The Great Ugly-ification

Cities, landscapes, bodies: forget about ‘La Grande Bellezza’. We must rediscover the desire to preserve civilisation and pass it on to future generations
16 NOV 26
Last updated: 09:06 AM
Translated by AI
Image of The Great Ugly-ification

Photo by Danny Greenberg on Unsplash

“We are familiar with Rimbaud’s verse: ‘One evening, I sat Beauty on my lap. – And I found her bitter. And I insulted her’. The rebellious poet’s provocation still presupposed a passionate engagement with beauty. Today, however, it leaves us indifferent.” So writes Eugenie Bastié in Le Figaro. “Beauty has become the privilege of the wealthiest classes (and not always: as Nicolas Gómez Dávila wrote, ‘the only difference between the rich and the poor today is money’: bad taste triumphs even amongst the middle classes) or a destination for tourist pilgrimages. But it has abandoned everyday life. From street furniture to shabby clothing, via shopping districts, wind turbines, tattoos and graffiti, homogenisation and ugliness are gaining ground. “Our everyday environment is being debased, ruined,” observes Jonathan Siksou in Le Saccage de la beauté (Fayard), a brilliant little book that denounces with vigour and wit a major phenomenon of our age, which we might call the ‘great uglification’. The essayist courageously explores every layer of this renunciation of Beauty that affects our eyes, our ears and our souls. The defacement of landscapes: attention to their composition – from the Greek theatre blending into the landscape to the bell tower rising above the fields – gives way to urban planning demands. Wind turbines impose their industrial silhouettes on horizons whose harmony now seems to count for nothing. The decline of cities, simultaneously ‘Third Worldised’ and ‘Americanised’.
The outskirts of urban areas where commercial warehouses, car parks and advertising hoardings spring up. Benches that look like concrete blocks. Graffiti defacing building façades. Smooth, standardised architecture. Old barns, built to house grain or livestock, now serve as backdrops for our weddings. For our celebrations, we seek the kind of beauty we have ceased to demand in everyday life. The deterioration of our bodies. Once upon a time, elegance was not a matter of social class: everyone strove to present themselves in the best possible light. Today, even sloppiness is no longer a matter of social standing: from the billionaire footballer to the factory worker, right through to the collections of luxury brands, a scruffy look has taken hold and the tracksuit has become universal. The fan allowed for the elegance of an age-old flick of the wrist. It has been replaced by the ‘pocket fan’, which spares one from any movement at the cost of a buzzing noise: laziness breeds vulgarity. The deterioration of language, butchered by the constant use of ‘cool’ and ‘super’, has been sifted through the sieve of Globish and the pidgin of the suburbs. This impoverishment is fuelled by the relativism that reigns even within institutions, as demonstrated by the director of the Cité internationale de la langue française in Villers-Cotterêts, who is keen to point out: ‘We are not here to protect or defend the language. We are here to keep the language alive in all its welcoming vitality, because words migrate’. The widespread coarsening of the world has three main causes. First and foremost, the obsession with well-being, which leads us to prioritise the functional, the useful and the efficient over the beautiful.
Jonathan Siksou denounces, with vigour and wit, a significant phenomenon of our age: the renunciation of Beauty that affects our eyes, ears and souls
Already in Dostoevsky’s The Demons, Stepan Trofimovich reduces the dispute to this question: ‘Which is more beautiful, Shakespeare or a pair of boots, Raphael or oil?’. Secondly, egalitarianism, which rejects any hierarchy – even though it is essential for artistic judgement – and favours homogenisation. Finally, there is generalised relativism, which consists of no longer establishing any distinction of value between cultural productions. Aesthetic judgement is reduced to a matter of personal preference. We have abandoned the practice of training the eye to recognise beauty, whilst manuals are now required to decipher the intentions behind certain contemporary works. On the eve of the presidential elections, can the question of beauty become a political issue? The preference for utility and individualistic hedonism are so deeply ingrained in the contemporary mindset (that ‘new psychological regime’ described by Jérôme Fourquet and Ruben Rabinovitch) that it will be difficult to gain acceptance for the sacrifices that a return to beauty would require. ‘How can we reconcile the demands of the passage of time, the right to happiness, and the construction of new motorways and airports with the preservation of landscapes?’, asks Siksou. Everyone wants to preserve the countryside, yet finds motorways very convenient; they appreciate the silhouette of a church, yet want to do their shopping in a hypermarket; they love the façades of historic town centres, yet want their detached house in a soulless housing estate. Let us recall Georges Pompidou, who, in a famous letter, opposed the felling of trees along roads, which had been recommended on safety grounds: “The preservation of trees planted along roads (and I am thinking in particular of the magnificent roads of the Midi lined with plane trees) is essential to the beauty of our country.” Somewhat surprisingly, Marine Le Pen made beauty a political issue in her speech in Orléans: “The elevation of society, as well as of the people who make it up, also depends on promoting a concept that has been forgotten, or even deliberately set aside, and which is nevertheless essential because it speaks to the heart and even to the soul: it is beauty”. Beauty is political. Because it involves our relationship with others. Why do we put flowers in a vase? Why do we take care of our clothes or our home? Because others will see them. Attention to beauty is a form of courtesy. It implies consideration for our fellow human beings. Beauty also nurtures a sense of belonging. We want to protect the places we care about, to pass on the landscapes we love. That is why the fire at Notre-Dame or the one at Limoges Town Hall breaks our hearts: something of our shared world goes up in smoke. How can all this be translated into concrete terms?
If one compares the magnificent secondary schools built during the Third Republic with the concrete and steel buildings, one can understand the students’ anger at the state of the building sector
In England, the philosopher Roger Scruton co-chaired the ‘Building Better, Building Beautiful’ commission, launched in 2018. His work has helped to bring architectural quality, resident participation and tree-lined streets back to the forefront of urban planning discourse. When one compares the magnificent secondary schools built under the Third Republic with some of the concrete and steel buildings designed by modern architects, one can understand the students’ anger towards ‘construction’. “Beauty will not save the world; it is what makes it bearable,” writes Jonathan Siksou. Ugliness has never inspired a desire to care for the world. Making France more beautiful also means restoring the French people’s desire to preserve it and pass it on to future generations.”
(Translation by Mauro Zanon)