Spirit and decree. When Pope Symmachus decided that only the clergy could elect the Vicar of Christ

In 499, the Pope restricted the electoral college by excluding all the city’s faithful. However, the idea that a Pope could designate his own successor did not gain traction. And in the decades that followed, those designated – where there were any – were not automatically elected
20 NOV 26
Translated by AI
VATICAN CITY, VATICAN – 15 MARCH: A general view of St Peter’s Basilica and the Vatican at dusk ahead of the evening rosary prayer service for the health of Pope Francis on 15 March 2025 in Vatican City, Vatican. Pope Francis was hospitalised in Rome on

Photo: Getty

21 November 496. Gelasius I, an African born in Rome, died. Amidst discussions on the relationship between spiritual and temporal power, he wrote a letter to the Eastern Emperor Anastasius I which would provide the starting point for every debate throughout the Middle Ages. It is worth reading an excerpt: “There are two things upon which this world is sustained: the sacred authority of the popes and royal power. Of these, the authority of the priests carries far greater weight, for they must answer to God even for the kings of men… Even though, by virtue of your dignity, you are the head of the human race…, in religious matters you must submit… and it is you who are dependent on the judgement of the priests’. It was not the emperor, therefore, but the Pope of Rome who was Christ’s spokesperson on earth; indeed, according to a phrase that first appeared in Gelasius’s own time, he was the ‘Vicar of Christ’. The emperor’s task is to learn, not to teach, what is Christian. It is no wonder – it seems to me – that someone has described Pope Gelasius’s letter as the Magna Carta of the medieval papacy.
22 November 498. The Sardinian Symmachus was elected; he was the first Pope to establish, by decree (in 499), rules for the election of his successors. He took this decision because, on the day of his election, a minority of the clergy had put forward the archpriest Lorenzo as a rival candidate. Symmachus’s document restricted the electoral college by excluding the city’s laity: only the clergy could elect the new Pope by majority vote, whilst the populus (represented by the city’s leading figures, who were almost entirely the same as the members of the Senate) was tasked with approving the elected candidate by acclamation. The idea, however, that a Pope could designate his own successor did not gain traction. And in the decades that followed, those designated by the Popes – where such designations occurred – were not automatically elected.
26 November 399. Siricius, a Roman, died. Like his predecessor Damasus, with whom he had long collaborated, he was deeply aware of his role as successor to Peter and of the primacy of the Church of Rome. Of particular significance is a letter he wrote in 385 addressed to Bishop Imerius of Tarragona, in which he addresses various issues, from the baptism of heretics to clerical celibacy, not merely offering advice or expressing opinions, but issuing definitive rulings with authority. The letter is written in the same style as the decrees that the emperor sent to the provincial governors, which constituted legal sources—that is, they had the force of law and were regarded as precedents that could subsequently be invoked in similar cases. Siricius’s letter is therefore regarded as the first papal ‘decretal’ and concludes by stating that his decisions (which he specifically terms decretalia) must be observed on a par with conciliar canons, urging Imerius not only to apply them in his diocese but also to inform all neighbouring bishops in Spain, Africa and Gaul of them.