World
In Amnesty’s upside-down world •
The ban on the burqa and the anti-Semitism bill are both authoritarian
Amnesty condemns the Islamophobia underlying the measures against the full-face veil and Islamist infiltration, but regards the Anti-Semitism Bill as a threat to freedom of expression. From the campaigns against bans to the award presented to Francesca Albanese, these are the contradictions of an organisation that appears to defend rights depending on who is claiming them

(Photo: Getty)
Perhaps Salman Rushdie is right when he says that “it really does seem as though Amnesty’s leadership suffers from a sort of moral bankruptcy”. It really does seem as though Amnesty never wants to miss an opportunity to take the wrong side. On 10 November, the long-established human rights NGO wrote an open letter to the President of the European Parliament, Roberta Metsola, after Brussels had debated in plenary a landmark resolution on ‘Islamist entryism’ and the Muslim Brotherhood. Amnesty and other NGOs condemn the ‘racism and Islamophobia’ behind the resolution, which was passed by 381 votes (the EPP and the Renew liberals voted together).
A month ago, Amnesty condemned the Italian bill banning the burqa in schools. “We are deeply concerned by Giorgia Meloni’s statements on the ban on the burqa and niqab in schools,” said the NGO. Then came the famous case of the remedy being worse than the disease: “Women have the freedom to wear or not wear whatever they want. This leads us to condemn the compulsory wearing of the veil in Iran or the burqa in Afghanistan, just as we condemn the ban on wearing the hijab in France or elsewhere.”
For Amnesty, a girl’s face is therefore no longer just a face: it is a territory of identity. Concealing it becomes, in an extraordinary semantic and ideological reversal, an ‘act of autonomy’.
Yesterday, Amnesty Italia condemned the Anti-Semitism Bill: “Today is a dark day for freedom of expression. Its application in schools, universities, on social media platforms and in other settings risks creating a climate of intimidation”.
On the burqa, Amnesty therefore invokes a woman’s right to ‘choose’ even when that choice amounts to a complete withdrawal from public view; on anti-Semitism, however, it believes that a fundamental tool for combating it – such as the draft bill approved by Parliament – could stifle dissent. Amnesty zealously protects the freedom to conceal one’s identity, whilst viewing with suspicion any measure aimed at protecting another minority – the Jewish community – from a hatred that has millennia-old roots in Europe and which, since 7 October, has seen a documented surge in incidents. When a cultural practice belongs to non-Western communities, any public restriction is interpreted as ‘Islamophobia’; when the practice involves criticism of a state (Israel) or the protection of a group (Jews), any restriction is denounced as authoritarianism.
Denmark has adopted both the ban on the burqa in schools and the IHRA declaration, the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (like most Western democracies). And whilst Amnesty might well find Denmark a little authoritarian and gloomy, it still ranks first in the world out of 177 countries in all liberal democracy indices.
Moreover, after Amnesty published a hundred-page report on Islamophobia (“Choice and Prejudice: Discrimination against Muslims in Europe”), the NGO refused to produce a similar report on anti-Semitism because, as Amnesty’s UK branch wrote, “unfortunately, we cannot campaign on everything”. Not on everything, but only on what does not seem to fit their ideological agenda.
On 7 December, in Paris, Amnesty will present the UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese with its prestigious ‘Ambassador of Conscience Award’. However, some observers have questioned the decision, given that the same award has previously been bestowed upon figures such as Václav Havel, Nelson Mandela and Malala Yousafzai (Greta Thunberg has also been honoured).
There appears to be an error in Amnesty’s latest press release on the Italian bill. It should be corrected as follows: “Today is a dark day for anti-Semitism”. To some extent, this also holds true for the famous humanitarian flame.
More on these topics
Giulio Meotti è giornalista de «Il Foglio» dal 2003. È autore di numerosi libri, fra cui Non smetteremo di danzare. Le storie mai raccontate dei martiri di Israele (Premio Capalbio); Hanno ucciso Charlie Hebdo; La fine dell’Europa (Premio Capri); Israele. L’ultimo Stato europeo; Il suicidio della cultura occidentale; La tomba di Dio; Notre Dame brucia; L’Ultimo Papa d’Occidente? e L’Europa senza ebrei.
