Culture
IN BOOKSHOPS •
Douglas & D’Alema. A comparative reading of the actor’s and the politician’s memoirs
After a few pages, if one were to swap ‘Hollywood’ for ‘Botteghe Oscure’ and the ‘Oscars’ for the ‘Central Committee’, the text would appear to be the same book. It is possible they employ the same ghostwriter.

Photo: Lapresse
As is customary for those who write for newspapers, I receive a steady stream of books accompanied by requests for reviews; they arrive, accumulate, and remain unopened for weeks while I pretend not to notice. This week, at the top of the pile were the biographies of Michael Douglas (One Helluva Ride) and Massimo D’Alema (Eravamo comunisti). To make the most of them, I read them together. After a few pages, swapping Hollywood for Botteghe Oscure and the Oscars for the Central Committee, they seemed like the same book to me – perhaps they have the same ghostwriter.
As in many memoirs, such as Open – the model for all biographies aiming to become bestsellers – neither young Michael nor young Massimo truly chose their own destiny: in certain families, one’s calling is not selected; it is simply there, something one breathes in from childhood. The question becomes whether one will manage to do better than one’s Overbearing Father. On one side is Spartacus: Kirk Douglas, born Issur Danielovitch, son of a Jewish second-hand dealer who emigrated from Tsarist Russia, who started from nothing and rose to the heights of Hollywood by devoting himself to cinema – body, soul and dimple on his chin. On the other side is Giuseppe D’Alema, partisan, Communist MP, whose body, soul and class consciousness were devoted to the Party. At the age of eight, Michael found himself on a Vincente Minnelli film set. At eleven, Massimo was haranguing the Pioneers and Togliatti declared: ‘This isn’t a child, he’s a dwarf’ (the very same thing the coach said at Maradona’s first trial). 1950s Hollywood and the Italian Communist Party (PCI) are much alike: anyone who slips up ends up on the blacklist, expelled, struck off, and in both cases, your friends stop saying hello. Michael and Massimo grow up in a small, closed world, where everything passes through a single filter – cinema or communism – and they soon learn that private life is a minor genre. Then came their apprenticeship: Michael played a policeman on the TV series "The Streets of San Francisco", whilst Massimo served as secretary of the FGCI. Their encounters with the big names went as they are bound to go in memoirs – that is, badly: D’Alema answered the phone rudely to a stranger who introduced himself with, “I’m Berlinguer, if I’m not disturbing you.” The most Hollywood-esque scene, however, is his own: Fidel Castro meets the young communists in a nightclub, arrives armed and lays his belt on the table before launching into his speech.
I delve into the stories of these two great families, and after a while the headlines start to blur: “In Pursuit of the Bicameral Commission”, “The Jewel of Gallipoli”, “Party Instinct”, “Qualcuno volò su Palazzo Chigi” (produced by Michael Douglas, with his father originally intended to play Jack Nicholson’s role). Douglas becomes President of the United States in 1995 (“The President – A Love Story”). D’Alema arrives at Palazzo Chigi in 1998, without a love story. And of course “The War of the Roses”, which on the left has always been on repeat: Massimo versus Walter. Douglas was never Tom Hanks, the American everyman. He was the one who made mistakes, who strayed into the grey areas, who gave in to Glenn Close, who proclaimed that greed is good and right. D’Alema has never been Veltroni, the Forrest Gump of the left: he is the one who made deals, who came to terms with the dark corners of the left, whom you see today in the front row at Chinese military parades. The Bicameral System is his ‘Fatal Attraction’. Whilst courting Catherine Zeta-Jones, Douglas was seeing five other women in five different cities. We don’t know about D’Alema – though he does admit that many people disliked him, and that on the left he is seen as a model of sex appeal. Today, Douglas spends half the year in Mallorca, by the sea. D’Alema makes wine in Umbria and goes sailing. Veltroni and Elly Schlein were present at the launch of D’Alema’s memoir: “It’s a story to which we owe a great deal, but mass parties will never return,” says Elly. Just like the old Hollywood of Kirk and Michael Douglas.
