World
the conflict in Ukraine •
The Ukrainian tragedy: how it is reported, downplayed and normalised in the Italian public debate
Two films and a Z at the University of Bologna. How we came to be indifferent to the victims of aggression, and to downplay the Russian aggression

“Just another ordinary war massacre” – I read Marco Travaglio’s words on the Bucha massacre and think I really shouldn’t be surprised any more. Yet I continue to be surprised and, above all, outraged by the way in which the Ukrainian tragedy is reported, downplayed and, ultimately, normalised in the Italian public debate.
A few days ago, upon arriving at the University of Bologna, the first thing I saw was a ‘Z’ painted at the entrance to DamsLab, the cultural space of the Department of Arts. The letter symbolises the Russian invasion of Ukraine, its violence, destruction and cruelty. I was there for a discussion scheduled to take place after the screening of two Ukrainian films: “Intercepted” (“Gente pacifica” in the original) by Oksana Karpovych and “2000 Meters to Andriivka” by Mstyslav Chernov. Two deeply anti-war works, which depict the war through the eyes of those who wage it, those who suffer it and those forced to fight it.
The DamsLab hall is almost deserted, much like the emptiness that has characterised Italian squares and streets for the past five years whenever it comes to showing solidarity with the Ukrainian people. A solidarity that has never truly become a collective sentiment, widespread participation or a shared awareness. It is as though, faced with the suffering of the Ukrainians, a large part of the country has gradually suspended its capacity for empathy.
The film festival is aimed primarily at young people and students. It is also intended as a gesture of solidarity with their Ukrainian peers – those fighting on the front line and those trying to carry on with their lives in towns and villages under Russian bombardment. Young people of the same age, with the same desires, the same plans, the same expectations for the future; young people from whom the invasion has robbed the chance of an ordinary life – and, for many, life itself. But there are no students in the lecture theatre, nor are there any lecturers. There is emptiness in a place dedicated to knowledge, education and discussion. And a question hangs in the air: what remains of the university as a space for critical thinking, if a war that affects the fate of an entire generation of young people fails even to arouse curiosity, attention or a desire to find out more?
It is not just the deserted auditorium that reveals this indifference, but the vacant stares of the young people who storm in as soon as the film begins. They shout ‘No weapons for Ukraine’, ‘Kyiv must stop bombing the Donbas’, ‘War has no place at university’. Yet this is an anti-war event; the documentaries show what war does to people, to homes, to art, to everyday life. Those who speak out against war would find allies there. But those young people are not interested in watching, in listening to the testimonies, in engaging with the images; they do not want to know what is happening in a country that feels far away to them. They already have their own words, their own slogans, their own certainties and their indifference towards the tragedy of their Ukrainian peers. An indifference fuelled by an Italian public debate in which the Russian aggression is constantly relativised, with the victims reduced to pawns in an ideological dispute, to the point where the massacre can be described with a phrase such as ‘an ordinary war massacre’.
“No room for warmongering rhetoric,” they shout again in the hall, and I feel overwhelmed. I find myself wishing I were elsewhere, even in a place where war is a daily reality. In my mind, therefore, I return to the young Ukrainians I met just a week earlier on the pavements of Kyiv, in the dark and the cold under the air-raid sirens, beer in hand, talking, smiling and toasting life – that sense of normality which is hard-won there every day.
Stepping out of DamsLab, I glance up and read: Piazzetta Pier Paolo Pasolini. The name recalls the poet who was killed by violence in a void of empathy. My thoughts then turn once more to the young Ukrainians, to their ability to keep imagining the future, to their good fortune in believing that freedom is not an abstract word, but a concrete condition of life, an absolute value, something that can be lost and for which it is worth fighting – even dying. I then reflect on the tragedy of so many of their Italian peers who appear to no longer believe in anything. Not only those who storm into the hall, but above all those who do not come, who do not feel the need to learn about the history of a people under attack, to look their war in the face and recognise their desperate desire to continue living freely.
I feel overwhelmed by the emptiness once again.