World
in Spain •
Sánchez loses the TV debate with Feijóo. The Socialists’ comeback comes to a halt in front of Spanish households’ fridges
The Prime Minister has abandoned his aggressive tone and appears unusually subdued. Feijóo presses him on the train tragedy, corruption and the cost of living, contrasting inflation with the positive economic figures claimed by the government. Analysts award the victory to the People’s Party leader. But doubts remain as to whether the Spanish Prime Minister’s move was a calculated one

A “coitus interruptus”. That is how political scientist Pablo Simón, of Carlos III University in Madrid, described this morning the manner in which Pedro Sánchez approached Thursday evening’s televised face-to-face debate with the leader of the People’s Party (PP), Alberto Núñez Feijóo, his direct rival in the general election on 29 November. Speaking on Cadena Ser radio, the political scientist was referring to the Socialist leader’s sudden change of strategy – the contrast between the subdued, almost shy and defeatist tone displayed by Sánchez during yesterday’s debate, and an election campaign that had until then been very confident in its ‘comeback’, assertive, aggressive and upbeat. Perhaps too much so, according to those critics who did not appreciate the theatrics and sentimental displays (with his wife, Begoña Gómez, taking centre stage) during the rallies held immediately after the Toledo train tragedy – an issue on which Feijóo inevitably had his opponent on the ropes.
The meeting took place in an atmosphere of extreme courtesy and fair play, it must be said, the sort not seen in televised debates for some time. Perhaps because Spain lacks a long tradition of pre-election face-to-face debates, perhaps because, in the age of social media, there is ever less belief in the ability to overturn the result through an old-fashioned ‘political platform’. And perhaps also because the debate took place on the neutral ground of the Academia de Televisión, a Spanish non-profit organisation that brings together professionals and companies from the audiovisual sector to promote the quality and independence of television. It had been a requirement of the PP to avoid the platform of TVE, the state broadcaster, considered a completely divided stronghold of socialists. This view has recently been reinforced by a number of interviews with Sánchez and former Prime Minister Zapatero, who is now under investigation for corruption.
It should be added that Sánchez was on neutral ground following numerous television appearances that had caused quite a stir. In particular, there was the appearance on a newly launched TV channel (La Séptima), where the young female interviewers did indeed put him on the spot, but with questions such as ‘you’re really handsome, how did you meet your wife?’, whilst the drag queen Samantha Ballentines had just sung ‘good luck to you’ to the tune of Happy Birthday to You, imitating Marilyn with John Fitzgerald Kennedy.
In short, after the ‘weapons of mass distraction’, Sánchez returned to the political arena to address the real issues, which in yesterday’s debate were clearly divided into sections with pre-set time limits: housing, the economy and taxation, social policy and public services, the fight against corruption and democratic renewal, immigration and foreign policy. Speeches were timed and Sánchez never went over his allotted time; indeed, he often allowed himself to be politely interrupted by Feijóo and remained silent in the face of certain direct questions, for example regarding who would have financed his return to the party leadership following his ousting in 2016. He also frequently brought up concepts that were too abstract – perhaps interesting, but far removed from the common understanding. Analysts pointed out that, for those who care, what difference does it make that Spain has signed a cooperation treaty with France or that it is reporting excellent growth figures if inflation stands at 4.9 per cent?
Ultimately, this has always been Sánchez’s problem – the very issue that the left has no qualms about holding up to right-wing governments, and will certainly continue to do so when it returns to opposition: macroeconomics versus microeconomics, the much-maligned GDP versus the high cost of living at the shops (Feijóo referred to the ‘fridge’).
The result is that the vast majority of commentators today are awarding the victory (for what it’s worth, treating the debates as boxing matches) to Feijóo. And of course, since even Sánchez’s opponents acknowledge that he possesses a considerable degree of political cunning, everyone is now debating whether this was a tactical error on the part of his spin doctors or, once again, a skilful manoeuvre that we fail to grasp, but which voters will soon prove they have understood. A photo taken at the end of the programme shows Feijóo surrounded by his aides on the well-lit side of the studio, like a team that has just scored a goal. Sánchez is on the dark side, walking away all on his own. A defeat so blatant that it seems almost too contrived to fit the image of a beautiful loser. But that’s the thing about Sánchez: the Spanish haven’t yet worked out whether he has been underestimated or overrated so far.