Augias was right about the progressives’ timidity regarding 7 October

Who wrote to the editor-in-chief, Claudio Cerasa

20 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Corrado Augias at the ‘Arena Robinson’ event organised by La Repubblica at the Turin Book Fair, 17 May 2025. ANSA/TINO ROMANO
To the Editor – The PD has not been the PD since its leadership allowed an external ‘takeover bid’ that seized control of the party. And its current leadership is not subservient to AVS, the Five Star Movement, the pro-Pal faction and Landini’s CGIL; it is just like them (the co-owners of the takeover bid). Looking at the list of ‘removals’ mentioned in your editorial, and the interviews with Fassino and Fiano, it is difficult to regard this as a ‘stubbornly united’ left-wing camp. And, setting aside socialist reformism – now burnt at the stake like heretics – there is no serious left capable of governing.
Domenico Sugamiele
* * *
To the Editor – The majority’s behaviour may well have been arrogant and insensitive to Liliana Segre’s appeal, as Piero Fassino explained, but it does not justify abstaining on the bill against anti-Semitism. Given the ethical and political significance of the vote, I therefore still fail to understand the decision taken by the five reformist Democratic Party MPs (which, incidentally, differed from that of Italia Viva and Azione). And, perhaps, I prefer not to understand it.
Michele Magno
On the subject of Segre. Corrado Augias, a few months ago on ‘Otto e mezzo’, said he did not agree with the Anti-Semitism Bill, but he based this on a false premise. He said that, as it stood, the bill risked turning criticism of the Israeli government into an act of anti-Semitism. Some time before that, however, Augias had been formidable on the subject of anti-Semitism. And in an interview given to this newspaper, to our own Luca Roberto, he used strong, definitive language against the timidity of the progressive world when it came to defending Israel. That was on 27 October 2023. “With our progressive public opinion, which, just three days after the Hamas attacks, was already quick to say: it’s all Israel’s fault. Well, from this point of view, one could say that the terrorists’ subtle strategy has hit the mark, given that today the focus is solely on Israel’s bombings – with Israel now cast as the perpetrator of the massacres – or on the reckless statements by Defence Minister Gallant, who wanted to cut off supplies of water, fuel and electricity to the Gaza Strip, whilst the reason that triggered those bombings and those statements – namely, the horrors of 7 October – is being forgotten.” He was right.
* * *
To the Editor – In his editorial on defections from the PD – from Fiano to Picierno, from Chinnici to Cottarelli – Claudio Cerasa interprets Elly Schlein’s decision as a minority stance: she is abandoning key aspects of the party’s democratic identity on anti-Semitism, Ukraine, due process and labour. It is a serious criticism, but it looks only within the PD. The real battle, however, is being fought within the political system and the coalition. Schlein took over in 2023 after the PD had hit rock bottom: 18.8 per cent in 2018, 19.1 per cent in 2022. It was the party of the line that Cerasa laments, but that line had already lost: divisions, competition on the left, Meloni’s victory. It is therefore not enough to invoke Veltroni’s majority-oriented approach to demonstrate that going back is the answer. Not least because the system is no longer a majority system. The electoral law passed on 8 October emphasises the proportional nature of the system: it abolishes single-member constituencies, provides for a bonus only if a party secures over 42 per cent, and also gives weight to the votes of coalition lists that fall below the threshold. In such a system, it is not the party running alone that is rewarded, but the one that can hold together a broad coalition. The majority-based approach no longer belongs to a single party: it belongs to the coalition. This is Schlein’s strategy, pursued on two fronts: building the greatest possible unity within the opposition and, at the same time, taking ground away from the M5S and AVS. The figures are not insignificant: the PD has climbed back above 20 per cent, following its 24.1 per cent in the European elections; the M5S stands at 12.6 per cent and AVS at around 6 per cent. The same SWG poll that puts the PD at 20.8 per cent assigns 44.9 per cent to the centre-left; the Youtrend/AGI Supermedia poll places it at 43.3 per cent against 42.6 per cent for the centre-right. These defections, particularly Fiano’s, raise issues that the PD cannot dismiss lightly. Substantive answers are needed. But it is another matter entirely to interpret them as proof that the entire strategy has failed. Every broad coalition pays a price when it comes to taking the clearest stances. The question is whether the overall political balance is positive. Today, based on the figures, it is.
Gennaro Mola
All well and good. But if, after four years in government, we have an Italy in which the ruling coalition is not going into the elections as the clear underdog – something that happens regularly at the end of every parliamentary term – perhaps we should ask ourselves whether the opposition’s dynamic approach has worked, or whether, on the contrary, its shift to the left has penalised it, reinforcing its status as a minority party.