The anti-Semitism bill has become law. The M5S and AVS voted against it, as did the PD. But the reformists abstained.

The motion was passed with 147 votes in favour, 93 against and 5 abstentions. These were the members of the Democratic Party minority, who had voted in favour in the Senate. Merola: “The atmosphere in which today’s debate took place is incomparable to that in the Senate.” +Europa is also split. Vannaccia’s supporters voted “no”.
17 NOV 26
Last updated: 08:01 PM
Translated by AI
Image of The anti-Semitism bill has become law. The M5S and AVS voted against it, as did the PD. But the reformists abstained.
“We are still debating”, “the situation could change”, “no amendments have been approved….”: it is 6.30 pm and the Chamber of Deputies has still not voted on the anti-Semitism bill, which was finally passed with 147 votes in favour, 93 against and 5 abstentions. The evening’s vote will reveal a broad political divide (with the PD, AVS and M5S on one side, and IV, Azione and Più Europa on the other, with the PD reformists in the middle) and will put the PD and the PD reformists themselves to the test (they abstained, unlike their reformist colleagues in the Senate who had voted in favour in March). Among them, the former PD mayor of Bologna, Virginio Merola, tells Il Foglio: “The atmosphere and context in which today’s debate on the anti-Semitism bill is taking place are incomparable to what happened in the Senate. I cannot bring myself to vote in favour alongside this right-wing bloc, because the substance of the issue has vanished whilst fascism is being glorified and FdI is attacking the partisans as cowardly murderers. As a former mayor of Bologna, it is simply not possible for me. I am abstaining because the principle of combating anti-Semitism must be upheld… but I do not wish to do anything else.”
A rift divides the majority and the opposition, placing the PD in an awkward position: in the Chamber of Deputies, where Secretary Elly Schlein sits (and at a time when thematic working groups are multiplying to draw up a broad-based programme that must be kept united at all costs), a firm no is the only option, though not one everyone can stomach. The reformist minority in the Senate’s former ‘yes’ vote has turned into an abstention, a dilemma and a source of anxiety, given that, as is said amongst the Democrats, ‘the majority did not wish to amend the text to secure bipartisan approval, as Liliana Segre had called for in an appeal’. And yet, in words, when everyone already knew that the agreement had long since fallen through, the rhetoric revived it: ‘Stop, let’s find common ground’, had been the opposition’s initial exhortation, with a request to ‘backtrack’ on the definition of antisemitism: not that of the IHRA, but the Jerusalem Declaration.
“We are open to a unanimous vote,” said Augusta Montaruli on behalf of the Meloni supporters. But then the amendments were rejected one by one, and the debate gathered momentum, taking a turn towards increasingly heated rhetoric. Meanwhile, Rossano Sasso, a supporter of Vannacco, went so far as to say that Giovanni Gentile had been murdered “by cowardly communist barbarians” (to which the Democrat Gianni Cuperlo replied: “Fascists! Shut up!”), and the aforementioned doubt weighed heavily on the reformist MPs of the PD: what should they do? Meanwhile, insults, barbs and jibes flew thick and fast.
The crux of the controversy: the aforementioned IHRA definition of antisemitism, which critics see as a potential future tool for curbing free expression of political criticism towards Israel. ‘No to “new McCarthyism”’, said AVS co-leader Nicola Fratoianni, ‘no to “wielding the issue to suppress all dissent”’. Once again, the Futurist Sasso spoke out from the right: “No to an ethics tribunal, no to the thought police”. The Liberal Democrats, led by Luigi Marattin, declared themselves “stunned”: “On the Middle East issue, it is impossible to debate without resorting to personal attacks”. “It is not enough to include the word ‘anti-Semitism’ in the title of the bill if the right to political and moral criticism enshrined in our Constitution is not safeguarded,” said Federico Fornaro of the Democratic Party, whilst also attacking “those who proudly defend the symbol of the Tricolour Flame chosen by the veterans of the Social Republic: today, of all days, we should remember the RSI’s role in the extermination of Italian Jews, which was based on the vile writings of the magazine Sulla difesa della razza.”
The bill’s sponsor and Forza Italia MP Paolo Emilio Russo, ahead of its arrival in the Chamber, had offered reassuring words: “The text was approved with cross-party support and has a positive, educational and preventative value”. However, by evening, Liliana Segre’s hope of seeing her ‘bipartisan’ dream come true had vanished; with the bill dead in the water due to the breakdown of the broad coalition, the issue of the wealth tax was also coming to the fore, further dividing opinion.