The story of Laura, a naive spy shot in the back

The only woman ever executed in Italy for collaborating with the enemy was thirty years old and believed she had done nothing serious. It was her zeal and messages written with water and salt that led to her conviction
22 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Laura D’Oriano was born in Constantinople on 27 September 1911

Laura D’Oriano was born in Constantinople on 27 September 1911

On the days of the executions at Forte Bravetta, a clamour of voices and vehicles shattered the early-morning silence of the fields. Inaugurated in 1883 on the Prussian model, the Fort is now a hollow monstrosity entrenched in a park overlooking the Casali valley, yet engulfed by the city.
On the day Laura D’Oriano died, 16 January 1943, the tide of the war had already turned for the worse. Some claimed she had turned to look at the firing squad out of pride or fear, but that assertion is unfounded. Convicted of espionage, she was shot in the back, and the report by Dr Alfredo Monaco states that the body showed “entry wounds to the occipital region and posterior thoracic region, with pulverisation of the brain and fatal injuries to vital thoracic organs”. The doctor also noted the bullets: from a Carcano Model 91 musket, a long-serving service rifle that was already rather obsolete by 1943 (three years earlier, the rifle with serial number C 2766 – the one Lee Harvey Oswald would later buy by post in 1963 to assassinate JFK, fitted with a Japanese sight – had been manufactured at the Terni factory).
Laura D’Oriano died on 16 January 1943. Some claimed she had turned to look at the firing squad out of pride or fear, but that assertion is unfounded.
Now, on the parade ground of the Fort, the grass is growing, dotted in mid-October with little white and yellow flowers. It is hard to imagine that between 1932 and 1945, dozens of people were shot there. The memorial stones at the entrance to Bravetta Park bear the names of the ‘heroic patriots who were executed’, but not those of the common criminals or spies killed inside. In truth, one name was included due to a mysterious oversight: Francesco Vigilante from Naples. A mythomaniac. They had found a map of La Maddalena, where he had completed his military service. He dressed as a naval lieutenant, rambling on about imaginary missions. An anonymous letter denouncing his boasts – including his medical expertise, as he also claimed to be a healer – led to his being sent to Calvario. The judges refused to consider him insane. He was shot four months after Laura, on 20 May.
Now, on the parade ground of Forte Bravetta, the grass is growing, dotted with little white and yellow flowers. It is hard to imagine dozens of people being shot there
Even after a death sentence has been handed down, the state sets in motion a whole bureaucratic process, as if stamps, envelopes and telegrams could mitigate the individual responsibilities of those who handled the case. Subject: Laura D’Oriano, née Fraunholz, daughter of Policarpo and Aida Agnese Caruana, born in Constantinople on 27 September 1911, married with two children, literate, with no previous convictions, travelling saleswoman, Swiss citizen by marriage.
In the hours between the verdict and the execution – fewer than twenty-four – there was a frantic exchange of documents: ‘extremely urgent’ letters delivered by hand between the Special Court for the Defence of the State, the Mantellate women’s prison where Laura was awaiting execution, the Carabinieri tasked with transporting her, and the XVII Army Corps, which was to provide the firing squad. The Special Court’s verdicts were final: they became legally binding upon pronouncement. As was standard practice, the prison administration had provided the chair and accessories (“ropes, blindfolds, a knife and whatever else might be required”), as well as “a suitable number of unarmed officers” to restrain the condemned woman, and also a doctor and a priest. It is true that on the afternoon of the 15th a petition for a pardon had been sent to the King and Emperor, drafted half-heartedly by the court-appointed defence counsel, given the unlikelihood that it would be considered within such a derisory timeframe and, above all, because, as the commander of the XVII Army Corps in Rome, General Augusto Barbieri, objected, “said sentence could not be the subject of a royal pardon”.
She had never been to school but spoke five languages. She had abandoned her two daughters and her husband, yet she looked to the future as someone who still has everything to play for
Laura D’Oriano’s demise was the result of her naivety: she did not think she had done anything serious, and perhaps she had not. Rather, strange as it may seem, it was her zealous cooperation that led to her death. The documents examined at the Central State Archives detail a remarkable story, briefly touched upon in specialist literature. She was the only woman to be shot in Italy for espionage during the war. She was no Mata Hari, but she was beautiful – or so it seems from three different passport photographs. She had not attended university but spoke five languages. She was simple-minded, yet she knew how to seduce. She had abandoned her two daughters and her husband, but she looked to the future as someone who still had everything to play for; the bleaker the present, the more splendidly she dreamt of tomorrow.
When he was arrested on 27 December 1941, he had just turned thirty. Carabinieri Captain Ettore Saraco, of the Turin Territorial Legion, likened his situation to that of other spies recruited by British intelligence via the French Deuxième Bureau, which continued to operate from a centre in Marseille even after the 1940 armistice with Italy: “Broadly speaking, this centre,” he explains in his statement to the Special Court, “recruits our compatriots who, whether because they lack the means to support themselves, or because they do not hold a residence permit in France, or because they are known to be anti-fascists, are veritable human wrecks adrift.” Laura confessed how she had ended up in that situation on 29 December during her first interrogation. Her statement filled 23 pages. She was arrested at Littoria station – now known as Latina – whilst travelling in third class on the direct train taking her from Rome back to Naples after spending Christmas with her family.
His espionage mission consisted of reporting on which military vessels were in the ports of Genoa and Naples. He sent an initial letter from the Ligurian capital to a man in his network, the travel agent Emilio Brayda in Turin. The parcel contained a second envelope which Brayda was to deliver to Aldo Rossetti, an Italian naturalised as a French citizen residing in Modane, regarded by investigators as a ‘man of few scruples’. The information, hidden between the lines of a harmless ‘plaintext’ message, was written using a solution of water and salt in conventional graphic symbols that became legible when the sheets were held close to a heat source. Laura has received no training whatsoever. They sent her off without a second thought as to whether they might lose her. She is unaware that Captain Saraco’s men intercepted the letter the moment she posted it, for ever since she arrived – alerted by an informant – they have not let her out of their sight. She had crossed the border illegally during the night of 11–12 December and had stopped for a meal at the Croce Bianca hotel in Cesana, presenting a forged identity card in the name of a certain Laura Fantini, resident in Turin. She had then made her way to Genoa. Counter-intelligence, having checked the document’s number, had already established that it was a forgery.
Saraco’s usual tactic is not to corner his prey straight away, but to pounce at the right moment. In Genoa, the tailers report that on 14 December, Laura “made a visit outside the port, then went to Corso Oddone – a ring road – from where there is a full panoramic view of the port; she stopped for some time to observe and note down the characteristics of the cruiser ‘Bolzano’, which was undergoing repairs in the ‘delle Grazie’ dock”.
The second stop is Naples. Laura arrives by train in the city ravaged by bombing. British aircraft strike after dusk, but at 4:45 p.m. on 4 December 1942 there was the first daytime attack by the Americans, and the number of casualties is impossible to pinpoint: ranging from 286 to 900. Collective memory tells of people decapitated by the blast waves who walk a little further before collapsing. She is staying at the Pensione Lombardi and spends Monday the 15th strolling about and at the Cinema Umberto, in the Galleria where, during the previous world war, another, far more astute spy had been lurking: the British agent Ashenden, portrayed with autobiographical traits in William Somerset Maugham’s novel of the same name. The following day she visits the harbour, strikes up a conversation with a railway worker, returns to the guesthouse, and then leaves again. She asks the landlady to keep her room for when she returns from Rome after Christmas and pays eight days’ rent in advance: 144 lire. In the afternoon, she goes to church to pray ‘for about 20 minutes’ and in the evening she returns to the cinema, this time at the Santa Brigida, where they are showing an English film from seven years earlier: The Clairvoyant by Maurice Elvey, released in Italy as L’uomo che vide il futuro, starring Claude Rains. On the morning of the 17th, she leaves for Rome on the seven o’clock train. From the capital, he will send his second letter to Agent Brayda: whilst in the first he had reported to Genoa the presence of a cruiser undergoing repairs and four MAS boats – the armed torpedo motorboats – in the second he specifies that the steamship ‘Roma’ is also in the shipyard; he then adds the information gathered in Naples, where he had seen the torpedo boat ‘Cosenz’ and two hospital ships, but intends to return there to investigate further.
Emilio Brayda and his accomplice Aldo Rossetti, to whom the Turin “postman” was supposed to deliver Laura’s letters, received relatively lenient sentences.
If Laura is going to Rome, it is to meet her mother, Aida Agnese, because the D’Oriano family have recently moved to the capital, to 83 Largo Brancaccio. Hers is a happy, impromptu Christmas visit, but it allows the Royal Carabinieri to finally ascertain the spy’s true identity. That address corresponds to an Umbertine-era building where the surnames on the intercoms now bear witness to the changes in the Esquilino district: flats 1 and 17 are registered to Chinese residents, flat 24 to an Arab, and there is a B&B, but perhaps the magnolia trees out front are the same as they were back then.
Laura spends her time with her family or out for a walk, “always accompanied by a relative, though”. It is the first time she has set foot in Rome. It is cold; she buys some Nivea hand cream and tells her mother that she came to Italy on false documents to see her again, as she was not granted a visa. They have an argument because Aida Agnese wants to sort the matter out at the police station.
This is the second Christmas of the war, and Pope Pius XII’s speech irritates the Duce because of its references against dictatorships. Mussolini, as Galeazzo Ciano notes in his diary, displays a resurgence of anti-religious sentiment: ‘Certainly,’ he tells him, ‘I am the man in the world who feels these occasions the least’. “However,” adds Ciano, “this year the churches are overflowing with people.” The D’Orianos attend Mass at Santa Maria Maggiore. Two days later, Laura will be arrested.
On the second Christmas of the war, the D’Orianos attend Mass at Santa Maria Maggiore. Two days later, Laura will be arrested
His biography highlights the story of a cosmopolitan family – whether by necessity or inclination – torn between artistic aspirations and material needs. A lineage that set out from Pozzuoli for the East: his father, Policarpo, was born Laura in Turkey, in Smyrna, in 1886. The children born of his marriage to Aida Agnese Caruana bear witness to this wandering destiny: after Laura, Maria was born in Naples in 1919; Vittorio Emanuele in Brindisi in 1923; Umberto in 1926 in Smyrna; and Maria Teresa in Marseille in 1929.
This, if the interrogation transcript has not distorted it too much, is Laura’s account of her past: “A few years after I was born, I followed my family to Russia. My father and mother were musicians and at that time they travelled to give concerts. When the war with Russia broke out in 1914, my family came to Italy; they then moved to Smyrna. They also stayed in Greece; but I cannot recall whether this was before or after we went to Smyrna. Following the Greco-Turkish War, my family returned to Italy, settling in Brindisi. After about two years, they returned to Smyrna, where they remained until around 1928 or 1929. In Smyrna, my father ran a musical instrument shop. As it was impossible for him to continue his business due to the restrictions imposed on all foreigners by the Turkish authorities, my family moved to Marseille, where my father opened a grocery shop. In Marseille, she became engaged to Emil Fraunholz, who was born in Bottigaffen (Switzerland), she believes in 1907–1908. At that time, he was an accountant at an import and export firm. She married in Marseille on 18 August 1931 and moved with her husband to Grasse, where they opened a grocery shop. The couple lived together for approximately five years and had two daughters, now aged 10 and 9. The children are currently staying with their paternal grandparents in Bottigaffen. Following persistent disagreements, the marriage ended in separation in 1936. Fraunholz returned to Switzerland, while Laura remained in Nice, to which they had moved from Grasse. My family had left France in 1934, returning to Italy, and I did not know where they had settled. As a foreigner, I was not entitled to work in France, so I began trading in ladies’ hats and various items of women’s clothing. From Nice, towards the end of 1938, she moved to Paris, where she managed to find work as a sales representative for the Elevator factories, which manufactured tools for bricklayers. She remained with that company until the outbreak of the Franco-German war. Following the outbreak of the war, the company ceased all operations, so I decided to leave Paris and go to Sospel to stay with a friend of mine, Giovanna Bourgeois. It was there that I received news of my mother for the first time.” Sospel—known as “Sospello” in Italian—became a zone of hostilities after France was declared war on, so Laura set off again for Nice. Like a shrub tossed about in the whirlwind of the world.
His biography highlights the story of a cosmopolitan family – whether by necessity or inclination – torn between artistic aspirations and material needs
It was not until 23 November 1942, shortly before the trial, that the Attorney General’s Office requested information about Laura’s family. The Carabinieri are more efficient than the police: the Royal Carabinieri Station in Piazza Iside replied that, as of 1 October, the D’Orianos had moved again, from the capital to Modena. Little is known about her father Policarpo, who is in Albania ‘on duty’. The station commander points out, however, that the family “during their brief and sporadic stay in Rome behaved well”. Curiously, the report from the Royal Police Headquarters contradicts the Carabinieri and fails to mention that the D’Orianos had left; regarding Laura, it states that “the highly confidential investigations carried out have revealed her to be a person of dubious moral and political conduct. Information is also being gathered regarding the family members who recently arrived here and are staying at 83 Largo Brancaccio, and this information is by no means edifying’. These conflicting accounts would not have altered the course of the trial.
How did Laura become a spy? A brief recap is in order. In Nice, where she was working as a typist for the owner of a cutlery shop, she was approached by ‘a Jew, a certain Benderly, who, having worked in the special police force for foreigners, might have been able to resolve my situation’. She was the ideal recruit: a Swiss citizen, a foreigner in France and Italy – countries she could not enter without a visa; in dire straits; multilingual, alone, attractive and adventurous. In January 1941, Benderly took her to a certain Cotoni, who asked her if she was willing “to do a little something” and gave her 300 francs; by April, she had been paid a further 2,000 and 2,500 francs. The arrangement was like a matryoshka doll, because in June she was introduced to another agent, Monsieur Darin, who directed her to a certain Sablairolle. Her first mission was to Bordeaux, in occupied France, to spy on the Royal Italian Navy’s Betasom base, from where she would send coded postcards. She stayed there from July to September, receiving money on several occasions: one instalment of 4,000 francs, and two of 5,000. Once the mission was over, her superiors announced that they would send her to Italy, but the journey was delayed by Laura’s appendicitis, and Darin paid for her hospital treatment. Before she left, on 6 December, she was introduced in Marseille to the deus ex machina of British intelligence in France: the mysterious ‘Cosic’, a name well known to Italian counter-intelligence.
His espionage mission was to report on which military vessels were in the ports of Genoa and Naples. He had received no training whatsoever
Lulù is the nickname by which Louise Fremont – alias Laura Fantini – alias Laura D’Oriano – is known in Bordeaux. She passes herself off as a widowed artist and befriends a Genoese labourer, Italo Landini, who works at the base and shares accommodation with two colleagues. Lulù resorts—who knows whether reluctantly or unscrupulously—to the key that unlocks men’s hearts, prompting Landini to invite her to move in with them. When questioned by counter-intelligence, the three will insist that Lulù never asked any questions but seemed well-informed about the movements of the submarines, perhaps because she was eavesdropping on conversations in cafés. The workers were cleared of all charges, even though, according to Captain Saraco, ‘there would be a charge of negligent aiding and abetting against all of them; but such liability vanishes due to the impossibility of determining the exact extent of the negligence’.
She tried to play down the matter: “If I acted wrongly, I did not do so out of hatred, but simply because I was swept along by the very life I was leading. So, both in Bordeaux and in Italy, I gave my principals very little information. Proof that I did very little is that, during my stay in Italy, I wrote only two letters containing scant information, some of which was inaccurate.” Very little, very little: she repeated this to the Deputy Attorney-General Giuseppe Calzetti, who questioned her on 2 December 1942 and did not believe her: “There is no doubt,” he wrote in the indictment, “that the disclosure of information regarding the Bordeaux base could have compromised the State’s war effort and military operations, not only as a potential threat, but also, in the case in question, as an actual occurrence, given that during D’Oriano’s stay in Bordeaux, two or three submarines had failed to return, and that shortly after her departure, four or five vessels had not returned either”. It is paradoxical to think that it was she herself who had candidly revealed the events in Bordeaux to her interrogators.
“If I acted wrongly, I did not do so out of hatred. Proof that I did very little is that (...) in Italy I wrote only two letters containing little news and, in part, inaccurate information.”
In the summer of ’42, whilst Laura was in prison, Eiar released La canzone dei sommergibili “taciti ed invisibili” (The Song of the ‘Silent and Invisible’ Submarines), with lyrics by Guglielmo Giannini and music by Mario Ruccione, composer of Faccetta nera, La sagra di Giarabub and Camerata Richard (in the role of the soldier Primo Arcovazzi, Ugo Tognazzi sings that tune in the film Il federale). The situation at sea was far less inspiring: as early as 13 December 1941, whilst Laura was strolling through Genoa, Ciano wrote in his diary that “the Navy’s losses are growing more severe by the day and that one must now ask oneself whether, by any chance, the Navy’s war will not last much longer”. Now, however, whilst Laura was in prison, matters had truly taken a turn for the worse: ‘On 1 January 1943, I met a friend, and we exchanged melancholy New Year’s greetings. “This year begins on a Friday, and to top it all, there’s the comet too”’: this is the opening line of Paolo Monelli’s Roma 1943. The loss of Libya, the aerial bombardments and the dire news from Russia all foreshadowed defeat.
Perhaps she knows nothing of it, or perhaps a faint echo of the outside world reaches her even in her cell. In the face of justice, the worst thing is uncertainty. The Special Tribunal is a Moloch lurking within the Palazzaccio: ‘The secrecy of the preliminary investigation prevents the effective right to a defence: right up until a few days before the trial, the defendants remain unaware of the basis for the charges. By the time they appear in court, everything has already been decided’, recalls Mimmo Franzinelli in Il Tribunale del Duce. In the absence of accounts of Laura’s imprisonment, we turn to those who endured a similar experience, even though the offence – anti-national activities – was less serious and the case concluded with a lenient sentence followed by a pardon. Luigi Ugolini, a writer and journalist from a distinguished Florentine family, had far more extensive connections and cultural resources at his disposal than Laura did; yet in his memoir Regina Coeli, published in 1970, he effectively conveyed the slow torment: “I spend long hours on childish horoscopes. Everything is a matter of divination; from everything I draw auspicious and inauspicious omens: from the page number I am reading, from that of a page opened at random. Sometimes a number recurs, with diabolical insistence, that terrifies me. I read calmly… suddenly I glance up at the page number and it is a thirteen or a seventeen, or the sum of the digits adds up to that number. And even the number of my cell, 458, when broken down into its factors, does it not total seventeen? I cannot read the words ‘death sentence’ without a shudder of horror”.
There were only a few hours between the verdict and its enforcement. The Special Court’s verdicts were final: they became legally binding as soon as they were handed down
We know nothing of Laura’s personal circumstances; she was served with the charge by the Court on 7 December 1942. The hearing, originally scheduled for the middle of the month, was postponed to 15 January 1943, and only now does she have the opportunity to exercise her right to a defence. Someone suggests Mario Pittaluga, a solicitor with a practice in Via Tacito who acts before the Court of Cassation. Meanwhile, the Special Court continues to work through the backlog of cases with which it is overwhelmed because, following the outbreak of the war, in addition to offences relating to state security, it has been tasked with dealing with common offences if committed in circumstances arising from the war situation. The Central Archives preserve records of its swift and frenzied activity between December ’42 and January ’43, about which the President of the Court, Antonino Tringali-Casanuova, duly informed the Duce’s private secretariat. Even cases of violence could be removed from the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts depending on the time at which they occurred, such as those taking place at night, as they were facilitated by the wartime blackout. Six days before Laura’s sentencing, Sebastiano D’Orazio – a maniac who had struck between 23 and 31 August 1942 near the Foro Mussolini – was sentenced to 30 years. The first time, at half past midnight, he attacked a woman in her forties with a blow to the head; the second time, he attempted to rape a domestic worker and beat her with a stick.
The documents examined at the Central State Archives detail a remarkable story (photo: Central State Archives)
The documents examined at the Central State Archives detail a remarkable story (photo: Central State Archives)
Surely someone must now have made Laura D’Oriano aware of what lies ahead. On 26 December, Pittaluga refused the appointment, but the President of the Court appointed him ex officio, even though the defendant’s fate is sealed for after Epiphany – by which time the nativity scene will certainly have been taken down. The story would end here were it not for the fact that a look at the supporting characters might still teach us something.
What became of Brayda, the ‘postman’ from Turin, and his accomplice Rossetti?
They could not have got off more lightly. Rossetti was sentenced to 15 years but served only a fraction of his sentence: he is said to have escaped from Castelfranco Emilia prison in 1944 and subsequently benefited from an amnesty. Brayda was even acquitted due to lack of evidence, despite the fact that, according to the Deputy Attorney General, he had “full awareness that he was aiding the enemy, given the clandestine nature of the correspondence’s transmission” and “the sheer volume of such correspondence, originating from a wide variety of sources”. There must therefore have been a very solid reason for sparing him from such overwhelming evidence, namely that he had collaborated with counter-intelligence by playing a double game imposed on him by Captain Saraco. Arrested on 22 January 1942, he had been released after forty-eight hours: “In order not to compromise another important operation that had taken shape in the meantime and in which it was necessary for Brayda to continue acting as a courier”, reported the Royal Carabinieri’s report, “it was necessary to release him on bail and with the necessary precautions”. On his own initiative, he passed on to the enemy around ten letters, “all containing ‘sanitised’ information”.
Saraco used two adjectives to describe Brayda: ‘cunning and experienced’. Two qualities endowed with the magical power to override merits and faults, talents and shortcomings, thereby decreeing victory when it is less plausible than defeat, and success in place of disaster. Or the firing squad.