The competition for the extension of the Gallery has been a success, despite the (usual) controversy

386 participants from 29 different countries, including many of the world’s finest architectural practices, amongst them several Italian firms. A source of pride for the capital, which has the opportunity to experience the kind of beautiful architecture that enhances cities all over the world
16 NOV 26
Last updated: 08:57
Translated by AI
Image of The competition for the extension of the Gallery has been a success, despite the (usual) controversy

Photo: Lapresse

Taking part in the competition for the extension of the Galleria Borghese is the best response to the far-fetched controversies that have accompanied the conception of the idea. There were 386 entrants from 29 different countries, including many of the world’s finest architectural practices, amongst them several Italian firms. The Borghese Gallery, one of the world’s most exceptional museums both for the works it houses and for the architectural and landscape setting that surrounds them, is naturally also one of the most visited. The waiting list is extremely long – visitors must book months in advance – and numerous works remain confined to the cellars due to a lack of space. Hence the idea arose to expand the exhibition spaces and launch an international design competition. Proger, Italy’s leading engineering firm, offered to fund the competition at a cost of around 1 million, making it clear that it would not be involved in any stage of the potential construction. So why did it do this? Because, fortunately, there are still those who believe in good ideas and in the enhanced reputation that comes with them. All hell broke loose. Controversy was not long in coming, in the name of the sanctity of Villa Borghese, the large urban park that houses the Gallery.
Prominent figures in the controversy include, on the right, Fabio Rampelli, a long-standing member of Fratelli d’Italia and rumoured to be a candidate for mayor of Rome, and, on the left, Tomaso Montanari, accompanied by the usual suspects: Italia Nostra, the Greens, the Five Star Movement and AVS. The arguments put forward? Just one: nothing must be touched because Villa Borghese is untouchable. In short, the stance is one of conservation and nothing more. Now, given that no one intends to tamper with the historic building housing the Gallery – being a listed monument subject to strict conservation restrictions – there are abandoned buildings and areas – the upkeep of the Villa leaves rather much to be desired – where architectural intervention could only improve the situation. Yet the diverse coalition opposing the project—without even having seen the design that will emerge from the competition—is therefore opposing not a concrete, possible realisation, but the mere emergence of ideas. This is an obscurantist attitude stemming from a total distrust of the creative capacities of contemporary culture and from a stubborn attachment to the past and to the immutability of history and the landscape. The extent of the damage this approach has already caused in Italy can be seen in the projects that were only finally realised after years and decades of controversy.
From Venice’s Mose project to the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline (TAP), which has provided us with some protection from the gas crisis. Villa Borghese is not a strictly protected nature reserve. It is a collection of green spaces – some landscaped, others more wild – along with avenues and buildings. It is the result of numerous developments carried out over different periods, including the construction of the building that now houses the Gallery. In subsequent periods, the Museum of Modern Art, the zoological garden (now a biopark), Piazza di Siena and the riding school, the children’s cinema, the Globe Theatre and the Casa del Cinema were built. To be honest, not all of these are works of unquestionable beauty, but they nevertheless enrich the visitor experience. It is an urban park that is visited, walked through, used and enjoyed. A piece of the city. Today, the Borghese Gallery is probably its finest jewel, attracting hundreds of thousands of visitors; making it even more accessible, with spaces that allow a wider audience to admire the treasures housed in its cellars, is first and foremost an act of cultural democracy. The fact that the world’s leading architectural firms have responded to its call is a source of pride for the capital, which now has the opportunity to experience the kind of beautiful architecture that enhances cities across the globe. The real challenge at this stage will be selecting, from among so many qualified firms, those to be invited to the next phase – the one in which the actual designs must be submitted. There is bound to be controversy surrounding both those excluded and those accepted. But this is also the beauty and the inevitable aspect of any competition.