World
Trump’s Broken America •
Biden’s memoir and the promise that Trumpism has already broken
‘America, Make Me a Promise’ is out – the memoir in which Biden defends his term in office without regret or self-criticism and attacks Trump. But in this account of an America that still believed in its role in the world, the missed opportunity in Ukraine weighs heavily, where the White House’s caution ultimately limited Kyiv’s chances of victory.

(Photo: Getty)
Joe Biden writes, in a commanding tone, the memoir of his presidency of the United States – four years set against the backdrop of the Trump decade, a glimmer that smacks of order and missed opportunities, a painful book for many different and relentless reasons. “America, Make Me a Promise” is published today in Italy by NR Edizioni, coinciding with its release in the US and in many parts of the world: promises are a recurring theme in Biden’s books; in 2008 it was “Promises to Keep”; in 2018 it was "Dad, Make Me a Promise"; and now that Biden is 84, with a cancer that will prevent him from undertaking a particularly demanding book tour and with a single term behind him – he withdrew late from the re-election race in the summer of 2024, effectively forced out by his own Democratic Party due to an all too visible physical vulnerability: He has not forgiven those who sought to oust him – he asks America to promise to remain exceptional, whilst looking back on his term in office without regretting anything, without apologising for anything, attacking Donald Trump – who will take the subversion of the 6 January 2021 attack on the Capitol to his grave – and calling for reforms and courage. On the withdrawal from Afghanistan, he says: it was the right thing to do. On Ukraine, he says: I have been committed to this since 2014; I did everything possible for our ally; Volodymyr Zelensky was tough and, at times, ungrateful.
This last point, highlighted by the Wall Street Journal review, was taken very badly by Ukraine’s defenders, but it is a single sentence in a narrative in which everything – the world, America’s role, its relationship with its allies – was still in order: Biden speaks of values, of united democracies, of what he saw in Kyiv – its strength and its wounds – and of Russia’s unjustified aggression. That linearity glitters painfully: today, his successor Trump recognises nothing of the world as it has been for eighty years and is tearing it apart, seeking an understanding with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, the enemies of the West. But the missed opportunity by the Biden administration also glitters painfully and burns into the flesh of the Ukrainians, far more than an ill-chosen comment about their president: the doctrine of caution so as not to ‘humiliate’ Putin and his nuclear weapons, the limited support for the Ukrainians in terms of arms and in terms of the use of those arms – to respect ‘red lines’ that applied only to Kyiv’s allies and not to the Russians – prevented a victory (an unmentionable term) on the battlefield for the Ukrainians when it was within their grasp. It is this caution – this having to fight with their hands tied – that the Ukrainians hold against Biden. And then Trump came along, who turned everything on its head, far beyond what anyone could have imagined.
Yesterday, in an editorial, the Wall Street Journal stated that Trump’s diesel deal with Putin had yielded no results, neither on the price of diesel nor on the mid-term elections, but it was clear from the outset that it would not work, to the extent that “it is becoming increasingly difficult not to conclude that Trump’s real objective is to appease Putin”, to curry favour with him, to please him. The U.S. president is attending the summit with the leaders of Russia and China having suffered an electoral defeat that carries weight in the eyes of his fellow diners: they can smell the blood of democracies, which still hold elections and still opt for a change of government. While a Democratic-controlled Congress may certainly rectify certain tragic decisions, such as the suspended civilian aid to the Ukrainians, it will still be Trump who sets the priorities and points of convergence, and his course is quite clear. Yesterday he told journalists that Putin “could be much tougher than this”, whilst no one in America can explain why Starshield has not been working for the past seven days, and everyone else sighs in astonishment: what on earth can this ‘exceptional’ America possibly promise?
More on these topics
Scrive di politica estera, in particolare di politica europea, inglese e americana. Tiene sul Foglio una rubrica, “Cosmopolitics”, che è un esperimento: raccontare la geopolitica come se fosse una storia d'amore - corteggiamenti e separazioni, confessioni e segreti, guerra e pace. Di recente la storia d'amore di cui si è occupata con cadenza settimanale è quella con l'Europa, con la newsletter e la rubrica “EuPorn – Il lato sexy dell'Europa”. Sposata, ha due figli, Anita e Ferrante. @paolapeduzzi
