Anti-Semitism Bill: an easy vote

It does not suppress the right to criticise, but rather creates a space for rhetorical impunity
17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Anti-Semitism Bill: an easy vote

Photo: Ansa

The much-discussed anti-Semitism bill is due to be put to a vote in the Chamber of Deputies today, two months after receiving the green light from the Constitutional Affairs Committee. The bill, which has already been approved by the Senate, adopts the definition of antisemitism formulated by the IHRA (International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance) and includes a list of examples of antisemitism (such as ‘drawing parallels between Israeli policy and that of the Nazis’). The government, contrary to the opposition’s requests, does not intend to amend the text.
The IHRA, adopted by dozens of countries that are consistently held up as models by opposition groups, defines antisemitism and includes specific examples, such as denying the Jewish people’s right to self-determination, applying double standards to Israel compared with other countries, comparing Israeli policies to those of the Nazis, or the use of classic stereotypes (such as Jewish control of the media, finance or governments). All those forms of hatred that we have seen erupt in the West since 7 October. Adopting the IHRA definition does not mean closing the debate on the Middle East, but recognising that contemporary anti-Jewish hatred has learnt to disguise itself as political criticism and that a democracy has a duty to call it by its name before it becomes accepted as normal. Laws against incitement to racial hatred have existed for decades, and the IHRA simply clarifies when certain statements about Israel cease to be opinions and become expressions of collective hostility. Those who call for its repeal are, in reality, calling for the preservation of a dangerous space of rhetorical impunity. This bill does not protect a foreign government, but rather the very possibility, for Italian and European Jews, of living without being constantly questioned about their loyalty. It is the bare minimum of decency. And decency calls for an easy vote.