At the time, they were referred to as ‘transitional provisions’. A sign that at some point they were meant to disappear, a sign that they are written in a different ink from that of the principles and cornerstones of civil life – understood as the blueprint for democracy and the rights and duties of citizenship, enshrined in the Constitution. I am referring to the ban on fascism. Now, on the basis of some appeal or other, an activist public prosecutor’s office has emerged: General Vannacci and his party are said to represent an attempt to reconstitute the National Fascist Party, according to the very wording of the ‘transitional’ provisions which, in a couple of decades, will mark a full century since their introduction. The fact is, however, that no one really believes in the seriousness of the accusation, its relevance to the present day, or its historical significance.
It is one thing to incite squadrist violence and a spirit of anti-Bolshevik and anti-working-class struggle in Italy in the early 1920s, to foreshadow and then establish a regime founded on the suppression of democracy and the murder of opponents – socialists, communists and liberals; It is quite another to orchestrate, in a country disciplined, regimented and indoctrinated through farcical procedures and the cult of personality, colonial imperialism, biological racism and devastating wartime alliances in Europe. It is one thing to publish, at one’s own expense, a useless book full of reactionary and generally intolerant drivel; to enjoy a successful stint aboard the most ramshackle vessel in Italian politics – that of Senator Salvini; and finally to strike out on one’s own and enter the race for votes in the general election, keeping an eye on the polls and those minuscule percentages to influence the dynamics of the political establishment.
Three giants of Italian politics and culture – Bettino Craxi, Marco Pannella and Renzo De Felice – at a certain point in their careers came out with the idea of abolishing anti-fascism as a rhetorical relic and legal-constitutional scrap, doing away with its most ephemeral provisions. Whether ‘The Flame’ was meant to warm Mussolini’s grave or the roots of fascism was, historically speaking, an unenforceable legacy, a dreamlike fiction, even back when, in Fiuggi, the Italian Social Movement – born of a constitutional and political-parliamentary compromise – was dissolved and replaced by a conservative coalition that ‘left the father’s house’.
And that Pino Rauti, whose alleged affinity with terrorism and anti-democratic ideology – which he openly espoused – is now being invoked for propaganda purposes, broke with the Fiuggi faction and resigned himself to an honourable and consistent decline as the political and spiritual leader of the defeated, having served as a Member of Parliament for twenty years and, upon his death, celebrated and remembered in the very same vein as the exhibition now at the centre of the scandal. There are so many trails to follow, so many holes to dig, so many new ideologies to decipher – ranging from more or less tech-driven populisms to new cults of personality and enthusiastic support for the autocracies currently in power – there is much to understand about the enduring appeal exerted on the weakest hearts and minds by the authoritarian spirit and anti-democracy, which now makes one smile at the idea of leaving the anti-fascist spirit and constitutional patriotism to poorly aged, arid and stony transitional laws.