World
The Hague •
In the Netherlands, Jetten has averted a crisis, but he’s a bit battered
The tax reform vote has laid bare all the limitations of the minority government: after lengthy negotiations, the leader of D66 has promised a change of direction, but the price will be making concessions to the right

Rob Jetten (photo: ANSA)
The Hague. In recent days, the Netherlands has averted an early government crisis, but Rob Jetten – the youngest prime minister in the country’s history – has emerged from it greatly weakened, as has the government he leads – a minority government formed with the commitment to secure spontaneous majorities on every parliamentary initiative. So far, the experiment had more or less worked: from the new law on cutting nitrogen emissions through to the recent tightening of immigration and asylum policies, the centre-right three-party coalition in government – D66, VVD and CDA – had managed, on each occasion, to secure additional ad hoc support from either its right or its left. However, the scheme fell apart when it came to approving next year’s budget and tax plan. How so? Jetten and the Christian Democrats were confident they could find new revenue for the public purse by raising taxes on large fortunes, and then reinvesting the proceeds to ease the tax burden on labour. A plan which, in the Prime Minister’s calculations, would have met with the natural support of the Pro – the Dutch Progressives, formed this summer from the merger of the Green Left and the Labour Party. And so it proved: last week, the budget bill was passed by the Tweede Kamer by a margin of just two votes. But Jetten had not reckoned with the simultaneous opposition from the VVD, the most conservative component of his government, which, in order to distance itself from the wealth tax, threatened to bring down the government.
Tense days followed, marked by gruelling internal negotiations: on Tuesday, coalition talks dragged on for eight hours. And in the end, they appear to have led to a temporary breakthrough. Jetten announced that “mutual trust has been restored”, assuring that the turmoil of this period “will not happen again”. To this end, he turned to a high-profile institutional figure, particularly to resolve the deadlock on the fiscal front: Sybrand Buma, Vice-President of the Council of State, former adviser to the incoming Jetten government and a veteran politician with a long career within the ranks of the CDA. Everyone in The Hague recognises his skills as a mediator and his expertise in the field. Yet this move has been perceived by Dutch MPs as an admission of vulnerability. Not to mention the potential conflict of interest: it is not yet clear in what capacity Buma will intervene, but if he were to facilitate a financial agreement between the governing parties and the opposition, it would mean remaining involved in the executive’s decision-making process. And the Council of State is, by definition, an independent institution.
This is yet another reason why the underlying problem is that Jetten is responsible for ‘serious errors of judgement’ – as reported by de Volkskrant, though this view is shared unanimously by the local press. In other words, the Prime Minister expressed excessive optimism that securing a parliamentary majority was purely a matter of arithmetic: by adding a certain number of votes to those of the three ruling parties, legislation can be passed and the country governed. In theory. Yet the coalition agreement is not unshakeable; it rests on three political entities that are, in any case, distinct from one another – Jetten’s own D66, in particular, was founded as a liberal-progressive party – and sometimes consensus can falter even from within. As was the case during the drafting of the budget. The other problem is that Jetten has shown he has no plan B up his sleeve: having failed to secure the VVD’s support, the government risked a crisis. This was followed by a swift admission of fault, accompanied by a change of approach for the future. From now on, the Prime Minister stated at a press conference, the coalition will have to secure a majority for its proposals in a different way: starting with a clear agreement between the three parties, upon which external support will only be built subsequently.
Jetten’s leadership has been weakened, and his government will have to start afresh amidst widespread scepticism. There is some additional concern on the part of D66 and their traditional electorate: to mend the rift, it will be necessary to move further to the right. Towards the VVD, but not only – the Dutch political spectrum has gradually shifted, and Jetten’s breakthrough had secured him a precarious lead amongst the conservatives and Geert Wilders’ sovereigntists. A hope that, in the long run, could turn out to be an illusion.