Religion
"QUE VIVA CRISTO!" •
The gulf between the Pope’s message and the demands of the declining European Churches
It is not difficult to see how far apart these words are from the claims made, for example, by the Church in Germany: the paths taken by the German bishops and the Pope are diametrically opposed

Rome. “Long live Christ! Long live the Virgin Mary! Long live the Catholic Church!”, shouted Leo XIV late in the evening from the balcony of the nunciature in Lima, before a jubilant and prayerful crowd who responded “Long live!”. Summarising more than thirty speeches across three countries is a daunting task. One thing that is clear, however, is the gulf that separates Leo XIV’s preaching from the ‘movement-driven’ demands of those Churches which do not merely call for reforms and modernisation, but which set out to subvert the very order that governs the Church. They present their ideas – at times amounting to ultimatums – under the banner of ‘synodality’ in its broadest sense, a catch-all term into which anything can be placed (Leo, however, in the briefest of his addresses in South America, clearly explained what true synodality is). In Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, the Pope emphasised the need to give fresh impetus to mission and evangelisation, in the name of Christ. He said this everywhere, on every occasion, even when speaking off the cuff. At the Pampas de Pimentel, he said that “the world awaits us and the mission is only just beginning”. For this reason, I invite you – right from this first celebration of our gathering before the Lord’s altar – here in Chiclayo and throughout Peru, to commit yourselves to sharing the living hope that is Jesus Christ, and to let the Gospel ‘overflow’ into our villages, towns and cities, so that we may proclaim the glory of the Lord to all. May the intercession of Our Lady of Evangelisation assist us in the task of proclaiming the Good News to all creation”. The same Pontiff who, in Florida, Uruguay, said: “Dear parents and grandparents, young people need to see you praying, drawing close to the sacraments, treating your wives with respect, asking for forgiveness and living honestly even when this requires sacrifice. A child learns a great deal by seeing that his father knows how to kneel before God without feeling any less of a man for doing so.”
It is not difficult to see just how far apart these words are from the claims made, for example, by the Church in Germany: the paths taken by the German bishops and the Pope are diametrically opposed. Whilst on the banks of the Rhine there has for years been a constant cycle of planning, studying, overturning, innovating and criticising (the usual Rome, of course), on the other side of the world Leo XIV invites us to view matters from a diametrically opposed perspective. This, in fact, is not too dissimilar to what Pope Francis set out in writing in June 2019 in his letter to the People of God on their journey in Germany, a document in which he warned that “wrapped up in a series of inevitable analyses, (…) we may end up going round in circles in a complicated game of arguments, disquisitions and resolutions that will do nothing but distance us from real, day-to-day contact with the faithful and the Lord”. This is precisely what has happened, given that the most high-profile outcome of the Synodale Weg is a Synodal Conference comprising more laypeople than bishops, which has not yet received the go-ahead from Rome (it was due to make its grand debut in November, but everything has been postponed indefinitely). Restructuring, updating and innovating are certainly possible, but we must never forget the fundamentals. Evangelise, be missionaries, go out and pray too, says the Pope. Que viva Cristo!, indeed.
More on these topics
Friulsardo, è nato nel 1986. Laureato in politica internazionale e diplomazia a Padova con tesi su turchi e americani, è stato arbitro di calcio. Al Foglio dal 2011, si occupa di Chiesa, Papi, religioni e libri. Scrittore prediletto: Joseph Roth (ma va bene qualunque cosa relativa alla finis Austriae). È caporedattore dal 2020.
