Trump should learn from Truman’s approach to Korea when it comes to Iran

“War is unpopular, but defeat would be even more so. Three generations of soldiers have fought against these barbarians,” says Senator Tim Sheehy

16 NOV 26
Last updated: 09:12
Translated by AI
Image of Trump should learn from Truman’s approach to Korea when it comes to Iran

Harry S. Truman (photo: ANSA)

“I shall spare you yet another post-election analysis of the drubbing the Republicans suffered last week. However, I feel duty-bound to put forward an unpopular argument in favour of an unpopular decision which, nevertheless, was the right one. Sometimes, a good political strategy translates into bad public policy, and vice versa; which brings me to our current battle against Iran.” So says Senator Tim Sheehy in the Wall Street Journal. “War is unpopular. It always has been. So, when the experts in Washington point this out to us – as if they’d discovered some profound political truth – it almost makes you smile. War is costly, unpredictable and, above all, deadly. It almost always lasts longer than planners anticipate and proves bloodier than experts estimate. Donald Trump is not the first president to suffer the political consequences of an unpopular war. One need only think of George W. Bush and Iraq, Lyndon B. Johnson and Vietnam, or Harry S. Truman and Korea. This last example is the most significant. In 1950, North Korean communist forces invaded South Korea, triggering a conflict that took a devastating human and political toll. Just a few years after the Second World War, Truman – a veteran of the First World War and well aware of the brutality of war – took the unpopular decision to send American troops to Korea to prevent the people of the peninsula from falling under the yoke of tyranny.
The Americans did not want another war. They were tired of fighting abroad and wanted to focus on domestic issues. Does that sound familiar? Truman paid the price in the 1950 mid-term elections: his opponents made significant gains in Congress, whilst public support for the conflict was waning. Yet his resolve in seeing the war through saved half of the Korean peninsula from totalitarianism. America’s refusal to cede Asia to the Soviets consolidated the United States’ position in the Cold War. Although I never knew Truman, it is reasonable to assume that, had he been able to see the thriving democracy and economic powerhouse that South Korea has become—in stark contrast to the brutal communist dictatorship to the north—he would have gladly accepted the political cost of having done the right thing. Our battle against Iran will be no exception. This is not a fight for Israel or for Saudi Arabia; it is a battle for Western civilisation and for the security of American families. The radical Islamist forces that control Iran, together with the groups acting on their behalf in the region, are bent on the destruction of the United States and of Western civilisation as a whole.
They have kidnapped, tortured, killed and maimed thousands of Americans and countless other innocent people around the world. A bolder Iran will once again target the United States. Don’t ask me; ask their Parliament, where slogans such as ‘Death to America’ are the order of the day. War is unpopular, but defeat would be even more so. Three generations of soldiers have fought against these barbarians. We owe it to our country and to the West to ensure there is not a fourth. The time has come to finish the job.”
(Translation by Giulio Meotti)