Fiandaca: "De Gennaro crushed by the Caltanissetta magistrates and the press"

The legal expert: “Magistrates should exercise great caution before charging individuals with serious offences or raising suspicions against people whose professional background makes it implausible that they could become suspects or defendants.” On the suicide: “Part of the blame lies with that section of the press which acts as a mouthpiece for judicial investigations.”

21 NOV 26
Last updated: 15:38
Translated by AI
Giovanni Fiandaca (screenshot from a YouTube video by the University of Catania)

Giovanni Fiandaca (screenshot from a YouTube video by the University of Catania)

“Hello?” “Yes, I’ve heard the news…”. The news of Gianni De Gennaro’s suicide – who had been overwhelmed in recent days by the investigation launched by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office as part of the inquiries into the misdirection of the Via D’Amelio case – had been reported by the news agencies just a few minutes earlier. When contacted by Il Foglio, Giovanni Fiandaca, professor emeritus of Criminal Law at the University of Palermo, was already aware of the news. A few seconds of silence, almost as if in contemplation, then the distinguished jurist – whose textbooks have been studied by generations of aspiring lawyers and magistrates – found his voice again. Clear-cut words, directed above all at the work carried out by the public prosecutors in Nisseni, which Fiandaca has criticised in the past: “Criminal justice is a machine of power that can crush people, even before it functions as a safeguard,” says Fiandaca. ‘This is why magistrates should act with great deliberation and caution before charging individuals with serious offences or, in any case, raising suspicions against people whose professional history or well-known personality traits make it implausible, even in the eyes of the public, that they should become suspects or defendants, with media hype that is irreparably damaging to their reputation’.”
Just two weeks ago, Fiandaca, writing in Il Foglio, had once again criticised the investigations “carried out in close and unusual collaboration between the parliamentary Anti-Mafia Commission and the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office” to shed further light on the motives behind the Via D’Amelio massacre. A case, he wrote, “symptomatic of abnormalities and degenerations”, referring to “anomalous procedures”, “moral indictments” and the treatment suffered by two former magistrates, Gioacchino Natoli and Giuseppe Pignatone, accused of a “hardly credible and defamatory offence of aiding and abetting the Mafia – an offence which, moreover, had long since become time-barred and was therefore not subject to investigation”.
It was De Gennaro himself who had ended up in the crosshairs of the Nissa Public Prosecutor’s Office, under investigation for misleading the inquiry – as highlighted in these pages – an inquiry characterised by numerous contradictions, conjectures and even moral judgements. The precautions taken by De Gennaro in his communications with his associates had been compared by the prosecutors to ‘communications via notes that have emerged in the most significant Mafia investigations’. The fact that De Gennaro did not reveal the sources of his information to those close to him led the prosecutors to speak of a “strategy strikingly similar to that adopted by criminal organisations”. Thus, a former senior civil servant, who had played a leading role in the fight against the Mafia in Italy, was compared to Mafia members and criminals.
“It is unacceptable and serious that, even in the written orders, the individuals under investigation in Caltanissetta have actually been branded as perpetrators of mafia-like behaviour, in a surprising and incomprehensible reversal of roles between those associated with the mafia and those who fight it,” says Fiandaca, who in a recent interview had expressed doubts about the investigation into De Gennaro: “The fear is that the prosecutors want to turn the story on its head.”
The legal expert does not hold back in his critical assessment of the media, which, in this case too, have uncritically reported the allegations put forward by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office: “I believe that a share of the responsibility lies with that section of the press which acts as a mouthpiece for judicial investigations without any critical consideration, at least in terms of raising questions,” states Fiandaca. “Unconditional, pre-emptive support for investigations contributes to exacerbating the judicial malaise,” he concludes.