Economy
Tax the ultra-rich •
The limits of the wealth tax that both unites and divides the broad political spectrum, according to the Tax Foundation
The PD is backing the Zucman model, whilst the M5S is focusing on financial activities. And Bray rejects the 15.9 billion figure put forward by AVS: “It’s an unrealistic figure. These estimates do not take into account behaviour following the introduction of a tax”

“Wealth taxes have failed time and again because they generate little revenue, have high administrative costs and drive the wealthiest people and their money abroad,” Sean Bray, director of tax policy at Tax Foundation Europe – the European arm of the Washington-based think tank of the same name – told Il Foglio, commenting on the debate surrounding the tax on great wealth, which is at the heart of discussions on the centre-left’s programme.
There are in fact three proposals on the table within the broad coalition: Avs is proposing a progressive tax on net wealth exceeding 5.4 million euros, from which it estimates “annual revenue of 15.9 billion”, to cut income tax for low and middle-income earners. On Sunday, Elly Schlein said she had “always been in favour of a tax on the super-rich” and added that “it can also be done at national level”, without waiting for a European agreement. The PD is reportedly looking to the tax model devised by the French economist Gabriel Zucman: a supplementary tax that brings the annual levy to 2 per cent of total net wealth for those with more than 100 million euros. The European Tax Observatory, which Zucman heads, calculated in 2025 that in Italy this would amount to 8.3 billion euros (in France, Zucman himself estimates the figure at around 20 billion, whilst according to economist Antoine Levy, cited in a French Senate report, the revenue would fall to 2–3 billion if corporation tax were also deducted). Giuseppe Conte has said he is opposed to a ‘wealth tax’, but in favour of ‘taxing the super-rich’. His proposal is for a tiered tax, ranging from 0.4 to 1 per cent, on the portion of taxable financial assets exceeding one million euros, plus a 3 per cent levy on the net profits from high-frequency trading in excess of 2.5 million per tax year.
It is therefore not yet clear what the compromise solution between the political forces will be, but it seems certain that some form of wealth tax will form part of the election manifesto. Of the three proposals put forward by the opposition, Bray says “it is difficult to say which is the worst”, because no wealth tax “would generate significant revenue in relation to GDP or total revenue”. And regarding the 15.9 billion estimated by AVS, the Tax Foundation expert comments: “It is an unrealistic figure in the light of historical examples, because only Switzerland would come close to such an amount. In most cases, the figure amounts to a few billion at most. Generally speaking, static estimates of wealth taxes do not take into account what happens to the economy once people change their behaviour as a result of the tax. This is why there is usually a large discrepancy between estimated and actual revenue.”
In Europe, according to a survey by the Tax Foundation, only Norway, Spain and Switzerland levy a net wealth tax. In 2023, according to the OECD, wealth taxes raised 9.4 billion euros in Switzerland and 2.6 billion in Norway, whilst in Spain, the wealth tax and the levy on large fortunes yielded a total of 2.2 billion (if other taxes classified by the OECD under the same heading are taken into account, the figure rises to 3.1 billion). “Wealth taxes do not tackle inequality,” explains Bray. “Furthermore, they do not support economic growth that benefits society as a whole. They might, however, win votes, and it may well be that this is all that matters to politicians. It is difficult to find examples anywhere in the world of governments giving up taxes capable of generating significant revenue, and this should tell us something about the wealth taxes that have been abolished.” In 1990, 12 OECD countries had a wealth tax; by 2017, only four remained. He then adds: “Emigration is one of the negative aspects of a wealth tax, but not the only one. Even if no one were to leave the country, the burden would fall on everyone through reduced economic activity, because this type of tax discourages future entrepreneurs from considering a particular country, which would thus lose the future tax revenue from those who, over time, choose to set up a business elsewhere. And this is a scenario that has been little studied and is rarely addressed in the debate.”
In 2023, according to the OECD, property taxes in Italy (on property, inheritance, financial assets, etc.) accounted for 2.2 per cent of GDP, compared with an OECD average of 1.7 per cent. “Italy is seeking revenue from every corner without considering how poorly designed taxes affect growth,” concludes Bray. In our tax competitiveness index, Italy ranks 36th out of 38 OECD countries. The 22 per cent VAT rate applies to the sixth-narrowest tax base in the OECD. And VAT is a far more efficient tax than a wealth tax: if politicians want stable revenue and the least possible economic distortion, they should focus on eliminating the various reduced rates and exemptions.”