safe funds are an alternative to the Superbonus scheme
To achieve the same objective on debt and avoid the ‘South American-style’ rule on construction loans, Italy can reclaim the 7 billion in EU defence loans left on the table. And request further funds

Last Tuesday, the EU Council gave final approval to Italy’s request for 8 billion from the SAFE (Security Action for Europe) funds, earmarked for defence strengthening. At present, senior government officials are working frantically on the final amendments to the Budget Bill, with the so-called ‘Spalma-Superbonus’ – which has sparked widespread protests amongst banks and businesses – at the centre of discussions. These are two completely separate news stories, yet they are closely linked.
The Superbonus measure, which was unexpectedly included in the budget, provides for the approximately €20 billion in tax credits relating to the Superbonus – which were due to be offset in 2027 – to be spread over ten years. The provision does not cover any expenditure margin, as the tax credits issued are accounted for in the 2023 budget, but it does have an impact on cash flow. The aim is simply to ease the Treasury’s borrowing requirement by reducing government bond issues by 18 billion to offset the tax credits due in 2027. The reduction in issuance would fall to 16 billion if the government, as it appears inclined to do, were to reduce the dilution period from 10 to 5 years. Consequently, borrowing requirements in subsequent years would not increase by more than 2 billion over nine years, but by 4 billion over four years.
Whatever the payment schedule, this would stabilise public debt – which is forecast to rise from 138.1 to 138.5 per cent of GDP – at around 138 per cent: it would not rise immediately in 2027 and would fall less sharply in subsequent years.
This benefit, however, comes at a price that is not borne by the debtor state, but by its creditors: banks and businesses. Unilaterally deferring the payment of a debt, without any compensation in terms of interest, results in a loss for creditors amounting to 2–3 billion of the total sum. This is, to all intents and purposes, a debt restructuring. In other words, a default. This is why Carlo Messina, CEO of Intesa Sanpaolo, criticised the measure, describing it as ‘South American’. Unilaterally extending the timeframes for debt recovery means imposing a financial cost on intermediaries, reducing the value of assets on the balance sheet and jeopardising the debtor’s credibility. This represents a heavy cost for banks and businesses and a high risk for the state, which could have knock-on effects on interest rates, whilst offering only a marginal and temporary improvement in terms of borrowing requirements and public debt.
The government is therefore also considering simply scrapping the regulation altogether. But is there a way to achieve the same benefit at a lower cost to businesses and without any risk to the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF)? Yes, it’s called Safe. As mentioned, on 17 November the EU Council gave the green light to the Italian plan under SAFE, the instrument through which the EU makes up to €150 billion in loans available to Member States for defence modernisation. Italy had submitted a plan, approved by the Commission, for approximately €15 billion. However, in the end, to appease the discontent within Matteo Salvini’s Lega – which is totally opposed to SAFE – the government requested only 8 billion. Following the signing of the agreement, Italy will be able to receive an advance of up to 15 per cent, amounting to around 1.2 billion, and draw down the remaining funds progressively by 2030. The advantage of SAFE lies in its financial terms. The loans have a term of up to 45 years, and repayment only begins after a 10-year grace period. This means that the Commission raises funds on the markets at lower rates than those of our BTPs and passes the loan on to the Treasury, which will begin to repay it after ten years and continue to do so for the following 35 years.
But as well as being cost-effective, the Safe loans – as provided for in the original 15 billion plan approved by Brussels at the end of 2025 – would cover military expenditure already planned and included in the budget prior to this budgetary manoeuvre. Drawing down all available SAFE funds, therefore, has the same effect on borrowing requirements as spreading out the Superbonus credits: the Treasury does not have to issue 15 billion in debt immediately, but only much further down the line. There is no increase in debt compared to what was forecast, but rather a change in its composition, replacing Italian debt with European debt, which has a longer maturity and is less costly.
The problem, however, is that the government ultimately requested only 8 billion, leaving 7 billion on the European table. These unclaimed funds, together with those from Hungary, have now been made available by the European Commission in another 21 billion Safe call for proposals. Member states have until 30 November to submit new applications. This is a second chance for Italy. The government can not only recoup the 7 billion it turned down, but can also try to secure an additional allocation. The 7 billion would go towards funding expenditure already planned, as agreed under the initial 2025 plan, whilst the additional loan could finance the increase in military spending – amounting to around 11 billion over the next three years – which the Italian government itself has provided for in this budget through the activation of the National Exception Clause (NEC).
The two instruments are complementary: the NEC allows spending outside the deficit constraints; the SAFE enables such expenditure to be financed on more favourable terms and, moreover, reduces the borrowing requirement in exactly the same way as the Spalma-Superbonus would.
Ultimately, there is a solution that achieves the same objective without harming banks and businesses, and it is simple: simply replace a ‘South American’ measure with a European one.
More on these topics
Cresciuto in Irpinia, a Savignano. Studi a Milano, Università Cattolica. Liberista per formazione, giornalista per deformazione. Al Foglio prima come lettore, poi collaboratore, infine redattore. Mi occupo principalmente di economia, ma anche di politica, inchieste, cultura, varie ed eventuali
