The trauma experienced by Ukrainian children who grew up under bombardment

The Persian Wars and Herodotus’s Histories, which still have something to teach us today. The ‘fantastic pseudology’ of dictators

16 NOV 26
Last updated: 07:51
Translated by AI
Image of The trauma experienced by Ukrainian children who grew up under bombardment

Photo: AP via LaPresse

By 2027, the ‘War in Ukraine’ will have lasted five years: longer than the First World War. Meanwhile, Ukrainian children are moving from nursery to primary school. They are the first in human history to start school whilst still wearing nappies. Like all children, when they started nursery they began to control their bladder and bowel movements and to go without nappies. As children, however, whilst at nursery they began wetting themselves again at the sound of sirens and, shortly afterwards, of bombs. At what age will they overcome their insomnia and anxiety, and regain control of their bodies? Many will live to see the year 2100: but in what condition? Older girls are not starting their periods. The women who remain meet their husbands on leave from the trenches, but they use contraceptives or have abortions (The Economist, 9 November 2026). Never has a country suffered such a demographic collapse as Ukraine: 52 million inhabitants in 1991, today 27–28 million. It is not genocide; it is depopulation.

Putin’s wolves

Seven months before invading Ukraine, Putin published ‘On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians’, which is still available on the Kremlin’s website. Putin says that reconstructing a thousand years of history is impossible: that is correct. But he also says that it is unnecessary, as one need only refer to ‘history’: this sounds dangerously self-evident and manipulative. In 13 pages, in fact, he traces that ‘unity’ without citing a single source. Both Hitler and Stalin used to repeat ‘It is well known that…’: a self-validating argument (chapters 8 and 9 of my book Paranoia: The Madness That Shapes History). In their day, it was risky to ask for further explanations. And in Moscow, it is still the case. The major treatises on psychiatry (Jaspers, Bleuler) include ‘pseudologia fantastica’ amongst mental disorders: the subject imagines a reality and gradually becomes convinced of it. The unproven ‘superiority of the Germanic race’ convinced Hitler to wage war on everyone – until his enemies became too numerous and destroyed him. Putin claims that NATO wants to encircle him. Putin’s pseudology first convinced the three Baltic states, then Sweden and Finland, to join NATO, thereby truly encircling him. Just like in the fairy tale, if you cry ‘Wolf!’ too often, the wolf will eventually come.

War and Peace today

Is an armistice on the horizon? Ukraine is scraping the bottom of its resources; Russia is in a slightly better position but is losing its ‘capital of goodwill’: at the start of the G20 summit, a group photo could not be taken. Westerners have a ‘historical memory’ that is not heroic, but neither is it non-existent. On 29–30 September 1938, a group photo was taken: the French and British alongside Hitler and Mussolini. (The Czechoslovaks, who bore the brunt of the Munich Agreement, were not present: just as the Ukrainians often find themselves in a similar position today.) On 1 September 1939, however, the Western powers did not offer Hitler another compromise at Poland’s expense: they declared war on him.
Every conflict has a history, with responsibility lying on both sides: this does not mean it is impossible to distinguish between aggressor and victim. Putin’s Russia buys national stability at the expense of international stability: like the pre-war Nazi-Fascist Axis, it is based on a perpetual ‘push forward’ of its borders. Weaker neighbours are incorporated through aggression or reduced to vassals. Before the First World War, Hitler annexed Czechoslovakia and Austria, whilst Mussolini annexed Albania. Lemkin, the expert in supranational law who formulated the crime of genocide and secured its adoption by the United Nations, had already defined Nazi-Fascism as an alliance aimed at subjugating weaker countries: and thus as an act of international crime.
Since Putin came to power, Russia has waged ‘low-intensity’ wars in Transnistria, Georgia, Crimea and the Donbas. Since February 2022, there has been an invasion of Ukraine and an ‘all-out war’. The Russian Federation is the largest remaining colonial empire on Earth, heir to the Tsarist and Soviet empires. But whilst communist Moscow also conquered space, Putin’s Russia depends on China for cars and washing machines. It exports raw materials: it does not promote technical progress, only extractive rents. By prolonging the war, it is consuming ‘romantic cultural capital’, as well as its mineral wealth. Traditionally, Russia brought to mind not only Stalin or Putin, but also Tchaikovsky, Pushkin and Tolstoy. But for how much longer?
Ukraine has far fewer economic resources and military potential than Russia. Is this like Poland facing Nazi Germany in 1939? No: Poland was overrun in a matter of weeks. The Russians, on the other hand, were at the gates of Kyiv in 2022: they were forced to retreat and the war has reached a stalemate. The disparity in military strength is offset by a ‘psychological and moral asymmetry’. The ‘morale’ (of the population) remains high. Those fighting on their own doorstep are highly motivated; the invader is less so, once they realise they have been driven far from home by an ambitious tyrant. One of the street movements in Ukraine that gave rise to a ‘moral force’ was called the ‘Revolution of Dignity’ (2014): an idea that a leading Italian constitutionalist has placed at the heart of modern rights (Stefano Rodotà, La rivoluzione della dignità).

Memory

Technology is advancing at lightning speed, whilst psychology remains unchanged. The ancients used horses; we use jets: yet the human imagination encompasses forms and symbols that remain fairly constant. David and Goliath come from a sacred text: yet everyone, in every age, recognises themselves in David. Even Herodotus – to whom we owe the earliest historical accounts and the very concept of history – weaves it with myth, to preserve images that become powerful archetypes. Our memory is Greek and Jewish: yet – let’s say it quietly, as it sounds ‘Eurocentric’ – it becomes universal. In Herodotus’s *Histories*, the Persian Wars sing a secular epic of the West. Surprisingly similar to Putin’s wars, they began with skirmishes along the dividing line between the empire and its neighbours. If the small neighbour pays tribute, the bully is satisfied. This was the case then for the Greeks of Asia Minor, and today for Lukashenko’s Belarus: better to be vassals than to be killed. Persia was not ‘a’ world empire, but *the* world empire: it encompassed the East, or Asia. Little was known of it: at the top stood an emperor, whose task was to make it ever greater. Upon his death, his son would continue that endeavour. The emperor spoke in terms of continents. One must ‘travel the length of Europe’ (Histories, VI, 43; VII, 8). It was linked to Asia with ropes and hundreds of ships: but huge waves destroyed the floating bridges. Instead of moderating his behaviour, the emperor flew into a rage at the sea and had it flogged 300 times. This psychological pattern, dating back millennia, shows that tyrants unchecked by opposition can escalate their actions to the point of ruining themselves through their own excesses. Herodotus speaks of ‘hubris’, arrogance, which sooner or later punishes those who practise it: a concept so important that it has passed into the English language and is used today to describe the excesses of American politics.

Molòn labé

Throughout the West, schoolchildren learn something about the two Persian Wars. These were fought by the Greeks a full 25 centuries ago. Yet they have formed the bedrock of what we call ‘Western thought’ and ‘Eurocentric culture’. Even more so than the clash between David and Goliath – a more mythical tale confined to the Hebrew holy book – those wars provided the intellectual framework for both what has been termed ‘progress’ and a ‘European superiority complex’: a complex which, in turn, was not unrelated to colonialism and racism. In the greatest direct clash between two continents, the smaller one – with a far inferior army – imposed a continental hierarchy that has endured from 479 BC to the present day.
The Persian horde had marched unhindered from the north as far as Thessaly. There, the mountains began. For an army, the route narrowed. Until they reached Thermopylae: a gorge perhaps a hundred metres wide, blocked by a simple wall. As their oath demanded, King Leonidas’s few Spartans did not retreat: suffering acceptable losses, they had held their position for days. According to Herodotus’s estimate, the Persians numbered in the millions: yet the territory could not have accommodated them all. Their frontline soldiers could not, in any case, form a front any larger than that of the three hundred Spartans: as the Spartans were cutting them to pieces, they had to be constantly replaced. A curious analogy with scenes we saw on television in early 2022, and which we find in videos. Just as had happened with Stalin, even today it is difficult for the Russians to save themselves by surrendering: they are sent forward with no alternatives, and with no regard for casualties; Mother Russia is great partly because she is not stingy with the lives of her children. Another interesting coincidence with antiquity: behind the front lines, the Persians deployed a line of soldiers armed with long whips, who drove back anyone attempting to flee. Russian tanks had also advanced from the north, right up to the outskirts of Kyiv. They had formed a funnel-shaped column and then become bogged down on ordinary roads, where their superiority could not be deployed across a broad front. Remember the assault on Hostomel – Ukraine’s largest airport – when hundreds of Putin’s special forces troops were dropped from helicopters? It was captured, lost, then recaptured by Russian reinforcements, who eventually withdrew. The surrounding area is countryside, but it turned into a swarm of makeshift militiamen. Every civilian was alerted by text message – even my fellow psychoanalysts in their fifties – and could collect a Kalashnikov with ammunition from any public building: schools, local council offices and so on. They distributed 18,000 of them in the blink of an eye. Further south, along the Black Sea, the Russians advanced at breakneck speed, right up to the centre of Mykolaiv. Their command had at its disposal both armoured columns and fantastical propaganda: ‘March straight on; they’ll come down to welcome you with flowers’. Instead, Molotov cocktails—those very simple anti-tank bombs, consisting of a bottle filled with petrol and a fuse—rained down from the tall, old Soviet-era buildings: seeping in from above, the burning fuel overheats the interior of the tank and can even cause the ammunition to explode. Mykolaiv’s vast central square is criss-crossed by an endless line of armoured vehicles, which have been rusting away since early 2022. The local council does not remove them; in wartime, it has other priorities: the children take care of it, having turned the scrap metal into a makeshift playground.
During that spring, by retreating, scattering or deserting, the Russians squandered their superiority. Not only in numbers, but also in weaponry. Their armoured vehicles outnumbered Ukraine’s five to one; they had a naval fleet, whilst Ukraine did not – just as the Persian troops had the advantage, with their hordes of horsemen and archers, whilst the Greeks had only infantry. That is not all. In this unequal struggle, the giant also had at its disposal weapons known as corruption and treachery. Herodotus explains (Histories, VII 213 ff.) that the Greek Ephialtes made contact with the Persians. He knew of a mountain pass that would allow them to take Leonidas by surprise from the rear. Ephialtes did not consider himself at war with the invaders: he merely wished to conclude an economic agreement. Those who compare him to Trump negotiating oil deals with the Russians are not far off the mark.
Plutarch, a more recent and precise historian than Herodotus, has left us with a famous detail, which describes not the military clash, but the psychological one. When the Persian messenger reported: ‘The emperor orders you to hand over your weapons!’, Leonidas is said to have replied: ‘Molòn labé!’, meaning ‘Very well: come and take them!’. At this point, our ‘Greek analogy’ becomes even more striking. At the western end of the Black Sea lies Snake Island: an ancient Greek colony. At the start of the conflict, a number of Ukrainians were stationed there. Given its strategic position, it was approached by two Russian warships which ordered them to surrender. The radio exchange between the adversaries went viral: the Ukrainian operator replied mockingly, just like Leonidas, but using more vulgar language. Subsequently, the Russians landed; there were casualties and prisoners, who were later released in an exchange. Also at the start of the current war, the Ukrainians sank one of those two ships – the immense Moskva, the fleet’s flagship – using a simple drone.
War, then, is not just rubble and blood. It is also a psychological battle, in which one collective soul bleeds whilst the other rejoices. To us Italians, accustomed to banter, this may seem trivial. Among Slavic peoples, speech is usually far more subdued: like a diagram with a steady, low-level flow that requires sudden peaks. From my last trip to Ukraine, I still have the postcard and the commemorative stamps. Every year, they celebrate the anniversary of the encounter between the Moskva and the Ukrainian soldier, who shouts: ‘Russian ship, go f* yourself!’, and in a post-Roman, or post-military, salute, raises his right hand, giving the middle finger.
Whilst the military outcome remains undecided, Ukraine has already won the war of memory, for generations to come.