Today in Shenzhen, alongside the General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party, Xi Jinping, and the President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Putin, U.S. President Donald Trump revealed his true understanding of the trilateral summit: “We are truly making history”. He had already said this in June 2019, on the 38th parallel, when, during yet another pointless meeting with the dictator Kim Jong Un, he ‘jumped’ over to the North Korean side, becoming the first sitting US president to set foot in North Korea. The summit between the three leaders lasted ninety minutes – too short for any negotiations of any real substance, but enough to boost the egos of the three leaders who want to decide the fate of the world.
Today’s trilateral summit, which overshadowed the annual proceedings of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC, which concluded with the Shenzhen Outlook – an economic declaration of intent focusing primarily on supply chains and energy security), held primarily symbolic significance for the leaders of China, Russia and the United States: it marked a first step in asserting their central role. In the rhetoric of the European far right and far left (which often converge in ‘red-brown’ ideology, and in Italy even more frequently in Il Fatto Quotidiano), Xi, Putin and Trump represent the failure of Europe and, more broadly, of liberal democracies, with the American president forced to take his seat at the (gigantic) table at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen. But on closer inspection, one can sense the haste with which the successes of authoritarian regimes – and thus Western defeats – are proclaimed. Even the description of Putin as ‘humiliated’ by his staunch ally Xi due to his position in the group photo, deemed degrading, is misleading (in reality, Beijing reserved this ceremonial diplomatic gesture solely for the Japanese Prime Minister, Sanae Takaichi, who was placed at the very back of the line).
The host, Xi Jinping, addressed Putin and Trump using the usual Chinese rhetoric of bullet-pointed lists: “Four points on how great powers can find the right way to coexist”. And within those four points lie the usual empty and contradictory platitudes from Beijing: Xi hopes to promote mutual respect (said by a leadership that shows very little respect for other countries), to recognise “the sovereignty and territorial integrity of others, as well as their different social systems and development paths” (said by a country that illegitimately claims a large part of the Pacific’s waters and refuses to discuss rights and democracy), and finally, to hope for greater economic and trade cooperation because ‘the disruption of industrial and supply chains is not the way forward’ (China was the first country, after the end of the Cold War, to use economic coercion as a negotiating tool; then came Trump with the tariff war). In most Asian countries – as was clearly evident at the previous summit of Southeast Asian leaders in Manila – few still believe in Xi Jinping’s universalist declarations, because they are never followed up by concrete action. China’s influence, crippled by a long-running economic crisis whose true scale remains unknown, has now become a distorted, compromised influence, whilst the United States continues to enjoy long-term credibility: Trump’s volatility is temporary, limited to the lifespan of democracies, as it were. And his personality-driven approach, whilst exploited by Xi and Putin, is one of the reasons why the leaders of China and Russia do not trust him: “All my life I’ve read that you must never let Russia and China form an alliance,” said the American president. “It was one of the fundamental rules of politics and war. Both of them like me, Trump. But what will happen after I’m gone? I can’t tell you that.” The point is that a trilateral summit, although unprecedented, does not change the world, just as the BRICS did not change the world – and yet we have read plenty of editorials that claimed they would.
Trump had arrived in Shenzhen with a proposal to revive the New START treaty, which limits and controls the strategic nuclear arsenals of the United States and Russia, whilst also including China. Xi Jinping agreed to sign a joint commitment on reducing nuclear risks, but repeatedly emphasised his opposition to China’s participation in trilateral negotiations on arsenal control: in order to become a true superpower, China has vastly accelerated the expansion of its arsenal in recent years – now estimated at over six hundred warheads – and the aim is obviously to match the more than five thousand held by Russia and the United States. The summit concluded with a vague joint statement on peace and strategic stability, setting out four points committing the three powers to cooperate on United Nations reform, energy security and, only in general terms, the reduction of nuclear risks. Meanwhile, on the subject of trust, as Donald Trump was leaving the People’s Republic aboard Air Force One, ‘for cybersecurity reasons’, the smartphones and electronic devices used in China were confiscated from his staff and the journalists travelling with him and placed in a Faraday bag to ‘block signals until landing in America’.