The threshold for the ‘wealthy’ in Italy. The highest income tax rate kicks in at 50,000 euros, earlier than in other countries

From a European perspective, a rate of 43 per cent is high but not exceptionally high: as many as eleven Member States have a higher rate, and in eight it is even 50 per cent or higher. What sets Italy apart from all other countries, however, is the threshold at which that higher rate kicks in

17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The threshold for the ‘wealthy’ in Italy. The highest income tax rate kicks in at 50,000 euros, earlier than in other countries

Photo: LaPresse

The accusation that raising the threshold above which the highest marginal rate of income tax applies would be ‘a gift to the rich’ raises an obvious question: who are the rich? Under the tax system, they are those who earn more than 50,000 euros (perhaps 55,000 from next year). It is within this framework that the debate on the progressivity of our tax system must be situated. From a European perspective, a rate of 43 per cent (around 47 per cent if regional and local surcharges are also included) is high but not extremely high: as many as eleven Member States have a higher rate, and in eight of them it is even equal to or higher than 50 per cent.
What sets Italy apart from all other countries, however, is the point at which the highest tax rate kicks in: in practice, we set the top tax bracket at a level where, in most other countries, the proportion of income taken by the state is considerably lower. In Denmark, for example, the top rate is 60.5 per cent but only applies to taxpayers with an income exceeding around 375,000 euros. In France, including surcharges on high incomes, the rate reaches 55 per cent, but only for incomes of around 600,000 euros or more. In Austria, the 55 per cent rate applies to incomes exceeding one million euros; in Spain, the 54 per cent rate applies to incomes exceeding 300,000. And what about a taxpayer with a taxable income of 50,000 euros? In Denmark, they would pay between 32 and 35 per cent; in France, 30 per cent; in Austria, 40 per cent; and in Spain, 37 per cent. Of course, these simulations do not take into account other factors, such as the allowances and deductions available to the taxpayer, nor the structure of the income tax system, which can affect the average effective tax rate. However, it is essential to understand that an individual’s tax burden depends not only on the nominal rates, but also on the corresponding income brackets. These figures illustrate just how disconnected our domestic debates are from reality: abroad, those we refer to as ‘the rich’ are considered part of the middle class and treated as such.